Letters to the editor: We need a good attitude to work together and fix South Africa, no 'holier-than-thou' sentiments
The visit to America by Freedom Front+ leaders is an undermining of the authority of the President and his cabinet.
As a sovereign state, South Africa has the right to make its own decisions and not be 'coerced' by American requests'. Being 'coerced' is the impression I got, because the implication is, if we don't meet their demands, our economy will suffer'.
The President has already made himself clear on the denouncement of 'kill the Boer'. It should not be taken up literally, because if it were so, we would have already seen a real genocide.
The small group of Afrikaners who exchanged their identity to become 'Amerikaners', is testimony to the fact that there is no genocide. The colonial conquest of South Africa included acts of genocide by a 'Christianing' Europe against the Khoi and San people.
I speculate that descendants of these colonists (possibly AWB, FF+, their family and circle of friends) have probably shouted during apartheid 'slaan die hotnot' and 'skiet die k****'
People of colour have lost more lives during the Struggle due to police brutality, than present day farm murders.
As a product of 1976, other students and I had to run for our lives across a field when the police shot at us. Who can forget the brutal murders of Ashley Kriel, Robbie Waterwitch, Colleen Williams, the Cradock 4, Chris Hani, Steve Biko, Hector Pieterson, et al?
If they (the FF+ and other colonialist descendants) are genuine in getting South Africa back on track, I would appeal to them not to fly to America, but to come forward on home soil to repent for the sins of their forefathers and start the process of restoration, reconciliation and restitution.
This will lay the platform for the spiritual, social and economic revival to eradicate poverty, inequality and unemployment.
Let's leave the holier-than-thou attitude behind and be humble enough to get our hands dirty in order to clean up the mess that the majority of South African find themselves in 'Helping Hands for A Better Future'. | Clive Solomon Goodwood
Poultry vaccination a game changer
The Democratic Alliance in KwaZulu-Natal welcomes the announcement by Agriculture Minister John Steenhuisen that South Africa will begin its first-ever national poultry vaccination programme against highly pathogenic avian influenza (HPAI).
This is a decisive step in protecting the agricultural economy – and in KZN, it could be game-changing.
KZN is home to a significant and growing poultry industry. From large-scale commercial operations to emerging black farmers and subsistence producers in rural municipalities, poultry farming remains the single most important source of both affordable protein and agricultural employment in the province.
Recent outbreaks of avian influenza have devastated producers across the country. For KZN, where rural livelihoods are often centred around backyard poultry operations or smallholder commercial ventures, the economic risks of HPAI are immense.
By proactively rolling out vaccinations, Minister Steenhuisen is not only protecting South African poultry – he is safeguarding food security, rural incomes, and economic stability in provinces like ours.
We further call on the KZN Department of Agriculture and Rural Development to:
■ Ensure full alignment with the national rollout plan, with special emphasis on rural and small-scale poultry producers;
■ Deploy veterinary support and training teams to all districts to assist with safe vaccination and biosecurity awareness;
■ Prioritise emerging black farmers and cooperatives to prevent inequitable access -to disease control interventions.
We are especially encouraged by this action as a signal of a more responsive, science-based agricultural policy environment under the new Government of National Unity.
The DA, in its role in the Government of Provincial Unity (GPU) in KZN, will continue to monitor implementation and provide oversight to ensure that this programme reaches every farmer – not just the biggest, but also the most vulnerable. | SAKHILE MNGADI, MPL DA KZN spokesperson on Agriculture
AI being willfully misused in law
As a practicing attorney and someone who has been at the side bar for almost 40 years, I'm seeing more and more attorneys using Artificial Intelligence for not only their research but also their letters.
Fortunately, their letters are completely see through and one can pick up the stultified manner in which AI writes letters.
In one particular case, acting Judge DJ Smit had the lawyer (advocate) admit that the citation emanated from AI. In a previous case lawyers have been referred to be disciplined at the Legal Practice Council.
We are probably going to see more and more of this.
However, what is becoming a real nightmare is that when you do see clients and they ask for an opinion on a legal issue or on the strength of their case, they come armed with AI advice to not only challenge you but also to second guess. The advice that they pick up is sometimes enormously problematic and wrong.
I have had quite a few clients advising me that they are going to go rather with the AI advice because it suits them better. This has had enormously destructive consequences for the clients. I suspect that they don't even bother to go and get the advice checked out by a lawyer. | MICHAEL BAGRAIM Cape Town
LETTERS
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

IOL News
6 hours ago
- IOL News
Letters to the editor: We need a good attitude to work together and fix South Africa, no 'holier-than-thou' sentiments
We need a better attitude to fix SA The visit to America by Freedom Front+ leaders is an undermining of the authority of the President and his cabinet. As a sovereign state, South Africa has the right to make its own decisions and not be 'coerced' by American requests'. Being 'coerced' is the impression I got, because the implication is, if we don't meet their demands, our economy will suffer'. The President has already made himself clear on the denouncement of 'kill the Boer'. It should not be taken up literally, because if it were so, we would have already seen a real genocide. The small group of Afrikaners who exchanged their identity to become 'Amerikaners', is testimony to the fact that there is no genocide. The colonial conquest of South Africa included acts of genocide by a 'Christianing' Europe against the Khoi and San people. I speculate that descendants of these colonists (possibly AWB, FF+, their family and circle of friends) have probably shouted during apartheid 'slaan die hotnot' and 'skiet die k****' People of colour have lost more lives during the Struggle due to police brutality, than present day farm murders. As a product of 1976, other students and I had to run for our lives across a field when the police shot at us. Who can forget the brutal murders of Ashley Kriel, Robbie Waterwitch, Colleen Williams, the Cradock 4, Chris Hani, Steve Biko, Hector Pieterson, et al? If they (the FF+ and other colonialist descendants) are genuine in getting South Africa back on track, I would appeal to them not to fly to America, but to come forward on home soil to repent for the sins of their forefathers and start the process of restoration, reconciliation and restitution. This will lay the platform for the spiritual, social and economic revival to eradicate poverty, inequality and unemployment. Let's leave the holier-than-thou attitude behind and be humble enough to get our hands dirty in order to clean up the mess that the majority of South African find themselves in 'Helping Hands for A Better Future'. | Clive Solomon Goodwood Poultry vaccination a game changer The Democratic Alliance in KwaZulu-Natal welcomes the announcement by Agriculture Minister John Steenhuisen that South Africa will begin its first-ever national poultry vaccination programme against highly pathogenic avian influenza (HPAI). This is a decisive step in protecting the agricultural economy – and in KZN, it could be game-changing. KZN is home to a significant and growing poultry industry. From large-scale commercial operations to emerging black farmers and subsistence producers in rural municipalities, poultry farming remains the single most important source of both affordable protein and agricultural employment in the province. Recent outbreaks of avian influenza have devastated producers across the country. For KZN, where rural livelihoods are often centred around backyard poultry operations or smallholder commercial ventures, the economic risks of HPAI are immense. By proactively rolling out vaccinations, Minister Steenhuisen is not only protecting South African poultry – he is safeguarding food security, rural incomes, and economic stability in provinces like ours. We further call on the KZN Department of Agriculture and Rural Development to: ■ Ensure full alignment with the national rollout plan, with special emphasis on rural and small-scale poultry producers; ■ Deploy veterinary support and training teams to all districts to assist with safe vaccination and biosecurity awareness; ■ Prioritise emerging black farmers and cooperatives to prevent inequitable access -to disease control interventions. We are especially encouraged by this action as a signal of a more responsive, science-based agricultural policy environment under the new Government of National Unity. The DA, in its role in the Government of Provincial Unity (GPU) in KZN, will continue to monitor implementation and provide oversight to ensure that this programme reaches every farmer – not just the biggest, but also the most vulnerable. | SAKHILE MNGADI, MPL DA KZN spokesperson on Agriculture AI being willfully misused in law As a practicing attorney and someone who has been at the side bar for almost 40 years, I'm seeing more and more attorneys using Artificial Intelligence for not only their research but also their letters. Fortunately, their letters are completely see through and one can pick up the stultified manner in which AI writes letters. In one particular case, acting Judge DJ Smit had the lawyer (advocate) admit that the citation emanated from AI. In a previous case lawyers have been referred to be disciplined at the Legal Practice Council. We are probably going to see more and more of this. However, what is becoming a real nightmare is that when you do see clients and they ask for an opinion on a legal issue or on the strength of their case, they come armed with AI advice to not only challenge you but also to second guess. The advice that they pick up is sometimes enormously problematic and wrong. I have had quite a few clients advising me that they are going to go rather with the AI advice because it suits them better. This has had enormously destructive consequences for the clients. I suspect that they don't even bother to go and get the advice checked out by a lawyer. | MICHAEL BAGRAIM Cape Town LETTERS

IOL News
7 hours ago
- IOL News
DA's grandstanding an 'insult' to the nation
Reneva Fourie Life is hard for the vast majority of South Africans. Given the high unemployment rate, most are in survival mode. We are doing whatever is required to ensure that our loved ones are fed and safe while contending with rampant crime and rising drug and human trafficking. In this context, the least we expect from our politicians is integrity. We need service delivery and a stable political environment. Above all, we need a president who leads with strength and clarity. That is why it was refreshing to see President Ramaphosa take decisive action for once. The removal of Andrew Whitfield from his position as Deputy Minister of Trade, Industry and Competition for travelling abroad without permission was long overdue. He had participated in a political party delegation to the United States (US), where they met with top American officials and reinforced lies propagated about South Africa's transformation policies, especially land reform. Their conduct not only smears our reputation abroad. It damaged diplomatic relations with one of our key trade partners, jeopardising domestic development. It posed a threat to our sovereignty and security. It also compromised the smooth handover of the G20 chairpersonship from South Africa to the US. The impact of their actions was severe. The dismissal of Whitfield is a very light punishment for the Democratic Alliance's (DA) disgraceful act of political sabotage. Instead of showing remorse, the DA used the moment as an opportunity to grandstand. The party's arrogance, its blatant disregard for governance processes and inability to recognise the seriousness of the offence are exhausting. They fail to demonstrate the humility and respect required of members of a Government of National Unity (GNU). The DA has repeatedly chosen to undermine the president. Their representatives refer to him by his first name in official communications. They challenge his authority at every turn and show little concern for the dignity of his office. This distorted sense of self-importance demonstrates disdain towards the president. It is also an insult to all South Africans. What is most disturbing is the DA's willingness to harm the country in its pursuit of power. Instead of strengthening democracy, they run to foreign governments and institutions whenever they fail to get their way at home. Their cosy relationship with the US and Israel has become a convenient route to bypass the democratic process and cast South Africa in a negative light. This behaviour is not new. It has been prevalent since the establishment of the GNU. The DA has consistently demonstrated that it believes the law applies only to others. When their actions are questioned, they cry foul. When their members are held accountable, they complain about political persecution. This is not in compliance with the rule of law. It is a double standard. Steenhuisen's reaction to Whitfield's dismissal is a concrete example of the DA's duplicity. He was informed well in advance that this decision was on the table. Yet when it was implemented, he acted as if it were a surprise. He accused the president of undermining the coalition agreement. He dared to say that he feels disrespected and issued ultimatums. When the president refused to cower to their demands, the DA backtracked. Their desire for power was greater than their honour. Instead, they decided to withdraw from the National Dialogue. While there is disagreement on the cost and format, there is general acceptance that public engagement and ownership are essential for the collective acceleration of the country's socio-economic advancement. Having committed to the dialogue in writing, the DA is now dismissing it as a waste of time. This is a betrayal of the public and of the agreements that brought the unity government into being. Furthermore, the DA threatened to initiate a vote of no confidence in the president. It once again sought to create chaos, weaken public trust in leadership, and destabilise the country for narrow party gain. Having suddenly realised just how irresponsible that threat is, it has now also been withdrawn, trapping the government in endless court battles instead. South Africans are tired of leaders who place their egos ahead of the nation. Tired of the noise. Tired of the never-ending circus of threats, ultimatums and name-calling. We face daily struggles that do not allow for political drama. Food insecurity, the high cost of living, crime and joblessness are real and persistent problems. These cannot be solved while elected politicians behave like squabbling children. The government is not a playground. It is a place for responsible leadership and mature decision-making. We do not expect miracles. We know the problems are complex. However, we expect those who have been given the responsibility to govern to take it seriously. That includes respecting democratic processes and the offices of the state. It means engaging in dialogue even when it is uncomfortable. It means disagreeing without tearing the house down. And above all, it means remembering that governance is not about promoting party-political power. It is about improving the quality of life of citizens. The DA must make a choice. It can be part of building a better South Africa, or it can continue on its current path of obstruction, grandstanding and political sabotage. If it chooses the latter, then it should not be surprised when South Africans stop listening. We are looking for solutions, not tantrums. We are looking for accountability, not arrogance. President Ramaphosa has taken a small but meaningful step in the right direction. He must now go further. He must act swiftly and consistently in holding all members of government accountable. He must reinforce the principle that no one is above the collective goals of unity, service and integrity. If he does, the country will follow. The time has come for calm, for order and for leadership that puts the people first. Let those who are unwilling to contribute step aside. Let those who are ready to serve do so with humility and focus. South Africa deserves nothing less. * Dr Reneva Fourie is a policy analyst specialising in governance, development and security. ** The views expressed do not necessarily reflect the views of IOL, Independent Media or The African.


Daily Maverick
8 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
US arrests, seeks to deport Mexican boxer Julio Cesar Chavez Jr
US immigration authorities have arrested Mexican boxer Julio Cesar Chavez Jr in Los Angeles and plan to deport him, they said on Thursday, just days after he lost a high-profile bout to American rival Jake Paul. The U.S. Department of Homeland Security said Chavez was determined to be in the country illegally last week after he made fraudulent statements on a 2024 application for permanent residence. He is married to a U.S. citizen, it said. Michael Goldstein, a lawyer for Chavez, said more than two dozen immigration agents arrested the boxer at his home in the Studio City area of Los Angeles on Wednesday. 'The current allegations are outrageous and appear to be designed as a headline to terrorize the community,' Goldstein said. Homeland Security said that the 39-year-old boxer, son of Mexican world champion fighter Julio Cesar Chavez, is suspected of ties to Mexico's Sinaloa Cartel, which Washington has designated a foreign terrorist organization. His wife, Frida Munoz Chavez, was previously married to the son of former Sinaloa cartel leader Joaquin 'El Chapo' Guzman, who is serving a life sentence in a U.S. prison. The son, Edgar, was assassinated in 2008. Chavez is the target of a Mexican arrest warrant on allegations of involvement in organized crime and firearms trafficking, DHS said. In Mexico, Chavez' family said in a statement they 'fully trust in his innocence.' Chavez lost to influencer-turned-boxer Paul, 28, last weekend before a sold-out crowd in Anaheim, California, in a unanimous decision after 10 rounds. He was allowed to enter the United States temporarily in early January under former President Joe Biden, DHS said. He had previously overstayed a tourist visa, it said. The agency said Chavez was convicted in Los Angeles in 2024 on weapons charges. Goldstein denied he was convicted, saying he pleaded not guilty and was granted mental health diversion which will result in dismissal of the charges. Chavez won the WBC middleweight championship in 2011, but lost the title the next year. His career has been overshadowed by controversies including a suspension after testing positive for a banned substance in 2009 and a fine and suspension after testing positive for marijuana in 2013. His record stands at 54 wins, six losses and one draw, with 34 knockouts.