‘Same as Phala Phala' – Police committee member not optimistic about Mchunu investigations
The portfolio committee on police and the portfolio committee on justice and constitutional development officially adopted their report, recommending to the National Assembly that an ad hoc committee be established to consider allegations made by KwaZulu-Natal police commissioner, Lieutenant General Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi.
The committees held a joint meeting on Tuesday, during which they agreed that an ad hoc Committee was the most effective parliamentary mechanism for fully investigating Mkhwanazi's allegations.
The report further proposed that the National Assembly establish the committee within three months.
Mchunu allegations a 'constitutional crisis'
'What makes this matter urgent is that the issue of the law will be heavily challenged,' said committee member and MK party MP David Mandla Skosana.
'Solomon Mahlangu was hanged because of the so-called law, and General Mkhwanazi went out and said he wants to see justice prevail, and society is waiting for us. If the legal opinion comes against us, we must have a Plan B, because we can't sing the same song like in the 1940s, 1960s and 1970s.
ALSO READ: Senzo Mchunu investigation will take longer to finalise, says Public Protector
'We are the seventh administration. We must see this thing succeed, irrespective of all these other bureaucratic issues, which we will have to address in this matter.'
'Public Protector investigation'
Skosana further expressed a lack of confidence in the investigation being conducted by the Office of the Public Protector.
Public Protector Kholeka Gcaleka was special advisor to Mchunu when he was Minister of Public Service and Administration.
ALSO READ: Mchunu denies ties to Cat Matlala, as tenderpreneur bust with cellphone in prison
'The country is in crisis. For us to say the public protector will come up with something, I can tell you, it will be the same song as in Phala Phala and what we have seen in other matters, because people are closing ranks here,' said Skosana.
'It's painful for some of us to say these things here, to say we know the end product is. We should go into this matter with our eyes wide open. We have already seen utterances in the media. The suspended minister has now said things, and the so-called appointed minister.
'We have a constitutional crisis in this country, and we must accept that it's not going to be smooth sailing. I don't have confidence in the so-called commission because at the end of the day, once there is politics at play here, there is no justice. What is going to happen at the end of the day is exactly what happened with the Phala Phala report.
WATCH: Mbalula warns of deepfake video falsely claiming he said Senzo Mchunu is guilty
'In this issue, we need justice, because if our law is not going to restore dignity and the public trust in the Saps [South African Police Service] and the judiciary, then we're just buying time, and it's just optics. We need to get to the bottom of this. There should not be anything between us and the truth.'
'Code of ethics'
On Thursday, 10 July, the Public Protector confirmed its investigation into Mchunu, as requested by the African Transformation Movement (ATM).
'In line with section 3(1) of EMEA, which provides that the Public Protector must investigate any alleged breach of the code of ethics on receipt of a complaint contemplated in section 4, you are hereby advised that the Public Protector has initiated an investigation into the allegations you have raised,' the office said.
ALSO READ: Mchunu denies ties to Cat Matlala, as tenderpreneur bust with cellphone in prison
The party laid at least four complaints against Mchunu, including allegations of enabling interference by outside parties in Saps operations, irregularly disbanding the Political Killings Task Team, unduly delaying and derailing investigations and a conflict of interest in the awarding of a R360 million Saps contract to Matlala.
However, the Public Protector cautioned that the investigation into the matter would not be finalised within 30 days, 'due to the number of issues raised in your complaint'.
'The Public Protector will therefore submit a report when the investigation has been finalised.
'We commit, in the circumstances, to make every effort to expedite the finalisation of the investigation and will accordingly continue to keep you apprised of the progress thereof.'
READ NEXT: Magashule says Mchunu should step aside, but ANC says there is no need for that
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
15 hours ago
- The Citizen
ConCourt sets date for MK party's case against Ramaphosa over Mchunu
Former President Jacob Zuma and the MK party are seeking to invalidate Ramaphosa's decision to place Mchunu on a leave. The Constitutional Court has set down a date to hear the MK party's urgent application against President Cyril Ramaphosa to place Police Minister Senzo Mchunu on leave. Former President Jacob Zuma and the MK party are seeking to invalidate Ramaphosa's decision to place Mchunu on a leave of absence and appoint Wits law Professor Firoz Cachalia as acting police minister. They are also challenging Ramaphosa's establishment of a judicial commission of inquiry to investigate allegations of corruption in the police. 'Applicants must file heads of argument by Sunday, 27 July 2025, at 14h00. Respondents must file heads of argument by Monday, 28 July 2025, at 14h00,' the court directed. The matter has been set down for Wednesday, 30 July at 11am. ALSO READ: Zuma says Ramaphosa has no constitutional power to suspend Mchunu Allegations KwaZulu-Natal (KZN) Provincial Commissioner Lieutenant General Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi made explosive allegations during a media briefing this month, accusing Mchunu and Deputy National Commissioner for Crime Detection, Shadrack Sibiya, of political interference in police operations. In Ramaphosa's answering affidavit on Wednesday, the president argued that the constitution gives him 'a wide berth as to how to deal with ministers' 'It is clear that I am empowered to place a minister on special leave when there are serious allegations… so that those allegations can be properly investigated,' said Ramaphosa. However, Zuma argues there's no express constitutional power allowing Ramaphosa to impose special leave on Mchunu. ALSO READ: Ramaphosa motion of no confidence: MK party requests secret ballot Zuma challenge Zuma said there are details in Ramaphosa's affidavit that Mchunu will not return as minister of police after the commission of inquiry. 'There is nothing said in the president's affidavit which justified placing Minister Mchunu on 'special leave' and thereby causing him to retain his ministerial title, salary and other perks or privileges at the expense of the long-suffering taxpayer'. Feroz Cacahlia Zuma said Ramaphosa 'openly dodges' the clear distinction between the power to appoint a minister and the different power to appoint an acting minister. 'The two are plainly not the same. The obfuscatory reference to the credentials of Prof Cachalia is nothing but deflection. For the record, no issue is taken against the professor's credentials… The issue is whether he was constitutionally qualified to be appointed by the president. The answer is that he was not.' Zuma also challenged Mchunu's version of events, portraying it as 'evasive and legally flawed', saying the minister's affidavit is a 'masterclass in evasion – it skirts the core allegations and offers no constitutional basis for the executive's conduct.' ALSO READ: Here's why Zuma's MK party wants Ramaphosa removed in 'urgent' motion of no confidence
The Citizen
a day ago
- The Citizen
Parliament fire: Over R500m already spent as restoration project now expected to cost R4.4bn
The reconstruction of Parliament is expected to be completed in late 2026. Smoke billows out of the National Assembly building after the fire at Parliament on 2 January 2022 in Cape Town. Picture: Gallo Images More than R500 million has already been spent on repairing Parliament after a fire in 2022, with the total cost of the reconstruction project now projected to reach R4.4 billion. This was revealed during a meeting of the joint standing committee on the financial management of parliament on Friday. MPs received updates on the investigation into the fire that destroyed parliament, which was not insured, as well as progress made in the ongoing restoration efforts. The Development Bank of South Africa (DBSA) provided detailed briefings on the restoration process, while officials from the auditor-general's office dealt with the financial management of the project. Sections of the National Assembly and Old Assembly buildings suffered major damage during the fire on 2 January 2022. The reconstruction is expected to be completed in late 2026 following delays that have extended the original deadline. Zandile Mafe, who admitted to starting the fire and was charged with terrorism and arson, was declared unfit to stand trial in December 2023. Parliament fire: Restoration progress Chuene Ramphele, DBSA group executive for infrastructure delivery, said during the meeting that work was initially stalled as the parliamentary site was treated as a crime scene and secured by police. 'Technically, the work actually started in March 2023,' he told the joint committee. Ramphele said that significant progress had been made since work officially began, including the construction of 155 offices for MPs on Plein Street. 'At this stage, our focus is primarily on the refurbishment,' he said. ALSO READ: Macpherson accused of being 'weak' after saying he's being sidelined over Parliament fire He said that demolition works were completed in March 2024 and came in under budget at R73 million, saving R2 million in the process. Due to design changes and necessary statutory approvals, the initial R2 billion budget had risen. 'When we concluded the detailed designs, you'll see that we started to be very sure of what are the detailed costs,' Ramphele said. 'After the final approval and the designs, the budget for both the refurbishment of the National Assembly and Old Assembly buildings amounted to R3.6 billion.' Watch the meeting below: Ramphele also said the DBSA is applying a risk-monitoring approach to minimise the impact of unforeseen challenges, such as bad weather, given the tight timeline. The revised total budget includes R900 million allocated for upgrading the information and communications technology (ICT) infrastructure. National Assembly construction Ramphele said that Raubex Construction was awarded a R2.27 billion contract to work on the new National Assembly wing. 'The site was handed over in April after having appointed [the company] in December 2024,' he said. He noted that the delay was caused by difficulties in obtaining a construction permit from the department of labour. READ MORE: Parliament quietly reclaims its power 'We could not start if we did not have the construction permit and also making sure that the occupational safety issues are intact to avoid any issues because our biggest risk that we want to mitigate is to ensure there is no fatality on the site or any particular kind of incident.' Ramphele told the committee that guarantees are in place to manage the contractor's performance in case of failure to deliver. 'Other things about the project contract management in place is how we are going to manage the penalties and the penalty regimes that are going to apply in that regard.' Timelines At the moment, work is focused on the basement and structural foundations, including support pillars for two additional floors and a new roof structure. 'At this point in time, the work is happening underground,' he said, adding that 'we want a climate resilient Parliament'. Ramphele said that once the three basement levels are complete, the team will begin construction of the first through sixth floors, including beams and slabs. READ MORE: Parliament allocates R71m for medical aid for former MPs This phase will take approximately 12 months, with the project expected to reach 40% completion by April 2026. Interior finishes – including flooring, toilets, offices, committee rooms, the public gallery and a banquet hall – will require another 18 months, pushing projected progress to 75% by September 2026. Ramphele said the full restoration of the new National Assembly is expected to be completed within 20 months. 'At that point, we will be looking at commissioning the building. In particular we are looking at November 2026. So at that time, the building will be practically complete.' Old Assembly restoration According to Ramphele, a contractor for the Old Assembly building was appointed last month. The R1.3 billion project is expected to take 18 months. Ramphele confirmed that the site has already been handed over to the contractor. He concluded with an update on the overall cost of the parliamentary restoration. 'So far, we have already spent, with what has been happening and what we have done, R574 million. 'Ultimately, the entire programme of Parliament is at a cost of around R4.4 billion with the major items being the National Assembly and Old Assembly.' NOW READ: Reconstruction of Parliament to finally begin – will include gym, sauna and daycare centre
The South African
a day ago
- The South African
MK Party wants secret ballot for Ramaphosa no-confidence vote
The uMkhonto weSizwe (MK) Party has requested that the Motion of No Confidence against President Cyril Ramaphosa be conducted via a secret ballot. The party's parliamentary leader, Dr John Hlophe, wrote a formal request to the Speaker of Parliament, Thoko Didiza. He believes that a secret ballot will ensure that Members of Parliament (MPs) can exercise their constitutional duty freely, without fear of intimidation. According to Hlophe, the request aligns with Rule 129 of the National Assembly Rules. Given the sensitive nature of the motion, the MK Party believes a secret ballot is necessary to protect the integrity of the process. Hlophe said the ballot must reflect principles of accountability and transparency, and protect MPs' freedom to vote according to their conscience. 'A secret ballot will safeguard the integrity of the voting process and ensure that the outcome reflects the true will of the MP,' said Hlophe. Hlophe further called on Speaker Didiza to consult with relevant stakeholders and to make an urgent decision on the matter. The MK Party filed the motion on Tuesday, 22 July. The party cited President Ramaphosa's dismissal of Police Minister Senzo Mchunu and the appointment of Acting Police Minister Firoz Cachalia as the basis for its action. Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 11. Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp, Facebook, X and Bluesky for the latest news
