Australia faces a ‘guns or butter' problem: defence spending or social programmes?
Australia confronts a 'guns or butter' choice between a bigger defence budget and expanding national disability insurance and other social programmes, according to multinational banking and financial services company Rabobank, which calls for economic statecraft to navigate a risky regional security environment.
For now, the government is opting for 'butter', but it retains substantial fiscal headroom to bolster military spending when compared to peer economies, Rabobank economist Benjamin Picton said in a research note on Tuesday. The nation's debt is lower than that of counterparts as a share of its gross domestic product.
Australian officials have warned that the nation faces its most complex strategic circumstances since World War II. The government aims to pivot its military posture to deterrence, including via drones and missiles, to complement a planned fleet of nuclear-powered submarines due to be delivered in the 2030s under the
Aukus deal.
A Virginia-class nuclear-powered attack submarine of the type Australia is set to acquire from the early 2030s. Photo: US Navy
But Canberra is caught between the expanding military footprint of China, which is also Australia's biggest trading partner, and its traditional US ally that is seeking to check Beijing's expansion in the Asia-Pacific.
Picton pointed out the contradiction of Australia deepening military engagement with Washington via Aukus to deter China while trying to keep defence spending low enough to 'remain relatively inoffensive' to Beijing.
'This have-your-cake-and-eat-it-too approach carries risk that Australia will be forced into supporting US foreign policy interests against its own, while also being underprepared if a major conflict were to break out, or if the US were to revise its strategic doctrine in the Western Pacific,' Picton said.
As a result, Australia faces higher defence, social programmes and debt servicing costs which may put pressure on long-dated government bonds, Picton said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
South China Morning Post
30 minutes ago
- South China Morning Post
China will bring out the big guns for its military parade. What's it all about?
China is preparing to show off its military might with a huge parade in Beijing on September 3 marking the 80th anniversary of the victory over Japan in World War II. Advertisement As well as thousands of goose-stepping soldiers, the People's Liberation Army will bring out the big guns with its latest missile systems, weaponry and aircraft on display for the first time since the last military parade six years ago. Why hold a parade? The PLA has not fought a war since the 1990s and its military parades since then have served as a demonstration of the PLA's prowess and determination. They have become more frequent since Xi Jinping took power in 2012. Amid an ambitious modernisation drive – with the goal of creating a 'world class' military by 2049 – there have been large-scale parades in Beijing in 2015 and 2019, and in Inner Mongolia in 2017. Two major naval parades have also been held, in the South China Sea in 2018 and in the Yellow Sea in 2019. Fewer parades took place when Xi's predecessors Jiang Zemin and Hu Jintao were in office. One was staged in 1999 when Jiang was in power and another in 2009 when Hu was president, both in Tiananmen Square. Naval parades were also held in the Yellow Sea to mark PLA Navy anniversaries in 1995 and 2009. Xi Jinping (centre) with former presidents Hu Jintao (left) and Jiang Zemin at the 2019 parade. Photo: AP In recent years, these parades have reflected a fundamental shift in China's defence strategy and foreign policy – from 'keeping a low profile and biding time' to 'proactively striving for accomplishments' – and they come as geopolitical rivalry has intensified, especially with the United States.
South China Morning Post
38 minutes ago
- South China Morning Post
China slams EU ban on medical-device sales as trade-dispute list grows ahead of July talks
China has hit back at the EU's decision to exclude Chinese companies from the 27-member bloc's public tenders for multi-million-euro medical devices – the latest items on a growing list of trade disputes between Beijing and Brussels. 'The European side has disregarded the goodwill and sincerity that China has repeatedly conveyed through bilateral dialogues,' a spokesperson for the Ministry of Commerce said on Tuesday. 'China is strongly dissatisfied with the decision and resolutely opposes it. 'China urges the European side to immediately correct its wrongdoings and will take measures to firmly safeguard the legitimate rights and interests of Chinese enterprises.' Brussels' decision came as both sides were attempting to manage their trade differences – ranging from electric vehicles to cognac – in preparation for next month's China-EU summit set to take place in Beijing. But efforts have faced fresh challenges in recent weeks. China's commerce minister, Wang Wentao, and his European counterpart, Maros Sefcovic, held a video call after the von der Leyen episode, attempting to pull trade talks back on track.
South China Morning Post
38 minutes ago
- South China Morning Post
Huawei, SMIC struggle to advance chips to 5-nm level, MateBook shows: report
Huawei Technologies continues to face challenges in advancing to the 5-nanometre chip manufacturing process, an analysis of its latest laptop hardware shows, underscoring the impact of US sanctions on the Chinese telecoms equipment giant. Canadian research firm TechInsights found that the newly launched MateBook Fold Ultimate Design laptop features Huawei's Kirin X90 system-on-a-chip (SoC), which is manufactured by China's Semiconductor Manufacturing International Corporation (SMIC) using its 7-nm process node, according to a report published last week. The finding dampens speculation that Huawei had made the leap to SMIC's 5-nm process, for which production is difficult to scale because of US sanctions on the sale of the most advanced chipmaking equipment to Chinese fabrication plants. The report comes nearly two years after TechInsights identified that Huawei was using SMIC's 7-nm process for the Kirin chips in its latest smartphones, starting with the Mate 60 Pro. Unveiled in May, the new MateBook Fold is Huawei's first laptop with a foldable display, aimed at competing with similar offerings from Lenovo Group and HP. It runs on Huawei's proprietary HarmonyOS operating system, as the company pushes for self-reliance in both hardware and software. Richard Yu Chengdong, chairman of Huawei's consumer business group, introduces the Huawei MateBook Fold Ultimate Design laptop on May 19. Photo: Weibo Huawei's slow progress in securing 5-nm chips would mean the company is 'multiple generations behind' its US rivals such as Apple , according to the report. Apple's M-series chips have been using Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company's (TSMC) 3-nm process for the past two years.
