China's BRI faces downturn over debt concerns
London
China's Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) is facing a downturn as multiple countries withdraw or scale back their participation over concerns about sovereignty, debt sustainability, surveillance risks, and overreliance on Beijing.
Notably, allies such as Pakistan and Myanmar have reassessed their involvement—a major blow to the megaproject that China has used to pursue political, economic, and military interests.
Panama is the latest country to officially leave the BRI, having issued the required 90-day notice. The first Latin American nation to join the initiative in 2017, Panama questioned the benefits it had gained. 'What has it brought to Panama all these years?' President José Raúl Mulino asked.
Losing Panama means China loses easier access to the Panama Canal, one of the world's most vital maritime trade chokepoints, and a strategic foothold in the Western Hemisphere near the US. While Beijing expressed regret and urged Panama to reconsider, Chinese officials failed to provide clear examples of benefits delivered under the BRI.
Brazil, Latin America's largest economy, has consistently declined to join despite China's appeals. Celso Amorim, Special Presidential Adviser for International Affairs, said Brazil did not want BRI to serve as an 'insurance policy' and refused to enter into a treaty.
Brazil is now the second BRICS member after India to reject the BRI, a move some analysts believe contributed to President Xi Jinping skipping the recent BRICS Summit in Rio de Janeiro.
Italy was the first G7 country to join the BRI in 2019 but has since withdrawn. Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni, a longtime critic who called the move a 'serious mistake,' led Italy's exit after concluding the country saw little economic benefit while China gained political influence. Italian Defence Minister Guido Crosetto described joining the BRI as an 'improvised and atrocious act.'
The European Union as a whole has taken a cautious stance, viewing the BRI as a tool for China to advance industrial, and military aims.
European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen warned that the Chinese Communist Party's goal is a systemic transformation of the international order with China at its centre, citing the BRI as part of that effort.
In Asia, the Philippines withdrew from BRI projects in 2023 over security, economic, and geopolitical concerns. Critics cited unfavourable loan terms, lack of Chinese financial commitment, and fears of unsustainable debt.
'These decisions can be assumed to be motivated by concerns over sustainability and Beijing's unwillingness to act like a responsible neighbour,' said Don McLain Gill, a geopolitical analyst at De La Salle University in Manila.
Pakistan has been among the hardest-hit BRI partners. Many projects under the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC) failed to deliver promised returns or even operate as intended. Islamabad has had to scrap metro lines and coal-powered plants while delays led to major cost overruns.
The country's mounting debt to China made Beijing its largest external creditor. Genevieve Donnellon-May, a geopolitical adviser, noted that China's loans have faced increasing scrutiny for exacerbating Pakistan's debt burden and fueling accusations of 'debt trap diplomacy.'
Sri Lanka has shelved or cancelled several BRI projects due to heavy repayment obligations. Myanmar scaled back its participation years ago after watching Sri Lanka lose control of its Hambantota Port to China under debt pressure.
'Lessons that we learned from our neighbouring countries show that over-investment is not good sometimes,' said Soe Win, Myanmar's former planning minister and current deputy prime minister.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Qatar Tribune
8 hours ago
- Qatar Tribune
Zelensky to bring European leaders to White House
dpa Berlin/Paris European leaders, including France's Emmanuel Macron, Britain's Keir Starmer and German Chancellor Friedrich Merz, will join Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky for his key White House meeting with US President Donald Trump on Monday. European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen, Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni, Finnish President Alexander Stubb and NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte will also be attending the talks in Washington. The government in Berlin said that 'security guarantees, territorial issues, and the continued support for Ukraine in repelling Russian aggression' will be discussed. 'This also includes maintaining the pressure of sanctions. The trip serves as an exchange of information with US President Donald Trump following his meeting with Russian President Vladimir Putin in Alaska,' it said. In Paris, the Élysée Palace stated that Macron is going to continue the coordination work between the Europeans and the US with the aim of achieving a just and lasting peace. This peace must preserve Europe's security and the existential interests of Ukraine, it said. But before the discussions in Washington, Zelensky will be in Brussels on Sunday to participate in a video conference with a broad range of European leaders, von der Leyen said. Macron, Merz and Starmer are co-chairing the talks of the so-called Coalition of the Willing at 3pm (1300 GMT). The coalition is a loose grouping of nations backing Kiev against Russia's full-scale invasion launched in February 2022. The flurry of activity follows Friday's high-profile summit in Alaska between Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin. Despite Trump's warm welcome for the Kremlin leader, the meeting produced no breakthrough on halting the war. Trump's position on the conflict has swung sharply, at times faulting Ukraine for the invasion while at other moments threatening Moscow with punitive measures if progress toward a ceasefire stalls. On Saturday, he told Fox News that Ukraine needed to make a deal with Russia because 'Russia is a very big power, and they're not.' Trump also dropped the demand for an immediate ceasefire after the summit, opting for Putin's preferred option of a full peace deal to end the war. European capitals, wary of being sidelined, have been pushing to ensure their views - and Kiev's - are not excluded from the US-Russia dialogue that could shape Europe's long-term security. European leaders have urged an immediate ceasefire as a first step toward peace, demanded binding security guarantees for Ukraine, and warned Trump against trusting Putin's assurances. Zelensky, who was not invited to the Trump-Putin summit, is scheduled to meet Trump in Washington on Monday. He has insisted Ukraine must be included in all negotiations about its future, especially territorial questions. The leaders travelling to Washington will no doubt recall Zelensky's last meeting with Trump at the White House in February, which erupted into a heated shouting match on live television. The confrontation led the US to temporarily suspend its crucial military aid to Ukraine. Several media outlets reported after Friday's summit that Putin demanded full control of the occupied eastern Ukrainian regions of Donetsk and Luhansk in exchange for a ceasefire. Trump has often floated the idea of Russia and Ukraine 'swapping' territory to end the war. The proposal has alarmed Kiev, which has categorically rejected ceding any of its land to Moscow. Trump has said he hopes to eventually have a three-way meeting involving Zelensky and Putin.
Qatar Tribune
8 hours ago
- Qatar Tribune
Trump administration unveils stricter subsidy rules for wind, solar projects
Agencies The U.S. Treasury Department on Friday unveiled stricter rules for how solar and wind projects can qualify for federal tax subsidies that President Donald Trump's new tax and spending law is phasing out over the next two years. The revisions change longstanding definitions for what it means for a project to be considered under construction by requiring developers of big solar arrays and wind farms to complete physical work rather than simply show that they have invested changes are in response to an executive order Trump issued last month directing the Treasury Department to restrict tax credit eligibility unless a substantial portion of a facility is built. Since taking office in January, Trump has repeatedly sought to stall development of wind and solar energy, calling them unreliable, expensive, and overly dependent on Chinese supply chains. The One Big Beautiful Bill Act, which Trump signed into law last month, requires projects to begin construction by July of next year or enter service by the end of 2027 to qualify for a 30% tax credit and bonuses that can push the subsidy even higher. Under the new rules, which will affect projects that start construction as of September 2, utility-scale projects will be required to show substantial and continuous physical work to be eligible for the credits. They will still have four years to claim the subsidies. For the last decade, project developers had also been able to 'safe harbor' projects for four years by incurring 5% of total costs before a credit expired or stepped down to a lesser value. According to an agency document, 'substantial' work does not include permitting, design or holding components in inventory. Small projects of under 1.5 megawatts will still be able to use the 5% 'safe harbor' provision, Treasury said, a positive for the residential solar industry.
Qatar Tribune
8 hours ago
- Qatar Tribune
China rises up ‘elite quality' league table as AI investment booms
Agencies Thanks to its combined strengths in artificial intelligence and manufacturing, China rose two places to rank 19th out of 151 countries in the 2025 Elite Quality Index – a Swiss study that assesses the extent to which national elites create sustainable value for their nations. Singapore topped this year's rankings, followed by the United States and Switzerland, in the annual report produced by the Foundation for Value Creation Activities in partnership with the University of St. Gallen. Asian economies performed strongly overall, with Japan maintaining fourth place and South Korea rising to fifth. In contrast, several European countries including the Netherlands, Denmark and Finland fell down the rankings this year. 'China ranks at 19th in the index, up two places from last year, maintaining its upward trend in Elite Quality and an outcome that is particularly commendable given the dramatic changes in the global economic order,' the report said. The index assessed 151 countries based on 149 indicators, which are designed to gauge the overall impact of elite business models in terms of creating positive value or engaging in negative rent-seeking behaviour. China scored particularly highly in the AI value creation sub-index, placing fourth behind the US, Singapore and South Korea. This year's report increased the number of AI indicators from two to seven based on the industry's growing importance as a source of value creation. Zhang Jun, dean of the School of Economics at Shanghai's Fudan University, said China's rise in the rankings showed that its elite-led model of governance had been effective in promoting the country's economic development. 'However, it should be noted that compared to countries with higher rankings, such as Singapore, China's political elite needs to allow economic activities to become more market-oriented and strike a balance between strong state capacity and a more free economy,' he said. The study praised China's close integration of innovation and local industry, citing the city of Hangzhou – an emerging Chinese tech hub – as a model where entrepreneurial networks had become a core competitive advantage for the region's business ecosystem. Still, challenges remain at the national level. 'China must improve government AI readiness and better commercialise academic research to fully unlock its AI-era innovation potential,' Zhou Weihua, director of Zhejiang University's International Research Center for Data Analytics and Management, was quoted as saying in the report. China ranked 68th in the study's political power index, which measures national elites' influence over business regulation, rule-making and labour law, and 15th in terms of elites' contribution to markets and economic growth. Through its 'manufacturing-driven innovation' development model, China has accumulated technological capabilities and become globally competitive in areas such as new-energy vehicles, high-temperature superconductors and green factories, according to the study. Yet, China's ability to maintain high-quality growth will depend on providing sufficient opportunities for the younger generation, the report cautioned. China ranked only 68th in the 'next-generation value creation' indicator, which focuses on intergenerational value creation and transfer, indicating that opportunities for sustainable value creation for young people remain limited. While noting that China's opening-up policies had achieved significant results, the report said there was room for improvement in areas including economic globalisation (where the country ranked 102nd), protectionist measures (142nd), discriminatory interventions (145th), trade freedom (67th) and openness for business (52nd). Improving in these areas would also benefit China's younger generations, as continued exposure to global market forces and openness would create more job opportunities, the study added.
