logo
Final call on three-language policy in Maharashtra schools after talks with all stakeholders, says Chief Minister

Final call on three-language policy in Maharashtra schools after talks with all stakeholders, says Chief Minister

The Hindu5 hours ago

Maharashtra Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis announced on Monday night that a final decision on implementing the three-language formula in schools in the State will be taken only after discussions with writers, language experts, political leaders, and all other stakeholders concerned.
The move comes amid widespread opposition to the government's decision to introduce Hindi as a third language in schools.
The announcement was made after a meeting on the three-language formula at the CM's residence. It was attended by Deputy CM Eknath Shinde, School Education Minister Dada Bhuse, Minister of State Pankaj Bhoir, and Education Department officials.
According to a press statement issued by the government, the leaders deliberated on the issue and decided to present the position of all stakeholders on the language policy.
The government has decided to prepare a detailed presentation covering all options, with a specific focus on ensuring that Marathi students do not suffer academic losses in relation to the Academic Bank of Credits, a digital platform envisioned in the National Education Policy (NEP), 2020. To this end, a presentation and consultation process will be conducted with all stakeholders, including Marathi language scholars, literary figures, and political leaders, according to the statement.
The decision to revisit the three-language formula comes after opposition from various quarters, including Marathi literary figures, who had strongly opposed the government's decision to introduce Hindi as a third language for students from Classes 1 to 5 in schools across the State.
Facing backlash
The Maharashtra government has faced backlash twice over its language policy. Initially, it issued a resolution on April 16 making Hindi a mandatory third language in Marathi and English medium schools. Following criticism, the government issued an amended GR, revising the policy to make Hindi the 'generally' third language option, while allowing schools to teach other Indian languages if at least 20 students opted for it.
However, civil societies have strongly opposed the decision. Marathi writer Hemant Divate on Sunday announced the return of the Kavi Keshavsut Puraskar he had received from the government as a mark of protest. 'I am returning the Maharashtra government award received for my poetry collection 'Paranoia'. I will only withdraw my decision if the government withdraws the decision,' he said on X.
Around 18 organisations under the Marathi Abhyas Kendra also collectively wrote to the Chief Minister, urging him to maintain a two-language policy instead of implementing the three-language model. They argued that the NEP does not mandate introducing the language policy from the beginning.
'Despite such strong opposition from various civil societies, child protection and linguistic experts, the government is pushing its own agenda. In fact, instead of withdrawing the original resolution, the government took a different approach, which is absurd. The government has done no scholarly or scientific analysis to implement such a decision,' Dr. Deepak Pawar, an Assistant Professor at the University of Mumbai, who is representing the platform, said.
Dr. Pawar sternly warned that if the government does not listen to their demands, they have planned various stages of protest, including a signature campaign for the support of parents, a campaign for the support of dignitaries, a meme competition, burning of amended GR and other documents, a public meeting, and a sit-in protest.
Signature campaign
The Raj Thackeray-led Maharashtra Navnirman Sena (MNS) has been spearheading protests against the move. On Monday, MNS leader Sandeep Deshpande led a signature campaign in Dadar, collecting signatures from parents opposed to the decision.
The MNS also called the State government 'impotent' over its handling of the language policy, with Mr. Deshpande criticising the government for not using Marathi banners at the National Conference of Estimates Committees of Parliament and State/UT Legislative Bodies held at Vidhan Bhavan in Mumbai. 'If everyone in the government is incapable, then what can Marathi people do? It is the misfortune of Marathi people and Maharashtra that the government's love for Hindi remains unexplained,' he said.
Mr. Deshpande pointed out that the banners for the event were only in Hindi and English, and questioned why Marathi was not included despite the conference being held in Maharashtra. 'Despite being a national conference, it has been held in Maharashtra, Marathi is a must. So, why no banners in Marathi and who will honour Marathi?' he asked.
CM's clarification
Maharashtra Deputy Chief Minister Eknath Shinde clarified that it was a Lok Sabha Secretariat event, which is why the banners were in Hindi and English. He explained that if the State government had organised the event, the banners would have been in Marathi.
During the signature campaign, parents expressed their opposition to the decision, with one parent saying, 'The government making Hindi optional is just a game of words. Without saying mandatory, they are imposing a third language. When we were kids, we also had two languages, and we grew up knowing Hindi without studying it. So, I don't think students should be burdened unnecessarily. This is the only way of putting down Marathi.'
The MNS has appealed to Marathi-speaking people to come out on the streets and protest against the decision.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Sanskrit got lion's share of language promotion funds: RTI data
Sanskrit got lion's share of language promotion funds: RTI data

Hindustan Times

timean hour ago

  • Hindustan Times

Sanskrit got lion's share of language promotion funds: RTI data

The central government spent ₹ 2532.59 crore on the promotion of Sanskrit between 2014-15 and 2024-25, 17 times the combined spending of ₹ 147.56 crore on the other five classical Indian languages –– Tamil, Telugu, Kannada, Malayalam and Odia, according to the data obtained by Hindustan Times through a Right to Information (RTI) application and from public records. Government spent ₹ 2532.59 crore on the promotion of Sanskrit between 2014-15 and 2024-25 (HT Photo) That works out to ₹ 230.24 crore every year (on average) for Sanskrit and ₹ 13.41 crore every year for the other five. Tamil, the highest-funded among the five classical Indian languages, received less than 5% of Sanskrit's total funding, Kannada and Telugu each received less than 0.5%, and Odia and Malayalam each received under 0.2% of Sanskrit's total allocation. Tamil, the first language to be designated as 'a 'classical' language in 2004 received ₹ 113.48 crore under Grants for Promotion of Indian Languages (GPIL) scheme, 22 times less than the amount spent on promotion of Sanskrit which was given the same status in 2005. The combined funding of the remaining four Kannada, Telugu, Malayalam, and Odia which received classical language status between 2008 and 2014, was ₹ 34.08 crore. To be sure, the spending on Sanskrit exceeded that on Urdu, Hindi, and Sindhi too (although none of these is recognised as a classical language). The combined funding for Hindi, Urdu and Sindhi between 2014-15 and 2024-25 was ₹ 1,317.96 crore, roughly 52.04% of the amount spent on Sanskrit. In this period, Urdu individually received ₹ 837.94 crore, Hindi, ₹ 426.99 crore, and Sindhi, ₹ 53.03 crore. According to the 2011 census, Tamil, Telugu, Malayalam, Odia, and Kannada speakers together accounted for 21.99% of India's total population of 1.2 billion. The proportion of Sanskrit speakers was negligible. Hindi speakers (those who listed the language as their mother tongue) accounted for 43.63%, and Urdu speakers, 4.19%. In March, Tamil Nadu chief minister MK Stalin condemned the promotion of Sanskrit and Hindi in the state while calling for practical measures to support Tamil culture. '...Rather than installing Sengol in Parliament, uninstall Hindi from Union Government offices in Tamil Nadu. Instead of hollow praise, make Tamil an official language on par with Hindi and allot more funds for Tamil than a dead language like Sanskrit,' he said. In October 2024 five more languages , Marathi, Pali, Prakrit, Assamese, and Bengali were recognized as classical languages through a Gazette notification, taking the total number of such languages to 11. The details of the funds used to promote these languages were not immediately available. 'Classical languages are regarded as the custodians of India's ancient and profound cultural legacy, preserving the rich history, literature, and traditions of their respective communities. By conferring this status, the government seeks to honour and protect the linguistic milestones of Bharat's diverse cultural landscape, ensuring that future generations can access and appreciate the deep historical roots of these languages,' the central government said in a statement in October 2024. While the ministry of home affairs (MHA) initially granted classical status to Tamil and Sanskrit in 2004 and 2005 respectively, the ministry of culture took over the responsibility for further implementations and future recognition of classical languages. The ministry of education (MoE) is responsible for promotion of these languages through different councils, institutes and universities. MoE also supports promotion of scheduled languages such as Hindi, Urdu and Sindhi. In the union budget 2025-26, the government has announced Bharatiya Bhasha Pustak Scheme (BBPS) to provide textbooks being taught at every level of school and higher education in 22 Indian languages in digital form. There are 22 scheduled languages in India including 9 classical languages. Pali and Prakrit are the only two classical languages which are not there in the list of scheduled languages. HT reached out to The Ministry of Education but did not receive a response till Monday evening. Professor Syed Imtiaz Hasnain, retired professor of sociolinguistics, department of linguistics at Aligarh Muslim University (AMU) said 'Sanskrit is largely used for religious purposes but it occupies a sanctified place in the larger imagination of common masses,' adding that this could be one reason for the 'disproportionate funding.' The government promotes Sanskrit Language through three Central Sanskrit Universities (CSU) established by Central Sanskrit Universities Act, 2020 and located in New Delhi and Tirupati by providing funds to them for teaching and research in Sanskrit Language leading to award of degree, diploma, certificate to students. The Central Institute of Indian Languages (CIIL), Mysuru works for the promotion of all Indian languages including four classical languages – Kannada, Telugu, Malayalam and Odia. CIIL with its seven regional language centres across the country also helps in implementation of the Union government's language policy and conducts training programmes for school teachers of different languages.

‘Final decision on 3 languages only after wide-ranging talks'
‘Final decision on 3 languages only after wide-ranging talks'

Time of India

time2 hours ago

  • Time of India

‘Final decision on 3 languages only after wide-ranging talks'

Mumbai: Bowing to growing criticism of its decision to introduce Hindi as the optional third language in schools from class 1, chief minister Devendra Fadnavis on Monday said a final decision regarding the three-language formula would be made only after discussions with literary figures, language experts, political leaders, and all other relevant parties. On Sunday poet Hemant Divate announced he was returning his state award to protest against the imposition of Hindi from classes 1 to 5 in Marathi and English medium schools. The MNS has been holding protests against the school education dept's revised order on introducing Hindi as a third language from class I onwards. Though the govt rolled back its decision to make Hindi mandatory in primary school, the govt resolution issued on June 17 states that while a third language is mandatory, Hindi will no longer be compulsory but in general it will be the third language for classes 1-5 in Marathi and English medium schools. It allowed schools or parents to choose an alternative Indian language and said there will be a teacher for the opted language if at least 20 students in a class go for it. On Monday night a meeting on the three-language formula was held at the CM's official residence Varsha. Dy CM Eknath Shinde, school education minister Dada Bhuse, minister of state Pankaj Bhoyar, and officials from the education department were present for the meeting. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like 마지막으로 2025년 최고의 좀비 게임을 무료로 즐기세요 경복의 바다 게임 플레이 Undo A CMO press release stated, "After an extensive discussion on the subject, it was decided to present the system in all states, ensure Marathi students are not disadvantaged under the new educational policy related to the Academic Bank of Credit, and to consider other options comprehensively for everyone. It was resolved in the meeting to present and consult with Marathi language scholars, literary figures, political leaders, and all relevant parties. " School education minister Bhuse will now initiate the next consultation process. The meeting was attended by director of the Maharashtra State Council of Educational Research and Training Rahul Rekhawar. Earlier, cultural affairs minister Ashish Shelar said Marathi is the only language that is mandatory in schools.

"Historic moment": CM Manik Saha after Tripura declared as third 'fully literate' state in India
"Historic moment": CM Manik Saha after Tripura declared as third 'fully literate' state in India

India Gazette

time4 hours ago

  • India Gazette

"Historic moment": CM Manik Saha after Tripura declared as third 'fully literate' state in India

Agartala (Tripura) [India], June 23 (ANI): Chief Minister Manik Saha on Monday said that the declaration of Tripura as fully literate was a 'historic moment'. He said everyone should be encouraged to study, and emphasis should be given to improving the skills of newly literate citizens and fostering self-reliance. 'Literacy in the country is very important for Prime Minister Narendra Modi's vision of building a Viksit Bharat by 2047. The declaration of Tripura as the third fully literate state in the country is a historic moment. The Education Department must now focus on further increasing the literacy rate in Tripura,' Saha said. The CM said this at the declaration event and celebrations organised under the 'ULLAS (Understanding Lifelong Learning for All in Society)' - New India Literacy Programme (Nav Bharat Saaksharta Karyakram) held at Rabindra Satabarshiki Bhawan today. Saha said that today marks a truly historic moment for everyone, as Tripura has become the third state in the country to achieve full literacy. 'This is a matter of great pride for us and will be remembered as a milestone. Earlier, Mizoram and Goa had achieved the status of fully literate states. I congratulate all those who have worked tirelessly to implement this campaign, including the Education Department. Prime Minister Narendra Modi always speaks about Sabka Saath, Sabka Vikas, Sabka Vishwas, Sabka Prayas. Today, we have witnessed that spirit in action. Our goal is to ensure that the benefits of public welfare schemes reach the last person in society,' he said. Saha, who also serves as Tripura Education Minister, added that the Union Ministry of Education provided the framework for the campaign's success and extended all possible support. The Chief Minister noted that according to the 1961 census, the literacy rate in Tripura was only 20.24 per cent. It increased to 60.44 per cent in 1991, 73.19 per cent in 2001, and 87.22 per cent in 2011. 'The Nav Bharat Literacy Programme is progressing through the ULLAS initiative. In the 2023-24 financial year, the literacy rate reached 93.7 per cent, and in 2024-25, it rose to 95.6 per cent. However, this rate may increase further with a more comprehensive survey. Therefore, the Education Department must play an even more effective role in advancing this campaign,' he said. The Chief Minister also emphasised that when parents in a household are illiterate, they want their children to study--and now, educated children also want their parents to learn. 'Education is essential for everyone. In this regard, the Education Department must come forward to support those still distant from the light of education. The literacy campaign is a social movement. It cannot succeed with just a few teachers or trainers; it requires collective participation. There is joy in learning to read and write. Under the ULLAS program, about 943 Social Consciousness Centres have been established in every block and village of the state. Around 2,228 volunteer teachers are involved in this initiative. Additionally, school and college students and retired teachers are also contributing. Through combined efforts of all, we can build a better Tripura,' he said. Saha further mentioned that on March 17, 2024, a total of 4,597 people took the Foundational Literacy and Numeracy Assessment Test, out of which 3,581 passed. On December 29 of the same year, out of 14,179 candidates, 13,909 passed the test. In March this year, 5,819 out of 5,896 candidates passed. The event was attended by special guests Preeti Meena, Director (Adult Education) of the Union Ministry of Education; Raval Hemendra Kumar, Special Secretary, Department of Education; Director of Education NC Sharma, Director of SCERT L Darlong, along with eminent educationists and senior officials of the department. (ANI)

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store