How ‘Smurfs' points to the dire straits of the Best Animated Feature Oscar race
Meanwhile, the animated films that have been released in U.S. theaters in the past seven months are mostly a distant afterthought with audiences and critics. With a 20 percent score on Rotten Tomatoes and dismal tracking numbers, Paramount's attempt to relaunch the Smurfs franchise is unlikely to change 2025's unfortunate trajectory when it opens in theaters this weekend — even with Rihanna onboard as an executive producer and the new voice of Smurfette.
More from Gold Derby
'She dies with me': Shari Lewis' daughter talks Lamb Chop's final act - including a new TV show and that song that will never end
'The Late Show With Stephen Colbert': Reflecting on its Emmy legacy as cancellation shocks Hollywood
That leaves Oscar voters with little to root for — let alone vote for — in the Best Animated Feature category as we head into the second half of the year. Fortunately, there are some bright cartoony spots on the horizon, including In Your Dreams from Netflix, another SpongeBob Squarepants film from Paramount, and Disney's Zootopia 2, which is expected to run wild at the Thanksgiving box office. But in a category with five nominees, a couple more contenders are going to be required.
With that in mind, we looked back at the seven biggest animated titles released between January and July and ranked them by their Academy Awards potential. Just call us Oscar Smurf.
7. Sneaks (April 18)
Just barely released in theaters during the spring, this talking sneaker comedy didn't even crack $1 million at the domestic box office, despite the presence of an all-star cast including Anthony Mackie, Martin Lawrence, and Macy Gray. Critics' reactions hovered between baffled to bothered, with many noting that despite the similarity to Cars — i.e., giving life to otherwise inanimate objects — the animation quality was light years removed from Pixar. Even in a thin field, Sneaks is likely to remain at the bottom of 2025's animation locker.
6. Smurfs (July 18)
Fun fact: the latest Smurfs feature opens in theaters exactly 60 years after their first big-screen outing, 1965's The Adventures of the Smurfs, a now-lost compilation of black-and-white made-for-TV shorts starring the Belgian cartoon characters. A hand-drawn European-made original film followed in 1976 and then Hollywood took over in the 2000s, with Sony releasing three films between 2011 and 2017. None of those movies were Oscar contenders in their respective years and while the latest attempt is a modest improvement — one memorable scene finds Smurfette and her sidekick No Name Smurf (James Corden) racing through different animation styles, from anime to 8-bit video game — it's still, at heart, an I.P. grab. On the other hand, Rihanna does stand a legitimate shot at a Best Original Song nod for one of her earworm-y tunes ... if only so the Oscars can guarantee her presence (and a possible performance) at next year's ceremony.
5. The King of Kings (April 11)
Faith-based features rarely factor into the Oscar race in any medium, but this animated retelling of Jesus' life does boast an impressive vocal cast — including Mark Hamill, Uma Thurman, Kenneth Branagh, and Oscar Isaac as Christ himself. (Funnily enough, Isaac played Jesus' earthly dad, Joseph, in the 2006 film The Nativity Story opposite Keisha Castle-Hughes as Mary.) The Angel Studios-distributed movie also earned a solid $60 million at the box office, suggesting it found an audience outside of the genre's traditional crowd. But reviewers did note the saccharine tone and the mixed quality of the animation, which could be the deciding factor with Oscar voters.
4. KPop Demon Hunters (June 20)
A surprise Netflix smash when it dropped on the service in June, this delightful fusion of KPop and demon slaying has deservedly gone viral with younger audiences. The streaming service gave the movie an Oscar-qualifying limited theatrical run in New York and Los Angeles, which means it is eligible for the Animated Feature statuette. But the punk-rock title may prove to be a hindrance as voters sift through their many, many screeners. Let's hope their kids persuade them otherwise.
3. Dog Man (Jan. 15)
Believe it or not, the feature film version of Dav Pikey's beloved series of graphic novels remains the year's highest-grossing cartoon released in U.S. theaters with a $97 million tally. That alone makes it a strong contender for nomination, but Dog Man also offers beautifully stylized animation that brings the comic book characters to life and, as many have noted, the story is essentially RoboCop for kids. Not for nothing, but that Paul Verhoeven classic did receive a special achievement Oscar for Sound Effects Editing and was also nominated in the sound and film editing categories. Case closed.
2. Elio (June 20)
If it were released by any other major studio, Elio's mixed reviews and behind the scenes troubles would effectively end its Oscar campaign before it began. But the movie hails from Pixar, which has an industry-best track record of 19 Oscar nominations and 11 wins in this category for such contemporary classics as Finding Nemo, Up, and Coco. Even less-loved titles like Incredibles 2, Luca, and Elemental have earned nominations — and the studio is still hoping that Elio could stage an Elemental-like resurgence. In other words, Elio may be down, but he's not out.
1. Ne Zha 2 (Feb. 16)
While stateside animated features have been struggling commercially, China struck box-office gold with Ne Zha 2, which has crossed the $2 billion mark abroad. Roughly $20 million of that total came from the sequel's limited U.S. theatrical release in February. But expect that tally to grow now that A24 is releasing an English-language version in August with an eye towards entering the Oscar race. The vocal cast for that new release include Michelle Yeoh and presumably more A-listers to be named later, which should provide it with an extra boost among voters. Leaving aside its astonishing commercial success, Ne Zha 2 is among the most visually vibrant cartoon adventures of 2025, bringing Chinese mythology to the big screen in eye-popping ways.
Best of Gold Derby
Everything to know about 'The Batman 2': Returning cast, script finalized
Tom Cruise movies: 17 greatest films ranked worst to best
'It was wonderful to be on that ride': Christian Slater talks his beloved roles, from cult classics ('Heathers,' 'True Romance') to TV hits ('Mr. Robot,' 'Dexter: Original Sin')
Click here to read the full article.
Solve the daily Crossword
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Geek Tyrant
12 minutes ago
- Geek Tyrant
The SILVER SURFER Rock Opera Film Almost Made in the '80s With Olivia Newton-John and a Score by Paul McCartney — GeekTyrant
There was a moment in the '80s and early '90s when the Silver Surfer almost rode a wave of psychedelic rock straight onto the big screen. This nearly-made movie would've mashed up the philosophical space opera energy of 2001: A Space Odyssey with a soundtrack driven by a rock 'n' roll legend. Executive producer Lee Kramer had a vision, and it was wild. He once explained: 'We're going to make an epic picture on the scope of 2001: A Space Odyssey with the kind of soundtrack that that film had, only using contemporary rock 'n' roll. It's even conceivable that the Surfer might have a chant or a fanfare made up of one thousand electric guitars.' One. Thousand. Electric guitars. And if that wasn't ambitious enough, the soundtrack was supposed to be written by Paul McCartney. According to reports, the Beatles icon was approached, and interested, in scoring this cosmic jam session. It's the kind of idea that could only come out of the high-concept, high-risk creativity of the 1980s. The film would have focused solely on the Surfer, with Marvel having lost the rights to the Fantastic Four at the time. Kramer turned to Stan Lee and asked for a standalone story. Lee, teaming with Jack Kirby, crafted a new narrative that reimagined the Surfer's arrival on Earth and his defiance of Galactus, no Fantastic Four required. This version leaned harder into the existential elements of the character's arc and introduced an original character named Ardina, a female counterpart to the Surfer created by Galactus to lure his herald back. Why a female Silver Surfer? Because Kramer wanted a role for his girlfriend at the time… none other than Olivia Newton-John. This movie would've paired the shiny, brooding bodybuilder-turned-Surfer Frank Zane with Newton-John's luminous, rebellious space goddess. In this retelling, Ardina falls in love with the Surfer and ultimately sacrifices herself, forcing the Surfer to return to Galactus in order to save Earth. Shakespeare in space with killer lighting and synth. Concept art from the film, which you can see above, shows the chrome-plated Surfer floating alone in the void, staring into the reflective surface of his board. But, like many overly ambitious passion projects, it fell apart. Financing collapsed, and this gloriously over-the-top space rock opera was scrapped Still, if you're a fan of the Surfer or just weird, almost-happened Hollywood tales, it's hard not to sit back and imagine what could've been: a Silver Surfer movie scored by Paul McCartney, starring Olivia Newton-John, with a thousand electric guitars echoing through the cosmos. Honestly? Still sounds better than most of the other Fantastic Four films that have been made.
Yahoo
14 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Joel Edgerton and Felicity Jones in Netflix's ‘Train Dreams' trailer: Everything to know about Clint Bentley's ‘Sing Sing' follow-up
On Thursday, Netflix unveiled the teaser trailer for Train Dreams, directed by Clint Bentley and starring Joel Edgerton. The film premiered to critical acclaim at Sundance, currently holds a 97 percent rating on Rotten Tomatoes, and is already generating significant awards buzz. Bentley cowrote the screenplay with Greg Kwedar, marking their first collaboration since the Oscar-nominated Sing Sing. WHAT'S THE PLOT? The film follows Robert Grainier (Edgerton), a logger and railroad worker navigating life in the forests of the Pacific Northwest during early 20th-century America. It is adapted from Denis Johnson's Pulitzer Prize finalist novella of the same name. More from Gold Derby Eileen Davidson leads Daytime Emmy predictions for Best Drama Actress, but watch out for Nancy Lee Grahn 2025 Emmys: These are the episodes every Best Drama Supporting Actor nominee submitted Bentley has previously described the film as, 'a really special story and it feels very unique in that it is just about this one person's life. This very simple life. Robert Grainier doesn't do anything that really alters the course of history — he doesn't fight in some great battle or create some invention that changes people's lives, and yet he lives a very deep and rich life.' WHO'S IN THE CAST? Besides Edgerton, the film boasts an acclaimed cast that includes Academy Award nominees Felicity Jones, Kerry Condon and William H. Macy, as well as Nathaniel Arcand, Clifton Collins Jr., John Diehl, and Paul Schneider and is narrated by Will Patton. WHO ELSE IS BEHIND THE FILM The score is composed by Oscar nominee and multi-Grammy winner Bryce Dessner (The Two Popes, The Revenant). The film is produced by Marissa McMahon, Teddy Schwarzman, William Janowitz, Ashley Schlaifer, and Michael Heimler. WHEN IS THE RELEASE DATE? The film will make its international premiere at this year's Toronto International Film Festival, open in select theaters on Nov. 7 and debut on Netflix on Nov. 21. WATCH THE TRAILER Best of Gold Derby Everything to know about 'The Batman 2': Returning cast, script finalized Tom Cruise movies: 17 greatest films ranked worst to best 'It was wonderful to be on that ride': Christian Slater talks his beloved roles, from cult classics ('Heathers,' 'True Romance') to TV hits ('Mr. Robot,' 'Dexter: Original Sin') Click here to read the full article. Solve the daily Crossword
Yahoo
39 minutes ago
- Yahoo
White House lashes out at 'South Park' over spoof of small-penis Donald Trump seducing Satan: 'Desperate attempt'
A White House spokesperson has responded to the season 27 premiere in a statement to EW. One day after hitting back at The View over Joy Behar's claim that Donald Trump was jealous of Barack Obama's looks, the White House has again taken aim at a Hollywood institution in a statement to Entertainment Weekly criticizing South Park's satirical depiction of the president seducing Satan in bed. The show's delayed season 27 premiere — which was pushed back and ultimately moved from Comedy Central to Paramount+ amid parent company Paramount's pending merger with Skydance — included several scenes that showed a fictionalized version of Trump with a small penis. He later makes his way to a bedroom at the White House, where he undresses and gets into bed with Satan, who remarks on the size of the animated Trump's genitals. "The left's hypocrisy truly has no end — for years they have come after South Park for what they labeled as 'offense' content, but suddenly they are praising the show," White House spokesperson Taylor Rogers tells EW via email, adding that "just like the creators of South Park, the left has no authentic or original content" to premiere. "This show hasn't been relevant for over 20 years and is hanging on by a thread with uninspired ideas in a desperate attempt for attention," the statement continues. "President Trump has delivered on more promises in just six months than any other president in our country's history — and no fourth-rate show can derail President Trump's hot streak." EW has reached out to representatives for Paramount for a response. The season 27 premiere of South Park started with Trump engaged in a meeting with a satirical depiction of the prime minister of Canada. Then, after the meeting, Trump passes by an artist painting his portrait, with the president stopping to yell at them for giving him a small penis in the image. "What the f--- is this?" the fictionalized version of Trump asks. "Why is my dick so small?" The artist replies, "That's the size it is in the photo," which prompts his removal from the White House. The cartoon iteration of Trump then enters his bedroom, where he undresses, revealing that his genitals are the same size as in the painting, and then attempts to seduce Satan in bed. South Park's season 27 premiere came after a delay that led co-creators Trey Parker and Matt Stone to release a statement criticizing the Skydance merge in which they alleged that "it's f---ing up South Park." Paramount announced Wednesday that the South Park production had reached a deal with Paramount+ to license the classic animated show, including putting all previous 26 seasons and forthcoming first-run episodes on the streaming service instead of Comedy Central. The announcement came shortly after CBS network announced that the Trump-critical The Late Show With Stephen Colbert would end in May 2026, which provoked many late-night hosts to rally around Colbert and offer their support amid observations that the Federal Communications Commission needs to approve the Paramount/Skydance merger. South Park is now streaming on Paramount+. Read the original article on Entertainment Weekly