Sheep farmer's ex-wife LOSES battle over £80MILLION ‘gift' he gave her for kids… after she divorced him & kept cash
Clive Standish, 72, transferred the multi-million pound gift to his former partner Anna in 2017, with the intention of eventually placing the money in an offshore trust for their children.
Advertisement
5
Clive Standish will keep the majority of an £80million gift he gave his wife
Credit: Central News
5
It was initially decided by the High Court that Anna should receive half of the funds
Credit: Champion News
Clive, a former chief financial officer at UBS, made the decision to move the funds over to his Australian wife to exploit her non-dom status and avoid a crippling 40% inheritance-tax rate.
The former banker believed he would face a bill of about £32 million if he died with the money in his name.
But the pair's 15 year marriage later hit the rocks and divorce proceedings began in 2020 with the assets still in her name.
It was initially decided by the High Court in 2023 that Anna, 57, should receive half of the funds in the settlement.
Advertisement
Read more News
But last year, the Court of Appeal ruled that her share should be reduced from half to £25million.
The amount was judged to fairly represent her contribution to raising the children and looking after their home.
And despite Anna's recent attempts to overturn the decision, the ruling was upheld by the Supreme Court yesterday.
Five judges argued that the sum was not a marital asset because it had not been shared by the couple and Mr Standish had intended it for their children.
Advertisement
Most read in The Sun
Exclusive
Exclusive
The ruling said: 'Tax planning schemes to save tax, involving transfers of assets from one spouse to another, are commonplace.
'The problem for the wife is that there is nothing to show that, over time, the parties were treating the 2017 assets as shared between them.
'Rather, the transfer was in pursuance of a scheme to negate inheritance tax and it was for the benefit exclusively of the children.
'The parties' intention was that the £80 million should not be retained by the wife.'
Advertisement
Fresh twist in Eamonn Holmes & Ruth Langsford's divorce as celeb pair battle over £3.6m home
His wife never established two offshore trusts as he had expected, so Clive was judged to be the sole owner of those assets when divorce proceedings began.
Lord Faulks, representing Anna, tried to argue that the
money had become shared property
after the initial transfer, adding that she had contributed by accepting the gift.
Mr Standish moved to Australia in 1976 and married Anna in December 2005, before the pair moved to the UK five years later.
The couple lived together at Moundsmere Manor, an 18-bedroom mansion near Preston Candover, Hampshire.
Advertisement
Clive's laywer, Tim Bishop KC, explained that in June 2004 his client was worth £57.3 million, while Anna had 'no significant pre-marital wealth'.
The marital assets at the time of the split amounted to £132million, almost all of which had come from Clive's initial fortune.
Mr Bishop added: "The husband made the transfers in March 2017, but the wife failed to transfer the assets into trust by the time the marriage ran into problems in 2019 and then broke down finally in 2020".
Delivering the Supreme Court ruling, Lord Burrows and Lord Stephens agreed with the Court of Appeal's verdict.
Advertisement
5
The pair lived together at Moundsmere Manor in Hampshire
Credit: Champion News Service
5
Clive moved the funds over to his Australian wife to avoid inheritance-tax
Credit: Champion News Service Ltd
They said: "There was no matrimonialisation of the 2017 assets because the transfer was to save tax and it was for the benefit of the children not the wife.
"The 2017 assets were not, therefore, being treated by the husband and wife for any period of time as an asset that was shared between them.
Advertisement
"Transfers of capital assets with the intention of saving tax do not, without some further compelling evidence, establish that the parties are treating the capital asset as shared between them.
"The 2017 assets comprise the husband's pre-marital assets and earnings that the husband made in the years 2004-2007, to which the wife contributed by being the home-maker and child carer during those years.
"In relation to a scheme designed to save tax, under which one spouse transfers an asset to the other spouse, the parties' dealings with the asset do not normally show that the asset is being treated as shared between them.
"Rather, the intention is simply to save tax."
Advertisement
5
Anna's share following the Supreme Court ruling will stay at £25million
Credit: Champion News
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RTÉ News
2 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Adams donates BBC defamation damages to 'good causes'
Gerry Adams has said he has made donations to "good causes" after the BBC paid the former Sinn Féin leader €100,000 in defamation damages. The British broadcaster lost a defamation case earlier this year after Mr Adams took them to court over a 2016 episode of its Spotlight programme and an accompanying online story. They contained an allegation that Mr Adams sanctioned the killing of former Sinn Féin official Denis Donaldson. Mr Adams denied any involvement. In May, a jury at the High Court in Dublin found in his favour and awarded him €100,000, determining that was the meaning of words included in the programme and article. Johnsons Solicitors, which represented Mr Adams in his action, confirmed that the BBC has discharged the order of the court in relation to the compensation to their client. Mr Adams said he intended to donate any damages awarded to good causes. The law firm said donations have been made to "Unicef for the children of Gaza", local GAA organisations, a support group for republican prisoners and their families called An Cumman Cabhrach, to the Irish language sector, to the "homeless and Belfast based youth, mental health and suicide prevention projects" and others.
Irish Examiner
2 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Gerry Adams donates to ‘good causes' after BBC pays €100,000 damages
Gerry Adams has said he has made donations to 'good causes' after the BBC paid the former Sinn Féin president €100,000 in defamation damages. The broadcaster lost a defamation case earlier this year after Mr Adams took them to court over a 2016 episode of its Spotlight programme and an accompanying online story. They contained an allegation that Mr Adams sanctioned the killing of former Sinn Féin official Denis Donaldson. Mr Adams denied any involvement. In May, a jury at the High Court found in his favour and awarded him €100,000 after determining that was the meaning of words included in the programme and article. Johnsons Solicitors, which represented Mr Adams in his action, announced on Tuesday that the BBC has discharged the order of the court in relation to the compensation to their client. A BBC spokesperson said: 'We can confirm the BBC has now paid Gerry Adams €100,000 in damages as required by the court.' Mr Adams said he intended to donate any damages awarded to good causes. The law firm said donations have been made to 'Unicef for the children of Gaza', local GAA organisations, a support group for republican prisoners and their families called An Cumman Cabhrach, to the Irish language sector, to the 'homeless and Belfast based-youth, mental health and suicide prevention projects' and others. The BBC, which was found by the jury not to have acted in good faith nor in a fair and reasonable way, was also ordered to pay the former Sinn Féin leader's legal costs, potentially in the order of millions. However, it is understood the final amount of costs have yet to be determined.
Irish Daily Mirror
3 hours ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Irish mum shot by ex called police five times after being stalked and trapped
Irish woman Eileen Gibbons, who was shot by her ex in an attempted murder-suicide, had called Australian police five times before the incident after he stalked and trapped her, an inquest has heard. Ms Gibbons, from Mayo, was shot in the stomach by Ralph Donald, her ex-partner, in a domestic violence-related attack at a house in Millner in Darwin, Australia in October 2023. The inquest is into the circumstances of the death of Mr Donald, who took his own life in the front yard of his house after shooting his former partner, Ms Gibbons. Ms Gibbons was seriously injured in the attack but survived. The coroner heard that in the six months leading up to the incident, police were called five times in response to reports Donald was stalking her, locking her inside the house and preventing her from leaving. Eileen Gibbons, who was shot and seriously injured in Darwin, Australia, pictured in her hospital bed with her daughter Silvia as she is visited by her mum Eileen and aunt Marian Langan from Castlebar (Image: Supplied) "Things were getting out of hand and I was crying out to the police," she said. Another report was made by Donald himself, and his brother also made one when an argument broke out between the couple. The court heard Northern Territory police officers followed up on the calls a number of times and offered further referral support, but failed to see the warning signs. One police officer who assisted Ms Gibbons in 2023, who cannot be named due to a suppression order, testified that while she told him about Donald's aggressive and controlling behaviour, he did not identify any immediate red flags. He said because there was no history of physical violence, a domestic violence order was not applicable at the time. However, the officer told the court that after undertaking Prevent, Assist, Respond training (PARt) - an educational programme that discusses coercive control - he had a better understanding of the signs and in hindsight would have done things differently. The inquest heard in the weeks before the tragedy, the 35-year-old had been "spiralling" over his recent break-up with Ms Gibbons and feeling "isolated and distressed". Ms Gibbons said that although Donald was a heavy drinker with anger issues and had become increasingly controlling and "toxic" — including locking her in the house — he had "never laid a hand on her" and she did not believe he ever would. On Monday, the inquest heard that on the evening of October 3, 2023, while Ms Gibbons was visiting her former partner's house to retrieve items for their 11-month-old daughter, Donald walked into the front yard with one of his three rifles and shot Ms Gibbons in the stomach, before taking his own life. "He got approximately two metres from her and said, 'do you want to die?' while holding up the firearm," Dr Dwyer said. She said Ms Gibbons, fearing for her life, had turned to run away, but fell to the ground. Donald's mother had been watering plants in the garden and his brother Charles, on hearing the gunshot, ran out. Charles, Donald's brother, stood between him and Eileen Gibbons during the shooting incident. Ms Gibbons gave evidence on the first day of the inquest via video link from Ireland. She moved to Australia in her 20s and in 2019, while she was working as a case worker at the Salvation Army, Mr Donald joined her programme to tackle his alcohol problem. Ms Gibbons told the court the attraction was immediate and she quickly requested to be taken off his case. Soon after she left the job, they started a relationship. Ms Gibbons told the court there had been red flags from the beginning, but after their baby was born in 2022, the relationship took a turn. "It was toxic," she said. "He was quite stressed… he didn't have coping skills." The coroner heard Donald was working as a tyre fitter and was beginning an apprenticeship at the time of his death. However, Ms Gibbons said the couple were under significant financial stress, with their mortgage having risen three times, and that things "really escalated in the last year". The inquest is expected to last five days. Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest news from the Irish Mirror direct to your inbox: Sign up here . The Irish Mirror's Crime Writers Michael O'Toole and Paul Healy are writing a new weekly newsletter called Crime Ireland. Click here to sign up and get it delivered to your inbox every week
