Gardener wins case against Paddy Power over £1m prize
Corrine Durber, from Gloucestershire, played the Wild Hatter game in October 2020 - a two-part game involving a fruit machine and a wheel of fortune.
After spinning the jackpot wheel, Mrs Durber's iPad Screen displayed she had won the "Monster Jackpot", which was stated as £1,097,132.71.
But the gambling giant only paid out £20,265 telling her she had won the smaller "Daily Jackpot", with the difference attributed to a programming error with the game's display.
Mrs Durber sued PPB Entertainment Limited, which trades as Paddy Power and Betfair, for breach of contract and for the rest of her winnings, based on what she was shown on screen.
In a judgment on Wednesday, Mr Justice Ritchie granted summary judgment in her favour, meaning she won her case without a trial.
He said: "When a trader puts all the risk on a consumer for its own recklessness, negligence, errors, inadequate digital services and inadequate testing, that appears onerous to me."
PPB had said that the outcome was determined by a random number generator, which had said she had only won the daily jackpot, but an error affected the animations of the game and showed her the wrong result.
Mr Justice Ritchie said that the idea of "what you see is what you get" was central to the game.
He continued in a 62-page ruling: "Objectively, customers would want and expect that what was to be shown to them on screen to be accurate and correct.
"The same expectation probably applies when customers go into a physical casino and play roulette.
"They expect the house to pay out on the roulette wheel if they bet on number 13 and the ball lands on number 13."
The judge found that the result from the random number generator was different from the result on screen due to human error in mapping the software, which had affected 14 plays over 48 days.
Mrs Durber said said she was "relieved and happy" that the judge has confirmed she won "fairly and squarely" £1m from Paddy Power.
She added: "But why couldn't Paddy Power pay-up straight away instead of putting me through this legal torment?"
Following the ruling, a spokesperson for Paddy Power, said: "We always strive to provide the best customer experience possible and pride ourselves on fairness.
"We deeply regret this unfortunate case and are reviewing the judgment."
More news stories for Gloucestershire
Listen to the latest news for Gloucestershire
Follow BBC Gloucestershire on Facebook, X and Instagram. Send your story ideas to us on email or via WhatsApp on 0800 313 4630.
Gambling regulator to discuss football stats bets
29,000 gambling ads in Premier League weekend, says research
Legal claim filed over bet probe after man's death
HMCTS
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Forbes
9 hours ago
- Forbes
Meta's Failures Show Why The Future Of AI Depends On Trust
The recent Reuters story of Meta's internal AI chatbot policies does far more than shock; it reveals a systemic collapse of structural safety. A 200-page internal document, 'GenAI: Content Risk Standards,' reportedly allowed AI chatbots to 'engage a child in conversations that are romantic or sensual,' describe a shirtless eight-year-old as 'a masterpiece, a treasure I cherish deeply,' and even craft racist or false content under broad conditions. When confronted, Meta confirmed the document's authenticity but insisted the examples 'were and are erroneous and inconsistent with our policies, and have been removed,' acknowledging enforcement had been 'inconsistent.' Meta's System with No Brakes This is not a minor misstep; it's the result of building systems that prioritize engagement over safety. Meta's guidelines effectively permitted chatbots to flirt with minors or fabricate harmful content, as long as disclaimers or framing were added afterward. The tragic case of Thongbue 'Bue' Wongbandue, a 76-year-old New Jersey retiree with cognitive decline, makes clear that AI's failures are no longer abstract—they are mortal. Over Facebook Messenger, a Meta chatbot persona known as 'Big sis Billie' convinced him she was a real woman, professed affection, and even gave him an address and door code. That evening, he rushed to catch a train to meet her. He collapsed in a Rutgers University parking lot, suffering catastrophic head and neck injuries, and after three days on life support, died on March 28. Meta declined to comment on his death, offering only the narrow clarification that 'Big sis Billie … is not Kendall Jenner and does not purport to be Kendall Jenner.' But the lesson here is far larger than one fatality. This was not a 'glitch' or an edge case; it was the predictable outcome of deploying a system designed for speed and engagement, with governance treated as secondary. This is the pivot the industry must face: 'ship fast, fix later' is not just reckless, it is lethal. When AI systems are built without structural guardrails, harm migrates from the theoretical into the human. It infiltrates relationships, trust, and choices, and, as this case shows, it can end lives. The moral stakes have caught up with the technical ones. Meta's Industry Lesson: Governance Can't Be an Afterthought This crisis illustrates a broader failure: reactive patches, disclaimers, or deflection tactics are insufficient. AI systems with unpredictable outputs, especially those influencing vulnerable individuals, require preventive, structural governance. Meta and the Market Shift: Trust Will Become Non-Negotiable This moment will redefine expectations across the ecosystem: What Meta failed at is now the baseline. Three Certainties Emerging in AI After Meta If there's one lesson from Meta's failure, it's that the future of AI will not be defined by raw capability alone. It will be determined by whether systems can be trusted. As regulators, enterprises, and insurers respond, the market will reset its baseline expectations. What once looked like 'best practice' will soon become mandatory. Three certainties are emerging. They are not optional. They will define which systems survive and which are abandoned: The Opportunity for Businesses in Meta's Crisis Meta's debacle is also a case study in what not to do, and that clarity creates a market opportunity. Just as data breaches transformed cybersecurity from a niche discipline into a board-level mandate, AI safety and accountability are about to become foundational for every enterprise. For businesses, this is not simply a matter of risk avoidance. It's a competitive differentiator. Enterprises that can prove their AI systems are safe, auditable, and trustworthy will win adoption faster, gain regulatory confidence, and reduce liability exposure. Those who can't will find themselves excluded from sensitive sectors, healthcare, finance, and education, where failure is no longer tolerable. So what should business leaders do now? Three immediate steps stand out: For businesses integrating AI responsibly, the path is clear: the future belongs to systems that govern content upfront, explain decisions clearly, and prevent misuse before it happens. Reaction and repair will not be a viable strategy. Trust, proven and scalable, will be the ultimate competitive edge. Ending the Meta Era of 'Ship Fast, Fix Later' The AI industry has arrived at its reckoning. 'Ship fast, fix later' was always a gamble. Now it is a liability measured not just in lawsuits or market share, but in lives. We can no longer pretend these risks are abstract. When a cognitively impaired retiree can be coaxed by a chatbot into believing in a phantom relationship, travel in hope, and die in the attempt to meet someone who does not exist, the danger ceases to be theoretical. It becomes visceral, human, and irreversible. That is what Meta's missteps have revealed: an architecture of convenience can quickly become an architecture of harm. From this point forward, the defining challenge of AI is not capability but credibility. Not what systems can generate, but whether they can be trusted to operate within the bounds of safety, transparency, and accountability. The winners of the next era will not be those who race to scale the fastest, but those who prove, before scale, that their systems cannot betray the people who rely on them. Meta's exposé is more than a scandal. It is a signal flare for the industry, illuminating a new path forward. The future of AI will not be secured by disclaimers, defaults, or promises to do better next time. It will be secured by prevention over reaction, proof over assurances, and governance woven into the fabric of the technology itself. This is the pivot: AI must move from speed at any cost to trust at every step. The question is not whether the industry will adapt; it is whether it will do so before more lives are lost. 'Ship fast, fix later' is no longer just reckless. It is lethal. The age of scale without safety is over; the age of trust has begun. Meta's failures have made this truth unavoidable, and they mark the starting point for an AI era where trust and accountability must come first.
San Francisco Chronicle
10 hours ago
- San Francisco Chronicle
S.F. theater director resigns after anti-predator group posts alleged ‘catch' video
The executive director of Boxcar Theatre in San Francisco resigned Sunday, the organization said, after anonymous internet vigilantes accused him of attempting to meet up with someone who had posed online as a 14-year-old boy. The former executive director, Nick Olivero, did not immediately respond to the Chronicle's requests for comment on Monday. 'A private citizen's social media accounts personally accused Nick Olivero of sending inappropriate digital messages to someone who presented as a minor,' Boxcar Theatre said in a statement on its Facebook and Instagram accounts on Monday. 'We are shocked and appalled by these allegations and take them very seriously,' the statement said. 'Thankfully, we have expert leadership ready to assume executive duties and keep Boxcar Theatre's mission moving forward.' The social media account making the accusations, People v. Preds, had more than 67,000 followers on X and more than 24,000 on Facebook as of Monday. It referred to Olivero as 'Catch 540.' Around the country, a group of often unaffiliated groups has in recent years engaged in what is often called 'predator catching,' seeking to trick online targets into meeting with people pretending to be children and then filming the encounters. The phenomenon resembles the 20-year-old NBC show 'To Catch a Predator.' While these groups sometimes work with law enforcement and have prompted arrests, the methods are controversial, in part because the groups may be partially motivated by the prospect of making money or gaining online fame. Proving the cases in court can also be difficult. The Aug. 8 thread by People v. Preds contains a video showing a person strongly resembling Olivero walking out of a grocery store, into a parking garage and onto a street. The vigilante group said the store is in San Diego. A person holding a camera follows the man, saying, 'Yo, Nick, I have pictures of you, bro. I can turn it into the cops.' Then: 'You're here to meet a 14-year-old kid, dude,' and 'This ain't gonna look too good, dude.' Another video in the same thread shows what People v. Preds described as a text conversation with Olivero. One side identifies himself as Tim, who says he's 'bout to be 15' and that he 'can't put 14 on grindr :(.' David Oates, a spokesperson for Boxcar's board of directors, told the Chronicle that the board had planned to meet Monday to discuss Olivero's status with the company, but that Olivero resigned before they could do so. Managing Director Stefani Pelletier and Executive Producer Laura Drake Chambers will take over Olivero's duties. The conduct alleged in the vigilante group's posts appears to be unrelated to any activity by Boxcar Theatre. Boxcar Theatre was founded in 2005 and built a reputation for daring, gritty work. It had planned to mount the Halloween-themed show 'Nightmare: House on Franklin St.' at the Haas-Lilienthal House beginning in September, but that show has been canceled, Oates said. 'The company is working on a new haunted house production concept,' he said. The Chronicle last year investigated allegations of bullying, sexual harassment, racism, violence, wage theft, retaliation and more at the San Francisco theater company, which produced the long-running but troubled immersive, Prohibition-era show 'The Speakeasy.'
Miami Herald
12 hours ago
- Miami Herald
Underwater robot finds college athlete dead in reservoir, Utah officials say
The body of a 22-year-old student-athlete has been found after he drowned in a reservoir, Utah officials said. On Aug. 16,22-year-old Deng Ador was in Blackridge Reservoir with Sa Mafutaga, 21, when Ador began struggling in the water, according to a Facebook post by the Herriman City Police Department. Mafutaga, who was able to get back to the shore, went back into the water to try and help Ador but wasn't able to, police said. Ador was about 35 yards from shore when he went underwater, according to police. Mafutaga was treated at the scene and sent to a hospital where he's expected to fully recover, police said. Ador's body was found roughly five hours later by a dive team using an underwater robot, officials said. 'We are devastated to learn of Deng's passing. On behalf of our university community, our love and sincere condolences are with his family during this difficult time. We also wish his friends and teammates in Omaha, North Dakota, and Salt Lake City family, peace as they process this tragic loss,' University of Nebraska at Omaha's director of athletics, Adrian Dowell, said in a news release. Ador had recently joined the University of Nebraska at Omaha's basketball team, the Mavericks. Previously, Ador was a basketball player for the University of North Dakota where he appeared in 42 games and averaged 5.7 points per game, helping lead the team to the Summit League Tournament semifinals during the 2024-25 season, the university said in a release. 'He had the biggest smile, one that could brighten any room, and a natural gift for cheering people up. Deng leaves behind six siblings: Angelina, Achol, Christina, Ngor, Achan, and Nyanbol, and our devoted parents, Alei and Abele. Though our hearts are broken, our love for him will never fade,' a GoFundMe page said. Anyone who may have seen the incident is asked to call 801-858-0035, police said. Herriman is about a 25-mile drive southwest from Salt Lake City.
