US-India tech ties must be driven by market forces, not just state support: Ashley J. Tellis at Carnegie Summit
New Delhi : Ashley J. Tellis, Tata Chair for Strategic Affairs and Senior Fellow at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, offered a candid analysis of the evolving US approach to global technology partnerships under a potential second Trump administration and the broader implications for the US-India relationship, at the Carnegie Global Tech Summit held in New Delhi on Friday.
On the US-India technology partnership, Tellis argued that while state-led initiatives and subsidies are useful to jumpstart cooperation, they are not a viable long-term model.
He stated, "I do not believe that a sustainable path for the US-India Relationship is through state action and state subsidies. Those are very good to jump-start the process, but if we have to keep it sustainable, we need to really have market transformations in both countries that essentially permit innovation to respond to the pressures of the market."
Tellis pointed out a shift in US policy priorities, stating, "I think the bias in the Trump administration is to sell services. And given that bias, it is very likely that there will be much greater technology acquisition opportunities over here and for the rest of the world. Now, what it does to a certain conception of global order is a very different question."
However, he cautioned that such a transactional approach could undermine long-standing frameworks designed to preserve the global order.
He said, "For 70 years now, we tried to help our friends while at the same time maintaining a proliferation regime that would date to a certain conception of order. Now, if we end up in a situation where the price of helping our friends is to engulf the regime simultaneously, I'm not quite sure long-term US interests are at hand, nor am I sure that the interests of our friends are at hand. What is even worse is that I'm not sure the administration has the discipline to understand the issues at hand."
Tellis expressed concern over whether future U.S. administrations would have the strategic discipline to manage these complexities. "Time will tell whether, net-net, we come out ahead," he said.
© Muscat Media Group Provided by SyndiGate Media Inc. (Syndigate.info).
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sharjah 24
37 minutes ago
- Sharjah 24
Trump signs proclamation banning citizens from 12 countries
Part of broader immigration crackdown The directive is part of Trump's broader immigration agenda in his second term, which includes mass deportations, restrictions on student visas, and removal of suspected gang members—especially Venezuelans—back to their home country. Countries affected by the travel ban The ban fully restricts entry from the following 12 countries: Afghanistan, Myanmar, Chad, Congo, Equatorial Guinea, Eritrea, Haiti, Iran, Libya, Somalia, Sudan, and Yemen. In addition, Burundi, Cuba, Laos, Sierra Leone, Togo, Turkmenistan, and Venezuela face partial travel restrictions. Trump: Security first In a video posted on X, Trump said: 'We will not allow people to enter our country who wish to do us harm.' He noted that the list could be revised and that new countries might be added. The order goes into effect on June 9, 2025, at 12:01 a.m. EDT. Visas issued before that date will remain valid. African Union expresses concern The African Union Commission raised concerns about the impact of the travel ban on diplomacy, trade, and educational exchanges. In a statement, it called on the US to engage in 'constructive dialogue' with the affected nations and adopt a more consultative approach. Background: Trump's previous travel bans During his first term (2017–2021), Trump imposed a travel ban on seven Muslim-majority countries—a policy that faced legal battles but was eventually upheld by the Supreme Court in 2018. His successor, Joe Biden, repealed the ban in 2021, calling it 'a stain on our national conscience.' Reasons cited for ban Trump said the most heavily restricted countries harbor a strong terrorist presence, lack proper identity verification systems, and have poor visa record-keeping and high overstay rates. 'We cannot have open migration from any country where we cannot safely and reliably vet and screen those who seek to enter,' he said. He referenced a recent incident in Colorado involving a gasoline bomb attack by an Egyptian national with an expired visa, although Egypt is not on the current ban list. Mixed international reactions Somalia pledged to work with the U.S. to address concerns, reaffirming its strong ties with Washington. In contrast, Venezuelan Interior Minister Diosdado Cabello criticized the ban, calling the US government fascist and warning Venezuelans of the risks of staying in the U.S. Other countries, including Afghanistan and Myanmar, did not immediately respond to the policy. Personal Impact: Programmes and dreams disrupted The ban has already begun to affect individuals. A 31-year-old teacher from Myanmar, accepted into a U.S. exchange programme, said her plans are now uncertain. 'It is not easy to apply nor get accepted,' she said, expressing frustration at the lack of updates after the ban announcement. Policy roots and political strategy Trump previewed this expanded travel ban during a 2023 campaign speech, targeting several regions including Gaza, Libya, and Somalia. He also signed an executive order in January requiring stricter vetting for all foreign nationals entering the US Initial report and media coverage The new travel restrictions were first reported by CBS News, while Reuters had earlier indicated that such measures were under consideration for dozens of countries.
Al Etihad
an hour ago
- Al Etihad
Tesla shares down as Trump fires back at ally Musk
5 June 2025 20:47 (REUTERS)Elon Musk, CEO of Tesla has stepped up criticism of the President Donald Trump's massive tax legislation in recent days. Investors are starting to shares dropped more than 5% on Thursday on a day otherwise devoid of news for the electric vehicle maker, leading traders to speculate that Musk's increasingly pointed rhetoric suggests strain in the relationship that has benefited his sprawling empire of Trump said on Thursday that Musk was upset because the bill took the EV mandate away."Look, Elon and I had a great relationship. I don't know if we will anymore," the president said."He said the most beautiful things about me. And he hasn't said bad about me personally. That'll be next. But I'm very disappointed."Trump's comments extended a decline in Tesla world's richest man, a key figure in the Department of Government Efficiency's (DOGE) cost-cutting initiative for several months, has blasted the bill, not long after he said he would spend less time in the White House and more time with his companies. On his social media platform X, Musk has called on Congress members to kill the legislation, calling it a "disgusting abomination.""It more than defeats all the cost savings achieved by the DOGE team at great personal cost and risk," Musk, the largest Republican donor in the 2024 election cycle, said on X on leadership of DOGE and his alignment with the Trump administration have put off some Tesla buyers. Sales of his EVs have slumped in Europe, China and key U.S. markets like California, even as overall electric vehicle purchases continue to has slowly started to separate himself from the White House in recent weeks, stung in part by the wave of protests against Tesla."Elon's politics continue to harm the stock. First he aligned himself with Trump which upset many potential Democratic buyers. Now he has turned on the Trump administration," said Tesla shareholder Dennis Dick, chief strategist at Stock Trader other businesses, SpaceX and Starlink, dominate their respective markets, but have also come under scrutiny due to Musk's relationship with two businesses often serve as the default choice for commercial launches and satellite internet deployment, and foreign governments have also increasingly looked to Starlink, with regulatory approvals smoothed by Musk's shares are down 12% since May 27, roughly coinciding with his decision to pull back from Washington stock has been on a roller-coaster ever since his endorsement of Trump in mid-July 2024 in his re-election bid, gaining 169% from that point through mid-December. That was followed by a 54% selloff through early April as a "Tesla Takedown" protest movement House of Representatives version of the budget bill proposes largely ending the popular $7,500 electric vehicle subsidy by the end of 2025. Tesla and other automakers have relied on incentives for years to drum up demand, but Trump promised during the transition to end the could face a $1.2 billion hit to its full-year profit, along with an additional $2 billion setback to regulatory credit sales due to separate Senate legislation targeting California's EV sales mandates, according to J.P. Morgan analysts."The budget bill contains bad stuff for Tesla with the end of the EV credits, and just generally his falling out with Trump has risks for Tesla and Elon's other companies," said Jed Ellerbroek, portfolio manager at Argent Capital public attacks have upset potential Republican Tesla buyers as well, Dennis Dick added. One White House official on Wednesday called the Tesla CEO's moves "infuriating."The billionaire joined Senate Republican deficit hawks this week in arguing that the House bill does not go far enough in reducing spending. Overall, Tesla shares are down 22% this year, including Thursday's losses. But the company is still the most valuable automaker worldwide by a long shot - carrying a market value of $1 trillion, far surpassing Toyota Motor's market value of about $290 billion. Tesla trades at 140.21 times profit estimates, a steep premium to other Big Tech stocks like Nvidia.
Khaleej Times
an hour ago
- Khaleej Times
Fighter pilot takes next giant step for India's space plans
Astronaut Shubhanshu Shukla blasts off into space next week as the first Indian to join the International Space Station (ISS), bearing with him New Delhi's dreams of its own manned space flight. An airforce fighter pilot, 39-year-old Shukla is joining a four-crew mission launching from the United States with private company Axiom Space, aboard a SpaceX Crew Dragon capsule. He will become the first Indian to join the ISS, and only the second ever in orbit -- an achievement that the world's most populous nation hopes will be a stepping stone for its own human flight. "I truly believe that even though, as an individual, I am travelling to space, this is the journey of 1.4 billion people," Shukla was quoted as saying by The Hindu newspaper this year. Shukla said he hopes to "ignite the curiosity of an entire generation in my country", and "drive the innovation that will make many such projects possible for us in the future". The airforce group captain -- equivalent to an army colonel or navy captain -- will pilot the commercial mission slated to launch June 10 from the Kennedy Space Center in Florida, a joint team between NASA and ISRO, the Indian Space Research Organisation. 'New era' India's Department of Space calls it a "defining chapter" in its ambitions, naming Shukla as "among the top contenders" for its maiden human spaceflight mission, Gaganyaan, "sky craft" in Hindi, scheduled for launch in 2027. "His journey is more than just a flight -- it's a signal that India is stepping boldly into a new era of space exploration," the Department of Space said ahead of the launch. New Delhi has paid more than $60 million for the mission, according to Indian media reports. Prime Minister Narendra Modi has announced plans to send a man to the Moon by 2040. India's ISRO said in May that it planned to launch an uncrewed orbital mission later this year, before its first human spaceflight in early 2027. Shukla's voyage comes four decades after Indian astronaut Rakesh Sharma joined a Russian Soyuz spacecraft in 1984. "What sets Shukla's mission apart is its strategic importance," the department added. "Unlike the symbolic undertones of India's first human spaceflight, this time the focus is on operational readiness and global integration." Shukla also trained in Russia, in 2020 along with three other astronaut hopefuls, at the Yuri Gagarin Cosmonaut Training Center -- before further training at ISRO's centre in the southern city of Bengaluru. He has said the journey aboard the Axiom Mission 4 -- and then the expected 14 days on the ISS -- will provide "invaluable" lessons to bring back home. - Space yoga - Shukla will be led by mission commander Peggy Whitson, a former NASA astronaut, and joined by European Space Agency project astronaut Slawosz Uznanski-Wisniewski of Poland, and Tibor Kapu of Hungary. The son of a government ministry official, from Lucknow in the northern state of Uttar Pradesh, Shukla is a veteran fighter pilot experienced in flying Russian Sukhoi and MiG jets. He has promised to perform yoga poses in the ISS. If he is unable to fly on Tuesday, fellow airforce pilot Group Captain Prasanth Balakrishnan Nair, 48, is expected to take his place. India has flexed its ambitions in the last decade with its space programme growing considerably in size and momentum, matching the achievements of established powers at a much cheaper price tag. In August 2023, it became just the fourth nation to land an unmanned craft on the Moon after Russia, the United States and China. Waiting at home will be Shukla's family, including his wife and son. "I've been having goosebumps by just thinking that soon my brother will be in space," his older sister Suchi, a school teacher, told the Times of India newspaper.
