logo
EXCLUSIVE Shocking footage shows Saudi police beat women and girls inside secret prisons where families send 'disobedient' females to be locked away and punished for YEARS to break their spirit

EXCLUSIVE Shocking footage shows Saudi police beat women and girls inside secret prisons where families send 'disobedient' females to be locked away and punished for YEARS to break their spirit

Daily Mail​29-05-2025
Shocking footage obtained by MailOnline shows Saudi police beating women detained inside secretive facilities where families send 'disobedient' women and girls to be punished.
Women seen in the clip were said to be staging a peaceful sit-in protest over poor living conditions at their so-called 'care home' in Khamis Mushair, in Asir Province.
Security and police officers at the Social Education Home for Girls are seen rushing in and hitting the woman; some as they lay helpless on the ground.
Women were seen being dragged by their hair, beaten with belts and sticks, and subjected to other forms of physical abuse.
The video, which caused outrage among rights activists in Saudi Arabia when it first circulated in 2022, re-emerged as former detainees bravely spoke out about their experiences held in 'Dar al-Reaya' facilities across the country.
Dr Maryam Aldossari, a Saudi academic at Royal Holloway, University of London, told MailOnline that despite recent reforms, many women remain held in these de facto prisons, unable to leave until a male guardian permits them.
She cited examples of women enduring horrifying conditions inside the facilities, some reportedly even moved to take their own lives due to alleged abuse.
'It still exists,' she warned. 'We still know people who are there and God knows when they will leave.
'They completely cut them [off]. There are cameras everywhere. If you misbehave you must go to these small individual rooms, you are separated.
'Anything can be considered as a violation of women's rights.'
Dr Aldossari, who left Saudi Arabia in 2008 to study and work in the UK, today works with Al Qst (ALQST), a human rights organisation that documents and promotes human rights in Saudi Arabia.
'What we do hear - it's such a dark time in Saudi Arabia. This is becoming a police state,' she said. 'People are scared.'
After the harrowing video first emerged, the local authority said it was ordering an investigation into the incident.
It did not condemn the security officers for the 'blatant and brutal assault on the women', Al Qst noted, assessing that any investigation would 'lack all credibility'.
They described violence at the hands of the authorities as a 'hallmark' of the Saudi prison system.
'In this respect, care homes for young women and girls (even if not officially for female criminals) and juvenile detention centres are no different from prisons, where violence mostly takes the form of ill-treatment, physical assaults and sexual harassment.'
A spokesperson for the Saudi government recently denied that the care homes were detention centres, claiming 'women are free to leave at any time' and can leave without permission from a guardian or family member.
They also said that 'any allegation of abuse is taken seriously and subject to thorough investigation'.
Dr Aldossari dismissed the claims. 'The regime lie and lie and lie and lie,' she said.
She maintained that women as young as 13 could be sent to a facility for 'disobedience' and held until a male guardian allows them to leave.
Despite recent reforms nominally strengthening women's rights, she said, there is no 'trial' to be sent to a facility that is not officially a prison, there is no process of appeal, and there is no consistent interpretation of the law.
'A woman might be legally allowed to apply for her own passport because of the reforms,' she explained, referring to the Saudi Personal Status Law (PSL), codified in 2022 and supplemented this year.
'But her male guardian can still prevent her from travelling by filing a case of disobedience - and they didn't even bother to define what disobedience means,' she said.
'So anyone and every male says "my wife or my daughter" is being disobedient and then all those rights will go.'
'It [has become] like a tool of the Saudi regime to control women,' she added. 'The reason could be anything. You could, for example, run away from your home because you are facing abuse, then you will be arrested by police.
'It could be the accusation of behaviour that doesn't align with norms. For example, being seen with a man who's not your husband. It could be because your family thought you're out of control or even being a feminist.'
The care homes have existed since the 1960s, initially presented as a rehabilitative 'shelter' for women accused or convicted of certain crimes. They are said to hold women between the ages of 7 and 30.
A Saudi government spokesperson told The Guardian: 'Women are free to leave at any time, whether to attend school, work, or other personal activities, and may exit permanently whenever they choose with no need of approval from a guardian or family member.'
But campaigners contest the claims, citing women who have experienced the facilities first-hand.
If a male guardian is not willing or available to release them, the authorities will move them to a similar 'guest' facility - from which they will also require the consent of a male guardian or relative to leave.
Dr Aldossari explained that under the 'ridiculous' system in Saudi Arabia, this role is 'inherited'. If a woman's husband or father is unavailable, her son could end up responsible for his mother.
In some horrifying cases, women have allegedly been sent to facilities after defying the men sexually abusing them at home.
'She ends up in the situation that the abuser has to release her,' she said.
Women have shared harrowing testimonies of being sent to the facilities as punishment for not 'obeying' sexual abuse at home, and then flogged or locked away in isolation until they 'reconcile' with their abusers.
Sarah Al-Yahia, campaigning to abolish the homes, told the Guardian that her father had threatened to send her to one of the homes as a child 'if I didn't obey his sexual abuse'.
'If you are sexually abused or get pregnant by your brother or father you are the one sent to Dar al-Re'aya to protect the family's reputation,' she explained.
Women may have to make the impossible choice between enduring abuse at home and the gruelling conditions inside the camps, she explained.
Some have reportedly been killed by abusive relatives soon after release.
One woman told the Guardian that she was taken to Dar al-Re'aya after complaining about her father and brothers.
She was then allegedly abused at the institution and accused of bringing shame upon her family for her social media posts about women's rights.
She was held until her father agreed she could be released, despite his being her alleged abuser, the outlet reports.
While testimonies from the facilities remain underreported, some women have bravely spoken out over the years.
In a 2021 ALQST report, women described being made to stand for six hours at a time by way of punishment for disobedience.
One former inmate told MBC in 2018 that she and others were made to eat their own vomit after throwing up bad food.
'They let men in to hit us. Sometimes the girls and kids face sexual harassment, but if they talk, no one listens.'
In other cases, local media has documented reports of suicide at the centres, blamed on the conditions inside.
In 2015, a woman was found to have hanged herself from the ceiling of her room at one of the shelters, writing in a note: 'I decided to die to escape hell.'
An inmate at the Makkah facility had said earlier: 'Dying is more merciful than living in the shelter.'
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

'No one should be subjected to racist abuse,' Meta tells Sky News - five days after England star Jess Carter quit social media
'No one should be subjected to racist abuse,' Meta tells Sky News - five days after England star Jess Carter quit social media

Sky News

timean hour ago

  • Sky News

'No one should be subjected to racist abuse,' Meta tells Sky News - five days after England star Jess Carter quit social media

Instagram's owners have taken five days to respond publicly to racism suffered by England star Jess Carter - and to raise issues about a Sky News interview with the head of the Football Association about the abuse. While the FA and police had been in operational discussions with social media platforms, FA chief executive Mark Bullingham told Sky News on Thursday he had received no direct contact and said they had "avoided responsibility". In a statement breaking its silence, Meta told Sky News: "We're surprised to read these comments since we have been working directly with the FA and UEFA both before and during this tournament." 3:27 Carter went public on Sunday with the online hate she has been facing throughout England's defence of the European Championship title - removing herself from social media. Sky News immediately asked Instagram owner Meta for comment, with follow-ups including DMs to Instagram head Adam Mosseri. The response from Meta's Press Office only came late on Friday to ask us to update our coverage of Thursday's interview with Mr Bullingham "ASAP" as "it's really important in the lead up to Sunday's game that your readers know we're firmly taking action on this matter". We first asked Meta for comment before we aired an interview with Kick It Out chairman Sanjay Bhandari, who said social media companies have "actually gone backwards over the last four or five years, not forwards. It's got worse on social media, not better". There was no response at the time to explain what Meta was doing - only to counter comments from the FA at the end of the week. "No one should be subjected to racist abuse and we remove this content when we find it," Meta asked us to attribute to an unnamed spokesperson. "We're surprised to read these comments [from Mr Bullingham] since we have been working directly with the FA and UEFA both before and during this tournament. "We have proactively removed a number of violating comments and taken action against accounts which break our rules. "We've also developed several tools to help protect people from having to see abuse, including Hidden Words which filters offensive comments and DMs. "No one thing will stop racist behaviour overnight, but we'll continue working to protect our community from abuse and cooperate with police investigations." Two hours after sending that, there was no response to follow-up requests to discuss the issues raised.

Donald Trump says 'great to be in Scotland' as he arrives for five-day visit
Donald Trump says 'great to be in Scotland' as he arrives for five-day visit

BBC News

time2 hours ago

  • BBC News

Donald Trump says 'great to be in Scotland' as he arrives for five-day visit

Update: Date: 20:54 BST Title: Protesters wait for Trump Content: David CowanHome Affairs Correspondent, BBC Scotland A handful of protesters are mixing with the media outside Trump Turnberry, waiting for the arrival of the president. One says he's driven four and a half miles from Cheshire to make his point about climate change. Another holds a sign which refers to Donald Trump's felony conviction. They've exchanged words with a Scottish man who's come along, wearing a Make America Great Again baseball cap. Update: Date: 20:47 BST Title: Starmer is 'slightly more liberal than I am' - Trump Content: "I like your prime minister, he is slightly more liberal than I am," Trump tells reporters on the runway at Prestwick Airport. He then praises the US-UK trade deal which he says is a "good deal for the UK". Update: Date: 20:43 BST Title: It's great to be in Scotland, Trump tells reporters Content: "It's great to be in Scotland," Trump tells reporters after he disembarks from Air Force One in Scotland. He says he will meet the UK prime minister tomorrow, adding: "We're going to do some great things". Update: Date: 20:40 BST Title: Trump waves to crowds at Glasgow's Prestwick Airport Content: President Trump waves as he disembarks Air Force One for his five-day trip to Scotland. Trump is set to open new golf course and meet UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer and Scotland's First Minister John Swinney during his visit. Update: Date: 20:38 BST Title: Will Trump speak to the media? Content: Chris ClementsReporting from Glasgow Prestwick Airport Air Force One has touched down and the engines are deafening. When the US president arrives, he will be greeted by Ian Murray MP, Secretary of State for Scotland, and the Honourable Warren Stephens, US ambassador to the Court of St James. Will he speak to the media? Perhaps. After that, he will leave the airfield in the waiting motorcade. You can see the Beast there - his presidential vehicle that has windows that are five inches thick. Update: Date: 20:30 BST Title: Plane-spotters say 'I'm here for the plane, not Trump' Content: Ben PhilipReporting from Prestwick Airport Abbie, Kevin and Cooper at Glasgow Prestwick Airport Hundreds of plane-spotters are on a grassy bank overlooking the runway, here to catch a glimpse of Air Force One. Carrie-Ann, 47, has travelled from Fife with her son to be here and has come prepared. She said: "We have snacks and a book. We've got rolls, crisps, sweets, juice, water - you name it, it's in the bag. Others have come from ever further afield. Sam Sharp, 24, from Newcastle is weighed down by a metre-long camera lens - putting our broadcast equipment to shame - although he admits it's "a bit overkill". Speaking of the presidential plane, he said: "It is the queen of the skies. Everyone just knows Air Force One. It's a rare chance to see such a beautiful aircraft. Further along the bank, Abbie, Kevin and Cooper are waiting patiently with their cameras on a picnic blanket. Asked about his thoughts of Donald Trump's visit, Kevin said: "Everyone has their different political views. I'm not a fan myself, but I think everyone is entitled to their own opinion. I'm just here for the plane, not him." Update: Date: 20:28 BST Title: Air Force One touches down in Scotland Content: Air Force One has just landed on the runway at Glasgow Prestwick Airport, after a short delay. Update: Date: 20:26 BST Title: Crowds gather outside airport to catch glimpse of Trump arrival Content: Morgan SpenceReporting from Glasgow Prestwick Airport Like him or loath him, thousands of people have now gathered at Glasgow Prestwick Airport to catch a glimpse of Donald Trump's arrival. Crowds are still streaming into a viewing area, just outside the perimeter fence. Update: Date: 20:25 BST Title: Who is travelling with Trump? Content: Bernd Debusmann JrReporting from the White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt is among those traveling with Trump on his trip. We have a list of those travelling with President Trump on his trip to Scotland. Among them are the White House Press Secretary, Karoline Leavitt and Stephen Miller, the White House Deputy Chief of Staff who is now considered among the most influential and powerful members of Trump's team. Also included are Josh Fisher, the head of the White House Office of Administration, as well as Robert Gabriel, Assistant to the President for Policy. Walt Nauta, the longtime aide to Trump who was embroiled in Trump's court case over classified documents at Mar-a-Lago, is also along for the ride, as is staff secretary Will Scharf. This is, for the most part, a standard group for most of President Trump's trips - essentially, the staff that ensure that the President can continue to do his job effectively while away from the White House. The one notable addition for this trip is Monica Crowley, who serves as ambassador and chief-of-protocol, who, as part of her job, manages diplomatic protocol and etiquette. Update: Date: 20:23 BST Title: What's it like on Air Force One? Content: Anthony ZurcherNorth America correspondent Donald Trump is on his way to Scotland aboard Air Force One, the modified Boeing 747 that serves as the American presidential aircraft. Unlike most transatlantic commercial travellers, Trump is flying during the day, so he won't have to worry about catching some sleep while en route (although his onboard suite does include a bed). He will spend Friday night in a bed he owns at Trump Turnberry. Air Force One is designed to be a mobile command post for the president no matter where he is – but the importance of this is heightened when he is travelling abroad and has less access to secure communications. The president is making the trip with a pool of White House reporters, who board with lower-level administration staff through a door at the back of the aircraft. It's not a bad way to travel – with padded seats and in-flight meal service roughly comparable to a business-class accommodations on a domestic US flight. Trump frequently comes back to chat with journalists during long flights, so keep an eye out for reports of what he may say about his weekend golf plans – or his scheduled meeting with British Prime Minister Keir Starmer on Monday. Update: Date: 20:20 BST Title: Donald Trump about to touch down in Scotland Content: Chris ClementsReporting from Ayrshire Good evening from the runway at Glasgow Prestwick Airport. Ground staff here are preparing for the US president's arrival, with a small number of media already in position. Air Force One has been delayed but Donald Trump is expected shortly. Update: Date: 20:08 BST Title: Trump cheerful as he left DC for a golf-heavy trip Content: Bernd Debusmann JrReporting from the White House As he left for Scotland, Trump spoke to reporters in Washington about a number of topics ranging from the economy and interest rates, to the war in Gaza. He only briefly mentioned his trip but appeared to be in a jovial mood, joking with reporters who were gathered on the South Lawn before his helicopter took off to take him to his waiting plane. "Are you going? You've got to get moving," he told a journalist, pointing at the crowd. "It's going to be a good one." Update: Date: 19:56 BST Title: Trump to tour his Scottish assets on unusual UK visit Content: Trump is in Scotland to visit his two golf resorts, as well as opening a new 18-hole course at the Menie resort in Aberdeenshire. The trip is exceptional as US presidents rarely promote their personal interests so publicly while in office. After landing in Scotland, he will head for Trump Turnberry in Ayrshire and is expected to spend the weekend away from the press. On Sunday, he is due to meet EU chief Ursula von der Leyen, with trade talks on the agenda - and on Monday, the president will head to Trump International Links Aberdeen accompanied by Keir Starmer. On his final day in Scotland, Trump is due to open a new 18-hole course at the Aberdeenshire site. Update: Date: 19:52 BST Title: A golf getaway for Trump as he heads to Scotland Content: Imogen JamesLive reporter The US president is currently on his way to Scotland, where he will spend the weekend golfing at his two luxury resorts - one in Aberdeenshire, the other in Ayrshire. It's the first time he's visited the country since 2023, and he's often spoken of his fondness for it, given his mother was born there. However, he might not receive a particularly warm welcome, with more than 1,500 extra police drafted in with protests expected. This is largely a private trip but Trump is expected to meet UK Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer, Scottish First Minister John Swinney and European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen while he is there. Air Force One will soon be touching down at Glasgow Prestwick Airport. We'll be bringing you updates if Trump speaks when he lands.

Turnberry turned into ‘American prison' for Trump's arrival
Turnberry turned into ‘American prison' for Trump's arrival

Telegraph

time2 hours ago

  • Telegraph

Turnberry turned into ‘American prison' for Trump's arrival

Turnberry resort has been transformed into an 'American prison', complete with high fencing and 'sniper towers', for Donald Trump's visit. The US president touched down in Scotland on Friday evening for a few days of golf at his resort in Ayrshire ahead of a trip to Aberdeen next week. Campaign groups have vowed to welcome Mr Trump with a 'festival of resistance', aiming to make their voice heard on issues from climate change to the plight of Palestinians. Gavin Scott, an independent councillor for Girvan and South Carrick, said police had gone above and beyond to deter potential disruption. He told The Telegraph: 'A local resident likened the high fencing and sniper tower surrounding the golf course to an American prison, finding the view quite disturbing and intimidating with a large armed police presence.' Trump Turnberry has become a lightning rod for protest groups targeting the president this year. Palestine Action daubed the resort's white buildings in red paint in March and Greenpeace created a sand portrait of Mr Trump on the beach by the course beside a message reading: 'Time to fight the billionaire takeover'. Earlier this week, protesters sabotaged a sign at Mr Trump's golf course in Aberdeenshire with a placard that claimed the luxury resort was 'twinned with Epstein Island'. The stunt was staged by the political campaign group Everyone Hates Elon as the US president faces renewed scrutiny over his past links to Jeffrey Epstein, the financier and sex offender who died in 2024. On Monday, White House communications director Stephen Cheung said Trump once kicked Epstein out of his club for being a 'creep' and called allegations about him 'recycled, old fake news'. Mr Trump's visit to the UK will include hosting Sir Keir Starmer for dinner before travelling to the 'oil capital of Europe' Aberdeen for 'lunches' and opening the new golf course at his resort at Menie. Mr Trump told reporters at the White House that 'Turnberry is rated the number one golf course in the world'. 'I'm going to see it for the first time in years,' he said, adding: 'It's the best resort in the world, I think. It's one of the greatest courses.' Mr Scott said there had been murmurs of discontent around the villages over 'who's footing the bill' for the extra security. 'To ask Police Scotland or our own government to pay for an already undermanned police force is quite ridiculous and grossly unfair,' he said. Cllr Alec Clark, deputy leader of South Ayrshire Council, said there would always be 'associated costs for any world leaders visit'. 'This is a democracy and people are entitled to make their feelings known,' he told The Telegraph. Emma Bond, Asst Chief Constable, encouraged protest groups to discuss their plans with police. She said: 'As you can imagine, it is a large-scale, complex operation, but actually that's something that Police Scotland is immensely experienced at doing.' The policing plan involves local, national and specialist officers from Police Scotland as well as other forces. She said: 'The key very much is to make sure the president of the United States can come, enjoy a peaceful and safe visit to Scotland and ensure Police Scotland is able to maintain delivery of services to the rest of the community within Scotland over the period of his visit.' Despite the protests, Mr Scott said most residents were supportive of Mr Trump. 'The feeling on the ground here in Girvan and surrounding villages is mainly of excitement and quite happy about President Trump's visit,' he said, pointing out that Mr Trump had refurbished the hotel and tended to the world famous course. 'Something tells me he is using his round to help persuade the R&A to return 'The Open' to Turnberry, we all wish him well on that one, what an achievement that would be!' The Ailsa course at Turnberry, sporting views of the granite craig in the Firth of Clyde and across to the Isle of Arran and the Mull of Kintyre, has hosted the Open championship four times. The course last hosted the British golf tournament in 2009 and Mr Trump is thought to be eyeing up one of the next free slots from 2028 onwards. 'No friend of Scotland' Campaign groups will gather by the William Wallace Statue at Union Terrace in Aberdeen, as well as outside the US consulate in Edinburgh on Saturday. Speaking ahead of the protests, Alena Ivanova, a campaigner with the Stop Trump Coalition said: 'Donald Trump may shake hands with our leaders, but he's no friend of Scotland. 'We, the people of Scotland, see the damage he has done – to democracy and working people in the US, to the global efforts to tackle the climate crisis, to the very principles of justice and humanity.' She added: 'As he dreams of rivieras built on the bones of Palestinians, we demand an end to the genocide. 'Trump is not welcome because he represents all that Scottish people reject.' Liz Murray, head of Scottish campaigns at Global Justice Now who are a part of the Stop Trump Coalition added: 'Trump is bullying his way around the world, slapping tariffs on countries, or threatening to – and that includes us here. 'He's using these threats to impose the interests of his oligarch friends on us – and in particular the Big Tech barons who have his ear – when actually governments should be taxing them and reining in their power. 'It's vital that both Keir Starmer and John Swinney stand up to him – because if they give him an inch on this or anything else he'll take a mile.'

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store