‘Don't forget Charlie Hebdo': Istanbul protesters rage over satirical cartoon, arrests
Unrest began late Monday after Istanbul's chief prosecutor ordered the arrest of staff at LeMan weekly saying it had published a cartoon that 'publicly insulted religious values'.
LeMan categorically denied the allegation, with its editor-in-chief telling AFP the image had 'nothing to do with the Prophet Muhammad'.
But news of the warrant brought an angry mob of hardline Islamist protesters onto the streets, who clashed with police late into the night, an AFP correspondent said.
A group called Islamic Solidarity Platform called another protest Tuesday, prompting police to shut Taksim Square and Istiklal, the city's busy shopping thoroughfare.
But they gathered anyway, with around 300 protesters shouted abuse and chanting 'Don't forget Charlie Hebdo', referring to the 2015 attack on a Paris magazine when Islamist gunmen killed 12 people after it published caricatures lampooning the Prophet Muhammad.
According to the correspondent, the protesters were far less aggressive than those who rallied on Monday night, when around 400 Islamist hardliners tried to storm a bar frequented by the magazine staff.
'Down with secularism, long live sharia (law)! Jihad, jihad, martyrdom!' they shouted while clashing with police, who fired tear gas and rubber bullets.
'No justification for violence'
Publication of the image drew sharp condemnation from President Recep Tayyip Erdogan, who denounced it as a 'hate crime'.
'It is a clear provocation disguised as humour, a vile provocation,' he railed, saying the authorities had confiscated all existing copies of the offending issue.
Monday's violence drew sharp condemnation from Erol Onderoglu of Reporters Without Borders (RSF).
'There is no justification for such violence, which we strongly condemn,' he told AFP, saying it was 'hard to understand' why police did not intervene sooner and that the 'cartoonists' safety must take priority'.
Overnight, Interior Minister Ali Yerlikaya posted images of the cartoonist, LeMan's graphic designer, its publisher and another staff member being roughly dragged away under arrest, prompting a rebuke from Turkish rights group MLSA.
'Detaining cartoonists and subjecting them to mistreatment under the accusation of 'insulting religious values' over a cartoon is unlawful,' its co-director Veysel Ok wrote on X.
The Istanbul Bar Association also denounced the arrests, saying: 'Actions such as reverse handcuffing applied during detention, sharing of footage taken by forcibly bowing the head, and similar acts clearly violate the prohibition of ill-treatment.'
Statements on the matter by politicians and ministers had 'undermined the presumption of innocence' and risked 'influencing judicial independence', it said.
And 'aggressive actions and protests accompanied by slogans opposing the secular rule of law... under the guise of freedom of expression cannot be tolerated.'
'Social lynching'
Copies of the disputed cartoon posted online show two winged characters with halos hovering in the skies over a city being bombed.
'Salam aleikum, I'm Mohammed,' says one shaking hands with the other who replies, 'Aleikum salam, I'm Musa.'
Opposition leader Ozgur Ozel said he was shocked when he first heard the allegations but after looking at the image, said he quickly realised they were not true.
'Take a proper look: I see an angel who died in a bombardment in Gaza, with a halo and wings who encounters another angel also killed by a bomb... (but) Muhammad is a prophet, not an angel,' he said.
'I will not allow any disrespect to the Prophet Muhammad, but I won't remain silent about a social lynching based on a non-existant disrespect.'
Speaking to AFP from Paris, LeMan editor-in-chief Tuncay Akgun said the image had been deliberately misinterpreted to cause provocation.
'In this work, the name of a Muslim who was killed in Israel's bombardments is fictionalised as Mohammed,' he said.
'This cartoon is not a caricature of Prophet Muhammad in any way,' he said, describing the arrest warrant as a 'systematic provocation and attack' on the decades-old satirical magazine. — AFP
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Malay Mail
4 hours ago
- Malay Mail
Turkish cartoon row deepens: ‘LeMan' staff remanded over ‘disrespectful' drawing
ISTANBUL, July 3 — Four staff members at satirical Turkish magazine LeMan were remanded in custody Wednesday over accusations they published a caricature of the Prophet Muhammad, a case that watchdogs have called an attack on press freedom. The four, who deny any link between the illustration and the prophet, were held as part of prosecutors' probe into what Justice Minister Yilmaz Tunc called the 'disrespectful drawing'. He added that a warrant has been issued for two additional suspects who were abroad. The publication of the cartoon and arrests of staff at the opposition magazine led to clashes in Istanbul on Monday. News site T24 published the police deposition of cartoonist Dogan Pehlevan in which he said that he wanted 'to talk about peace in this drawing' and condemned 'provocateurs'. 'I have been drawing in Turkey for many years. The first rule you learn is not to address religious issues and not to mock religion,' he said. 'I have always adhered to this principle. I reject the accusations levelled against me,' he added. The drawing in question shows two characters meeting in the sky above a city devastated by bombs. One is named Muhammed and the other Musa. 'I just wanted to highlight the absurdity of war, to show that people can get along but do you have to be dead to realise that? That's my only message,' he added. On Monday evening, a favourite haunt of LeMan staff in the Istiklal district of Istanbul was attacked. It escalated into a pitched battle between about 300 people, including people defending the magazine and furious at the arrests. On Tuesday, President Recep Tayyip Erdogan called the cartoon a 'despicable provocation' and a 'hate crime' whose authors will have to answer for 'disrespecting the prophet'. 'Political opportunists' Despite a ban, some 300 people also gathered around Taksim Mosque in central Istanbul, shouting 'don't forget Charlie Hebdo', referring to a deadly Islamist militant attack on the French magazine in 2015. LeMan's editor-in-chief Tuncay Akgun told AFP that the drawing in question 'has nothing to do with the Prophet Muhammad', adding: 'We would never take such a risk.' 'The character is a Muslim killed in Gaza... He was called Muhammed (like) more than 200 million people in the Muslim world,' he said. In a joint statement, Turkey's TGS press union and professional organisations said they had 'great concern' at the rise in attacks and 'violent rhetoric' due to the publication. Media watchdog Reporters Without Borders, the international network Cartooning for Peace and the US association Cartoonists Rights condemned the attack on press freedom in Turkey. They called on the Turkish authorities to ensure the safety of the editorial team. Terry Anderson, of Cartoonists Rights, said the arrests were 'based on a lie and are being exploited by political opportunists for intimidation and repression'. 'We demand the release of those detained and an immediate end to these baseless prosecutions,' he added. Many Turks and press organisations drew a parallel with the attack on LeMan and the Sivas massacre in 1993, when a radical Islamist mob set fire to a hotel, killing 33 writers and artists mainly from the Alevi minority. The protesters had been angered by the presence of the writer Aziz Nesin who had questioned the authenticity of the Quran and also sought to translate Salman Rushdie's controversial novel The Satanic Verses. — AFP
Malay Mail
a day ago
- Malay Mail
Three women on trial in Singapore over pro-Palestine procession near Istana
SINGAPORE, July 2 — Three women are on trial in the city-state after denying charges of organising a procession without a police permit around the Istana. Mossammad Sobikun Nahar, 26; Siti Amirah Mohamed Asrori, 30; and Annamalai Kokila Parvathi, 36, each face one charge under the Public Order Act for allegedly leading a procession in a prohibited area on 2 February 2024. Prosecutors said the event aimed to publicise support for Palestine and took place along the perimeter of the Istana, The Straits Times reported. Investigation Officer Muhammad Faizal testified that he was assigned to investigate the event, named Letters for Palestine. He presented CCTV footage showing around 70 people gathering at Plaza Singapura before walking towards the Istana with umbrellas painted with watermelon graphics. The footage showed Sobikun leading the group along Orchard Road, Buyong Road and Cavenagh Road to the Istana's rear gate. At the rear gate, the group posed for photographs while displaying the watermelon umbrellas, with Amirah seen fanning out a stack of letters. During cross-examination, defence lawyer Surian Sidambaram argued that the group believed they were acting lawfully based on similar past events. The judge rejected the defence's attempt to cite those events as precedent, saying a previous lack of enforcement did not justify breaking the law.
Malay Mail
a day ago
- Malay Mail
‘Don't forget Charlie Hebdo': Istanbul protesters rage over satirical cartoon, arrests
ISTANBUL, July 2 — Angry protesters rallied in Istanbul on Tuesday despite a heavy police presence, shouting threats following allegations a satirical magazine published a cartoon of the Prophet Muhammad. Unrest began late Monday after Istanbul's chief prosecutor ordered the arrest of staff at LeMan weekly saying it had published a cartoon that 'publicly insulted religious values'. LeMan categorically denied the allegation, with its editor-in-chief telling AFP the image had 'nothing to do with the Prophet Muhammad'. But news of the warrant brought an angry mob of hardline Islamist protesters onto the streets, who clashed with police late into the night, an AFP correspondent said. A group called Islamic Solidarity Platform called another protest Tuesday, prompting police to shut Taksim Square and Istiklal, the city's busy shopping thoroughfare. But they gathered anyway, with around 300 protesters shouted abuse and chanting 'Don't forget Charlie Hebdo', referring to the 2015 attack on a Paris magazine when Islamist gunmen killed 12 people after it published caricatures lampooning the Prophet Muhammad. According to the correspondent, the protesters were far less aggressive than those who rallied on Monday night, when around 400 Islamist hardliners tried to storm a bar frequented by the magazine staff. 'Down with secularism, long live sharia (law)! Jihad, jihad, martyrdom!' they shouted while clashing with police, who fired tear gas and rubber bullets. 'No justification for violence' Publication of the image drew sharp condemnation from President Recep Tayyip Erdogan, who denounced it as a 'hate crime'. 'It is a clear provocation disguised as humour, a vile provocation,' he railed, saying the authorities had confiscated all existing copies of the offending issue. Monday's violence drew sharp condemnation from Erol Onderoglu of Reporters Without Borders (RSF). 'There is no justification for such violence, which we strongly condemn,' he told AFP, saying it was 'hard to understand' why police did not intervene sooner and that the 'cartoonists' safety must take priority'. Overnight, Interior Minister Ali Yerlikaya posted images of the cartoonist, LeMan's graphic designer, its publisher and another staff member being roughly dragged away under arrest, prompting a rebuke from Turkish rights group MLSA. 'Detaining cartoonists and subjecting them to mistreatment under the accusation of 'insulting religious values' over a cartoon is unlawful,' its co-director Veysel Ok wrote on X. The Istanbul Bar Association also denounced the arrests, saying: 'Actions such as reverse handcuffing applied during detention, sharing of footage taken by forcibly bowing the head, and similar acts clearly violate the prohibition of ill-treatment.' Statements on the matter by politicians and ministers had 'undermined the presumption of innocence' and risked 'influencing judicial independence', it said. And 'aggressive actions and protests accompanied by slogans opposing the secular rule of law... under the guise of freedom of expression cannot be tolerated.' 'Social lynching' Copies of the disputed cartoon posted online show two winged characters with halos hovering in the skies over a city being bombed. 'Salam aleikum, I'm Mohammed,' says one shaking hands with the other who replies, 'Aleikum salam, I'm Musa.' Opposition leader Ozgur Ozel said he was shocked when he first heard the allegations but after looking at the image, said he quickly realised they were not true. 'Take a proper look: I see an angel who died in a bombardment in Gaza, with a halo and wings who encounters another angel also killed by a bomb... (but) Muhammad is a prophet, not an angel,' he said. 'I will not allow any disrespect to the Prophet Muhammad, but I won't remain silent about a social lynching based on a non-existant disrespect.' Speaking to AFP from Paris, LeMan editor-in-chief Tuncay Akgun said the image had been deliberately misinterpreted to cause provocation. 'In this work, the name of a Muslim who was killed in Israel's bombardments is fictionalised as Mohammed,' he said. 'This cartoon is not a caricature of Prophet Muhammad in any way,' he said, describing the arrest warrant as a 'systematic provocation and attack' on the decades-old satirical magazine. — AFP
