Markets cheer tax stability as industry voices concerns
While appreciating, the government's decision to maintain current capital gains as a stabilizing force for investor sentiment, market analysts warned that increased taxes on various sectors could stifle growth in local industries, particularly auto manufacturing.
Muhammad Sohail, CEO of Topline Securities, termed the budget's unchanged Capital Gains Tax (CGT) and dividend tax rates as a positive development for the stock market. He noted that maintaining the current tax treatment avoids disrupting investor sentiments. Additionally, he highlighted other favourable measures, including the removal of tax exemptions for the FATA/ PATA regions and a reduction in super tax, which could improve corporate profitability.
Sohail emphasised that if the budget passes in line with IMF guidelines, it could serve as a catalyst for stock market re-rating, potentially lifting valuation multiples to their historic average of 7 times from the current 4.6 times.
The budget also introduced Section 114C, imposing restrictions on non-tax filers. These include limits on purchasing securities above a certain threshold, acquiring vehicles with engines exceeding 850cc, and opening Investor Portfolio Securities (IPS) accounts, except for Asan accounts.
Furthermore, the government raised the dividend tax rate to 25 percent for regular payouts and 15 percent for mutual fund distributions.
Sheryar Butt, a market analyst at Darson Securities, described the FY26 budget as largely market-friendly, with notable benefits for the fertilizer, banking, cement, and steel sectors. However, he warned that the auto industry could face headwinds due to increased duties and taxes.
JS Capital's analysis revealed further tax modifications across asset classes, including an interest income tax hike from 15 percent to 20 percent (excluding National Saving Certificate instruments), maintained 15 percent CGT for equities, and a new 25 percent tax on loan income to encourage equity investments.
Research says that the real estate sector will benefit from abolished 7 percent commercial construction excise duty and a proposed federal stamp duty reduction from 4 percent to 1 percent, with provincial adoption anticipated.
According to Shahid Ali Habib, CEO of Arif Habib Corporation, the budget maintains the existing capital gain and dividend tax rates. Notably, tax rates for debt mutual funds increased from 15 percent to 25 percent, while equity mutual funds remain at 15 percent. This change favours equity investments, making the stock market a more attractive option.
In contrast, Mashood Ali Khan, another commentator, expressed strong reservations, stating that the budget closely mirrors IMF recommendations without addressing structural issues in local manufacturing. He predicted a disastrous year for auto and ancillary industries, leading to a surge in import bills.
Experts agree that overall while the budget provides stability for capital markets, its broader economic implications, particularly for manufacturing and auto sectors, remain a point of contention among them.
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
12 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Gaps in anti-laundering efforts: IMF
The International Monetary Fund (IMF) has observed that Pakistan is not effectively using data on the ultimate real owners of companies, creating hurdles in disrupting corruption-related laundering schemes and checking front companies from securing government contracts. The global lender's draft report on the Governance and Corruption Diagnostic Assessment revealed major flaws in the effective implementation of the country's beneficial ownership regime. The IMF found "little evidence of routine coordination" between the Securities and Exchange Commission of Pakistan (SECP) and investigation agencies for exchanging and using beneficial ownership data in financial investigations. However, Pakistani authorities disagreed with the IMF's findings, stating that agencies were using beneficial ownership data, except in the case of Designated Non-Financial Businesses and Persons (DNFBPs). Pakistan tightened its beneficial ownership rules about eight years ago as part of Financial Action Task Force (FATF) conditions. However, as in many other cases, implementation remains far below the desired goals. The IMF stated that effective use of beneficial ownership information in financial investigations requires regular exchanges between the SECP, the State Bank of Pakistan (SBP), the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR), commercial banks, money service providers, and investigation agencies. The IMF's diagnostic mission recommended that Pakistan institutionalise a multi-agency working group to review beneficial ownership data in support of corruption investigations. The IMF noted that Pakistan's beneficial ownership framework is an important foundational tool, but weaknesses in registry implementation, verification, enforcement, and inter-agency access reduce its impact. "Addressing these challenges will be essential to ensuring that beneficial ownership transparency plays a meaningful role in the identification and disruption of corruption-related laundering schemes," the global lender observed. It added that access to accurate and timely beneficial ownership data is essential not only for detecting illicit financial flows but also for uncovering conflicts of interest in public procurement, particularly when public officials or their close associates have undisclosed stakes in bidding firms. Pakistani authorities said that, as part of effective inter-agency coordination, the SECP has provided direct access to its beneficial ownership database to investigation agencies. They said the Financial Monitoring Unit (FMU) was regularly using the data to analyse suspicious transactions. In 2018, the SECP directed companies to collect information about their real owners to address FATF concerns about transparency in company ownership structures. The directions had been given to uncover layers of secrecy hiding ultimate beneficial owners. All companies with legal persons as members or shareholders are required to obtain and maintain information from their members and shareholders about the ultimate beneficial owners. The minimum information required includes the owner's full name, father's or husband's name, NIC/NICOP/passport number, nationality, country of origin, email address, usual residential address, the date on which the name was entered into the register, and the date and reason the person ceased to be the beneficial owner. Section 453 of the Companies Act 2017 also requires every company officer to endeavour to prevent fraud and offences of money laundering, including predicated offences under the Anti-Money Laundering Act 2010, in relation to the company's affairs. However, the IMF found serious gaps in the implementation of these laws and rules, hindering the disruption of illicit money flows. Global bodies agree that collusive practices can only be mitigated by exposing front companies used to siphon public funds and by supporting fair competition in government contracting. The IMF said that ensuring contracting authorities, integrity bodies, and investigative agencies can effectively access and cross-reference beneficial ownership data with procurement records is critical to advancing governance reform and restoring public trust. The effectiveness of financial institutions and Designated Non-Financial Businesses and Professions (DNFBPs) in detecting and reporting corruption-linked transactions remains limited, the IMF stated. Pakistan's legal and regulatory framework requires reporting entities — including banks, money service businesses, and DNFBPs — to implement risk-based customer due diligence, conduct enhanced due diligence on politically exposed persons (PEPs), and file suspicious transaction reports (STRs). However, implementation is uneven and often inadequate in addressing high-risk areas associated with corruption. Pakistani authorities said some state agencies were actively using the SECP's online beneficial ownership database to enrich financial intelligence. The FMU continues to advocate improved access to beneficial ownership data for key stakeholders and stronger implementation of anti-money laundering obligations by reporting entities through targeted guidance, training, and inter-agency collaboration. Financial institutions have made notable progress in applying risk-based customer due diligence and conducting enhanced due diligence on politically exposed persons (PEPs). However, challenges remain, particularly in the DNFBP sector, where the level of technical capacity, compliance culture, and supervisory coverage vary, according to Pakistani authorities.
Express Tribune
2 days ago
- Express Tribune
Railways set for major overhaul
Federal Minister for Railways Muhammad Hanif Abbasi on Wednesday outlined a comprehensive roadmap to revamp Pakistan Railways, saying that transformational progress was already underway despite limited resources. Responding to legislators' queries during the National Assembly's question-hour session, he said that passenger amenities had been substantially upgraded at major stations, including Rawalpindi City, Cantt, Raiwind, Khanewal and Multan, now aligned with modern standards for cleanliness, restroom facilities and waiting areas. He added that a state-of-the-art upgraded station was set to be inaugurated in Karachi on September 10, modelled after recent upgrades in Lahore. Stations in Hyderabad, Sukkur and Faisalabad would follow suit on September 30, with the full transformation of all major stations targeted for completion by December 31, 2025, and all smaller stations by June 2026. "We are committed to offering international-standard services to every class of passenger – economy, business and VIP, and I guarantee the facilities will match those seen in developed countries," Abbasi stated. On freight services, the minister noted that despite a shortage of rolling stock and wagons, Pakistan Railways had managed to operate an efficient nationwide cargo network originating from Sindh, generating significant revenue in the past year. "Freight is the backbone of rail systems worldwide. We're now moving toward a turnaround in this segment as well," he affirmed. Abbasi further said that the Narowal section had resumed operations after a 12-year hiatus, and the Musa Pak Express had been revived from Multan. Collaborations with the governments of Punjab, Sindh and Balochistan were underway to uplift and restore additional routes. "We're working on agreements with Sindh to restore discontinued routes, and discussions are ongoing with CM Sindh this month. Similar cooperation with Balochistan has enabled a 50km uplift from Sheikh Zaid to Kuchlak," he said. When he assumed office, Abbasi said, he had focused on three key service areas: punctuality, cleanliness, and food quality. He noted that the efforts had yielded measurable improvements, with punctuality now reaching 90 to 95 per cent on certain routes such as Lahore-Rawalpindi. Addressing a question on mass transit, the minister clarified that Pakistan Railways was not directly involved in projects like the Karachi Circular Railway (KCR) or Lahore Metro, as such initiatives had fallen under provincial jurisdiction after the 18th Amendment. However, he added, the ministry was available to extend technical support when requested. In a landmark development, Abbasi highlighted progress on the transnational rail link from Kohat to Mazar-i-Sharif via Kharlachi. The project, part of the regional connectivity initiative envisioned during the PDM government, had seen diplomatic and technical advances, including a trilateral signing ceremony in Kabul with Afghan and Uzbek counterparts. "The 850-km link to Central Asia, with an existing 75-km track inside Uzbekistan, will be a game-changer. A feasibility study will be completed by December 31 this year," he announced. "We've already allocated $5 million, matched by Uzbekistan, while Afghanistan has assured full security for the route." Abbasi revealed that the Karachi-Rohri section (480 km) was nearing final agreement with a financial institution, while the Lahore-Rawalpindi segment — also part of ML-1 — had received a Rs250 billion allocation in Punjab's budget. "The groundwork for Karachi-Rohri and Lahore-Rawalpindi is expected to begin next year," he added, noting that negotiations for the remaining segments were ongoing with multiple stakeholders. He said that the most modern station in the 77-year history of Pakistan Railways would be inaugurated in Karachi on September 10.
Business Recorder
2 days ago
- Business Recorder
Local, forex issuer and senior unsecured: Moody's upgrades debt ratings to ‘Caa1'
ISLAMABAD: Moody's Ratings (Moody's) on Wednesday upgraded the government of Pakistan's local and foreign currency issuer and senior unsecured debt ratings to Caa1 from Caa2. The rating agency also upgraded the rating for the senior unsecured MTN programme to (P)Caa1 from (P)Caa2 and concurrently, changed the outlook for the government of Pakistan to stable from positive. The upgrade to Caa1 reflects Pakistan's improving external position, supported by its progress in reform implementation under the IMF Extended Fund Facility (EFF) program. Foreign exchange reserves are likely to continue to improve, although Pakistan will remain dependent on timely financing from official partners, it added. Govt presents 'compelling evidence' of Pakistan's economic recovery to Moody's Moody's said the upgrade to Caa1 reflects Pakistan's improving external position, supported by its progress in reform implementation under the International Monetary Fund (IMF) Extended Fund Facility (EFF) programme. It said foreign exchange reserves are likely to continue to improve, although Pakistan will remain dependent on timely financing from official partners. The rating agency said that the sovereign's fiscal position is also strengthening from very weak levels, supported by an expanding tax base. Its debt affordability has improved, but remains one of the weakest among rated sovereigns. The Caa1 rating also incorporates the country's weak governance and high political uncertainty. In the report it is further stated that the stable outlook reflects balanced risks to Pakistan's credit profile. 'On the upside, improvements in the debt service burden and external profile could be more rapid than we currently expect. On the downside, there remains risks of delays in reform implementation required to secure timely official financing, which would in turn weaken Pakistan's external position again,' Moody's remarked. Moody's said the upgrade to Caa1 from Caa2 rating also applies to the backed foreign currency senior unsecured ratings for 'The Pakistan Global Sukuk Programme Co Ltd'. 'The associated payment obligations are, in our view, direct obligations of the Government of Pakistan. Concurrently, we changed the outlook for The Pakistan Global Sukuk Programme Co Ltd to stable from positive, mirroring the stable outlook on the Government of Pakistan', it added. Concurrent to this action, Moody's also raised Pakistan's local and foreign currency country ceilings to B2 and Caa1 from B3 and Caa2, respectively. The two-notch gap between the local currency ceiling and sovereign rating is driven by the government's relatively large footprint in the economy, weak institutions, and high political and external vulnerability risk. The two-notch gap between the foreign currency ceiling and the local currency ceiling reflects incomplete capital account convertibility and relatively weak policy effectiveness. It also takes into account risks of transfer and convertibility restrictions being imposed. Moody's further stated Pakistan's external position has continued to strengthen over the past year. 'We expect further gradual improvements as progress in reform implementation under the IMF program supports financing from bilateral and multilateral partners. In turn, this contributes to continued increases in the sovereign's foreign exchange reserves, albeit from still fragile levels,' Moody's added. Moody's said Pakistan fully met its external debt obligations and added to its foreign exchange reserves in fiscal year 2025 (ending June 2025). Reserves rose to $14.3 billion as of 25 July 2025, equivalent to about ten weeks of imports. This compares with $9.4 billion at the time of its last rating action in August 2024, and is about triple the level compared to end-June 2023. The agency stated that Pakistan successfully completed the first review of the IMF programme on schedule, unlocking a $1 billion disbursement from the IMF in May 2025. It also secured a $1 billion commercial loan in June 2025, with a $500 million policy-based guarantee by the Asian Development Bank (ADB). Moody's expect Pakistan to fully meet its external debt obligations for the next few years, contingent on steady progress on reform implementation and timely completion of IMF reviews. It stated the sovereign has unlocked new sources of financing with a 28-month arrangement under the IMF Resilience and Sustainability Facility (RSF) worth about $1.4 billion and a ten-year country partnership framework with the World Bank for fiscal year 2026-2035, with an indicative financing envelope of $20 billion. Moody's pointed out that Pakistan's external position remains fragile. Its foreign exchange reserves remain well below what is required to meet is external debt obligations, underscoring the importance of steady progress with the IMF programme to continually unlock financing. It estimates Pakistan's external financing needs are about $24-25 billion in fiscal year 2026, and similar amounts again in fiscal year 2027. Moody's said Pakistan's fiscal position has improved from very weak levels, reflecting progress in implementing revenue-raising measures. The budget deficits are narrowing and primary surpluses are widening. The government debt affordability is also improving, although it remains one of the weakest among our rated sovereigns. The government has strengthened its revenue collection through a combination of better enforcement and new tax measures. Government revenues rose to about 16 percent of GDP in fiscal year 2025 from 12.6 percent in fiscal year 2024, led by a large increase in tax revenues, amounting to about 2 percentage points of GDP. The government's non-tax revenues also rose sharply due to a one-off extraordinary dividend from the State Bank of Pakistan (SBP), the central bank. 'We expect the government to continue enhancing revenue administration and compliance, alongside the introduction of new tax measures. We estimate tax revenues to pick up by another 0.5 percentage points of GDP in fiscal year 2026. However, a decline in SBP dividends will lead to an overall narrowing of government revenue to about 15-15.5 percent of GDP,' it added. The rating agency stated that it expects the government expenditure to remain contained, even as budgeted defence spending has increased. The government has gradually cut subsidies to the power sector alongside progress with energy sector reforms. Debt servicing costs are also reduced due to declining domestic interest rates in tandem with lower policy rates. Overall, the fiscal deficit is expected to narrow further to 4.5-5percent of GDP in fiscal year 2026 (FY2025: 5.4 percent). At the same time, we expect government interest payments to absorb about 40-45percent of revenue in 2026-2027, which is a marked decline from about 60 percent in fiscal year 2024, but remains very high internationally and a key credit constraint, it added. On the upside, improvements in the debt service burden and external profile could be more significant than it currently expect. A building track-record of reforms, including revenue-raising measures, that effectively safeguard macroeconomic stability could unlock more financing. In turn, this would further strengthen foreign exchange reserves and the sovereign's external position. Pakistan's debt affordability may also improve more significantly than it currently forecast. This could come from the government implementing additional revenue measures that broaden the tax base more than it currently assume. On the downside, there remains risks of slippage in reform implementation or results, leading to delays in or withdrawing of financing support from official partners. This could in turn lead to renewed material deterioration in the sovereign's external position. A number of previous IMF programmes were not completed, in part reflecting weak governance and institutional strength, compounded by a challenging domestic political environment. Moody's said the ratings would likely be upgraded if Pakistan's debt affordability and external position improved significantly, beyond its current expectations. This would likely be linked to marked progress in reform implementation which would accelerate external financing from official and commercial sources. Continued fiscal consolidation, including through implementing revenue-raising measures, pointing to a meaningful improvement in debt affordability beyond our current expectations would also be credit positive. The rating agency said the ratings would likely be downgraded if there were evidence of a renewed material increase in government liquidity or external vulnerability risks. This could come from financing strains due to delays in or withdrawal of support from multilateral and bilateral partners, leading to a rapid and significant decline in the foreign exchange reserves. An increase in social and political risks that disrupted policymaking and undermined Pakistan's ability to secure financing would also be credit negative. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
