Phillies Trade Idea Sends Nick Castellanos to Blue Jays After Benching
Phillies Trade Idea Sends Nick Castellanos to Blue Jays After Benching originally appeared on Athlon Sports.
If the Rafael Devers-Boston Red Sox stunner taught us anything, it's that any feud can lead to an unexpected trade.
Advertisement
Devers refused to switch positions and battled management, eventually leading to the Red Sox sending him to the San Francisco Giants for two pitchers and two prospects. We'll see whether or not the Philadelphia Phillies have a similar problem on their hands with All-Star right fielder Nick Castellanos.
Phillies manager Rob Thomson benched Castellanos on Tuesday, citing a negative comment the 33-year-old veteran made during Monday's 5-2 victory over the Miami Marlins. Castellanos evidently disagreed with Thomson's decision to pull him in the eighth inning for defensive reasons.
Could Castellanos' benching, even if it's only for one night, eventually lead to a trade? The Blue Jays should be asking themselves that exact question, and they should be ready to pounce if the Phillies are willing to talk.
Philadelphia Phillies right fielder Nick CastellanosRon Chenoy-Imagn Images
Castellanos has a season and a half remaining on the five-year, $100 million contract he signed after the 2020 season. He's admittedly been relatively average thus far, hitting .278 with seven home runs, 36 RBI, 17 doubles, and a .746 OPS.
Advertisement
Those numbers are all in line with last year's, though his bWAR has plummeted from 0.8 to -0.5.
However, Castellanos offers durability, and he'd undoubtedly be an upgrade in left field over rookie Alan Roden. Unfortunately for the Blue Jays, they're likely stuck with Anthony Santander and his .577 OPS at DH, given that he's in the first season of a five-year, $92.5 million contract.
Castellanos should come relatively cheap, and the Blue Jays are in an excellent position to make a playoff run. Toronto entered Tuesday at 38-33, holding the AL's second Wild Card berth and only four games out of first in the AL East.
Advertisement
As for the Phillies, ditching Castellanos could eventually pave the way for another outfield-related trade. Boston Red Sox star Jarren Duran has been linked to the Phillies in recent weeks, and Chicago White Sox veteran Luis Robert Jr. remains available.
The Devers-Red Sox feud arguably began with a position change. Might we eventually look back at a mid-game benching involving two NL East teams as the start of an eventual Blue Jays title run?
Related: MLB Makes Bryce Harper Announcement After Injury Update
Related: Phillies Share Bryce Harper Injury Update Amid Trade Rumors
This story was originally reported by Athlon Sports on Jun 17, 2025, where it first appeared.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBS News
6 minutes ago
- CBS News
Phillies beat Marlins 4-2
Bryson Stott hit a three-run homer, Ranger Suárez pitched seven effective innings and the Philadelphia Phillies beat the Miami Marlins 4-2 on Wednesday night. Suárez (6-1) permitted one run and four hits in another solid performance since his return from an early-season back injury. He struck out eight and walked two. The veteran left-hander has only allowed eight runs since giving up seven in his first start of the season on May 4. Stott capped Philadelphia's four-run fourth inning against Adam Mazur (0-1) with his fifth homer of the season. J.T. Realmuto hit an RBI single before Stott drove a first-pitch fastball deep to center. Mazur struck out five and allowed five hits in 5 2/3 innings in his Marlins debut. He was recalled from Triple-A Jacksonville. The Marlins closed to 4-2 in the ninth on Dane Myers' one-out RBI single. They had a runner in scoring position before Matt Strahm struck out Connor Norby and got Nick Fortes to fly out for his fourth save. Alec Bohm singled twice and doubled for Philadelphia in his second multihit outing of the series and sixth in his last nine games overall. Nick Castellanos doubled and singled in his return to Philadelphia's lineup after being benched the day before for making "an inappropriate comment" when he was pulled for a defensive replacement on Monday. Norby hit a solo shot off Suárez that went 415 feet to center to make it 4-1 in the fifth. Key moment Jack Winkler got his first major league hit against Strahm in the ninth. Key stat Stott has pitched six or more innings in each of his eight starts since his rough season debut in which he gave up seven runs in 3 2/3 innings against Arizona. Up next LHP Christopher Sánchez (5-2, 3.05 ERA) will start for the Phillies on Thursday against Marlins RHP Edward Cabrera (2-2, 4.10 ERA).
Yahoo
10 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Nick Castellanos returns to Phillies lineup after benching for 'inappropriate comment'
MIAMI (AP) — Nick Castellanos returned to the Philadelphia Phillies lineup for their game against the Miami Marlins on Wednesday after being benched the day before for 'an inappropriate comment' the outfielder made when he was pulled for a defensive replacement on Monday. 'It's gone. It's gone. We're good,' manager Rob Thomson said Wednesday of the benching, which ended Castellanos' streak of 236 consecutive starts. Advertisement Castellanos played right field and singled in four at-bats against the Marlins on Monday before Johan Rojas replaced him in the bottom of the eighth with Philadelphia up 3-1. Max Kepler moved to right and Rojas played center. Thomson said after Monday's game he had intended to insert Rojas behind Philadelphia's right-handed pitching and indicated that could be the plan moving forward. Thomson added Wednesday that approach 'just depends on the situations.' When asked if he would be OK with taking Castellanos out in a similar situation on Wednesday, Thomson said, 'Probably not today." The plan was also for Castellanos to only be benched for Tuesday's game, Thomson added. The Phillies lost that matchup 8-3. Advertisement The 33-year-old Castellanos is in his fourth season with the Phillies, who are second in the NL East. He's hitting .278 with seven homers and 36 RBIs. ___ AP MLB: The Associated Press
Associated Press
25 minutes ago
- Associated Press
Bryson Stott hits a 3-run homer to help the Phillies beat the Marlins 4-2
MIAMI (AP) — Bryson Stott hit a three-run homer, Ranger Suárez pitched seven effective innings and the Philadelphia Phillies beat the Miami Marlins 4-2 on Wednesday night. Suárez (6-1) permitted one run and four hits in another solid performance since his return from an early season back injury. He struck out eight and walked two. The veteran left-hander has only allowed eight runs since giving up seven in his first start of the season on May 4. Stott capped Philadelphia's four-run fourth inning against Adam Mazur (0-1) with his fifth homer of the season. J.T. Realmuto hit an RBI single before Stott drove a first-pitch fastball deep to center. Mazur struck out five and allowed five hits in 5 2/3 innings in his Marlins debut. He was recalled from Triple-A Jacksonville. The Marlins closed to 4-2 in the ninth on Dane Myers' one-out RBI single. They had a runner in scoring position before Matt Strahm struck out Connor Norby and got Nick Fortes to fly out for his fourth save. Alec Bohm singled twice and doubled for Philadelphia in his second multihit outing of the series and sixth in his last nine games overall. Nick Castellanos doubled and singled in his return to Philadelphia's lineup after being benched the day before for making 'an inappropriate comment' when he was pulled for a defensive replacement on Monday. Norby hit a solo shot off Suárez that went 415 feet to center to make it 4-1 in the fifth. Key moment Jack Winkler got his first major league hit against Strahm in the ninth. Key stat Stott has pitched six or more innings in each of his eight starts since his rough season debut in which he gave up seven runs in 3 2/3 innings against Arizona. Up next LHP Christopher Sánchez (5-2, 3.05 ERA) will start for the Phillies on Thursday against Marlins RHP Edward Cabrera (2-2, 4.10 ERA). ___ AP MLB:
