logo
How ‘Smurfs' points to the dire straits of the Best Animated Feature Oscar race

How ‘Smurfs' points to the dire straits of the Best Animated Feature Oscar race

Yahoo7 days ago
With apologies to Papa Smurf, it's been a rough smurfin' year for theatrical animation. The first half of 2025 has seen a box-office resurgence for family fare with A Minecraft Movie, How to Train Your Dragon and the billion-dollar-grossing Lilo & Stitch all racking up massive numbers. But all three of those movies were live-action features — albeit live-action features that used extensive amounts of computer animation. Stranger still, Lilo and Dragon were remakes of animated movies released by their respective studios, Disney and Universal, over a decade ago.
Meanwhile, the animated films that have been released in U.S. theaters in the past seven months are mostly a distant afterthought with audiences and critics. With a 20 percent score on Rotten Tomatoes and dismal tracking numbers, Paramount's attempt to relaunch the Smurfs franchise is unlikely to change 2025's unfortunate trajectory when it opens in theaters this weekend — even with Rihanna onboard as an executive producer and the new voice of Smurfette.
More from Gold Derby
'She dies with me': Shari Lewis' daughter talks Lamb Chop's final act - including a new TV show and that song that will never end
'The Late Show With Stephen Colbert': Reflecting on its Emmy legacy as cancellation shocks Hollywood
That leaves Oscar voters with little to root for — let alone vote for — in the Best Animated Feature category as we head into the second half of the year. Fortunately, there are some bright cartoony spots on the horizon, including In Your Dreams from Netflix, another SpongeBob Squarepants film from Paramount, and Disney's Zootopia 2, which is expected to run wild at the Thanksgiving box office. But in a category with five nominees, a couple more contenders are going to be required.
With that in mind, we looked back at the seven biggest animated titles released between January and July and ranked them by their Academy Awards potential. Just call us Oscar Smurf.
7. Sneaks (April 18)
Just barely released in theaters during the spring, this talking sneaker comedy didn't even crack $1 million at the domestic box office, despite the presence of an all-star cast including Anthony Mackie, Martin Lawrence, and Macy Gray. Critics' reactions hovered between baffled to bothered, with many noting that despite the similarity to Cars — i.e., giving life to otherwise inanimate objects — the animation quality was light years removed from Pixar. Even in a thin field, Sneaks is likely to remain at the bottom of 2025's animation locker.
6. Smurfs (July 18)
Fun fact: the latest Smurfs feature opens in theaters exactly 60 years after their first big-screen outing, 1965's The Adventures of the Smurfs, a now-lost compilation of black-and-white made-for-TV shorts starring the Belgian cartoon characters. A hand-drawn European-made original film followed in 1976 and then Hollywood took over in the 2000s, with Sony releasing three films between 2011 and 2017. None of those movies were Oscar contenders in their respective years and while the latest attempt is a modest improvement — one memorable scene finds Smurfette and her sidekick No Name Smurf (James Corden) racing through different animation styles, from anime to 8-bit video game — it's still, at heart, an I.P. grab. On the other hand, Rihanna does stand a legitimate shot at a Best Original Song nod for one of her earworm-y tunes ... if only so the Oscars can guarantee her presence (and a possible performance) at next year's ceremony.
5. The King of Kings (April 11)
Faith-based features rarely factor into the Oscar race in any medium, but this animated retelling of Jesus' life does boast an impressive vocal cast — including Mark Hamill, Uma Thurman, Kenneth Branagh, and Oscar Isaac as Christ himself. (Funnily enough, Isaac played Jesus' earthly dad, Joseph, in the 2006 film The Nativity Story opposite Keisha Castle-Hughes as Mary.) The Angel Studios-distributed movie also earned a solid $60 million at the box office, suggesting it found an audience outside of the genre's traditional crowd. But reviewers did note the saccharine tone and the mixed quality of the animation, which could be the deciding factor with Oscar voters.
4. KPop Demon Hunters (June 20)
A surprise Netflix smash when it dropped on the service in June, this delightful fusion of KPop and demon slaying has deservedly gone viral with younger audiences. The streaming service gave the movie an Oscar-qualifying limited theatrical run in New York and Los Angeles, which means it is eligible for the Animated Feature statuette. But the punk-rock title may prove to be a hindrance as voters sift through their many, many screeners. Let's hope their kids persuade them otherwise.
3. Dog Man (Jan. 15)
Believe it or not, the feature film version of Dav Pikey's beloved series of graphic novels remains the year's highest-grossing cartoon released in U.S. theaters with a $97 million tally. That alone makes it a strong contender for nomination, but Dog Man also offers beautifully stylized animation that brings the comic book characters to life and, as many have noted, the story is essentially RoboCop for kids. Not for nothing, but that Paul Verhoeven classic did receive a special achievement Oscar for Sound Effects Editing and was also nominated in the sound and film editing categories. Case closed.
2. Elio (June 20)
If it were released by any other major studio, Elio's mixed reviews and behind the scenes troubles would effectively end its Oscar campaign before it began. But the movie hails from Pixar, which has an industry-best track record of 19 Oscar nominations and 11 wins in this category for such contemporary classics as Finding Nemo, Up, and Coco. Even less-loved titles like Incredibles 2, Luca, and Elemental have earned nominations — and the studio is still hoping that Elio could stage an Elemental-like resurgence. In other words, Elio may be down, but he's not out.
1. Ne Zha 2 (Feb. 16)
While stateside animated features have been struggling commercially, China struck box-office gold with Ne Zha 2, which has crossed the $2 billion mark abroad. Roughly $20 million of that total came from the sequel's limited U.S. theatrical release in February. But expect that tally to grow now that A24 is releasing an English-language version in August with an eye towards entering the Oscar race. The vocal cast for that new release include Michelle Yeoh and presumably more A-listers to be named later, which should provide it with an extra boost among voters. Leaving aside its astonishing commercial success, Ne Zha 2 is among the most visually vibrant cartoon adventures of 2025, bringing Chinese mythology to the big screen in eye-popping ways.
Best of Gold Derby
Everything to know about 'The Batman 2': Returning cast, script finalized
Tom Cruise movies: 17 greatest films ranked worst to best
'It was wonderful to be on that ride': Christian Slater talks his beloved roles, from cult classics ('Heathers,' 'True Romance') to TV hits ('Mr. Robot,' 'Dexter: Original Sin')
Click here to read the full article.
Solve the daily Crossword
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Daily Briefing: The people of 'South Park' apologize
Daily Briefing: The people of 'South Park' apologize

USA Today

time20 minutes ago

  • USA Today

Daily Briefing: The people of 'South Park' apologize

Good morning!🙋🏼‍♀️ I'm Nicole Fallert. Debate: Google Maps v. Waze. 'South Park' creators 'apologize' for latest episode The day after one of the most controversial episodes in the show's history, 'South Park' creators Trey Parker and Matt Stone said 'we're terribly sorry" for the ruckus they caused. The Season 27 premiere of 'South Park' blasted President Donald Trump, showing him literally getting into bed naked with Satan, and referenced their Paramount bosses' settlement with the president, the '60 Minutes' flap and the surprise cancellation of CBS's "The Late Show with Stephen Colbert." It all followed an agreement between Paramount and the "South Park" creators for 50 new episodes and a lucrative new streaming deal on Paramount+. The episode ended with the people of South Park settling with Trump and agreeing to do pro-Trump messaging as part of their deal. Trump's visit to Fed is latest twist in feud over interest rates President Trump and Federal Reserve chair Jerome Powell clashed as they toured ongoing renovations of the Fed's headquarters, with the chairman correcting the president over the scale of cost overruns. The takeaway: It's not unprecedented for U.S. presidents to push for lower interest rates boost the economy. But no president has tried to bully a Fed chief as persistently and overtly. More news to know now What's the weather today? Check your local forecast here. Blistering heat may grip your city this weekend An unrelenting heat wave that has baked the Midwest for days promises temperatures approaching 100 degrees in New York, Philadelphia and Washington, D.C., on Friday. Record high temperatures are "likely to be challenged" in parts of the Northeast over the next two days, meteorologists said, and all regions affected are also likely to see some record warm minimum temperatures broken. A "heat dome" has mixed a cocktail of high heat and humidity to push heat indices over 100 degrees in many areas. And the heat dome could linger. Advocates for homeless react to executive order ~ Jesse Rabinowitz of the National Homelessness Law Center, in reaction to Trump's executive action on Thursday making it easier for cities and states to remove homeless people from the streets. Today's talkers Hulk Hogan, WWE Hall of Famer and wrestling legend, dies at 71 Wrestling icon Hulk Hogan died at the age of 71 after suffering cardiac arrest. Considered one of the most popular pro wrestlers of all time, Hogan was instrumental in the rise of pro wrestling's popularity, considered one of the first larger-than-life personas. He influenced several stars that joined the business after him. Read more about his life and legacy. Photo of the day: Alone at the front of the pack Tadej Pogačar didn't win the hardest stage of the 2025 Tour de France on Thursday, but the defending champion and this year's favorite showed again that there's likely nobody capable of taking the yellow jersey from him. Riders had to overcome 5,450 meters in climbs up three different summits. Pogačar's lead leaves little room for drama with just three stages remaining. Nicole Fallert is a newsletter writer at USA TODAY, sign up for the email here. Want to send Nicole a note? Shoot her an email at NFallert@

TSA Staff in Disbelief at What Passenger Leaves Behind at Security
TSA Staff in Disbelief at What Passenger Leaves Behind at Security

Newsweek

time21 minutes ago

  • Newsweek

TSA Staff in Disbelief at What Passenger Leaves Behind at Security

Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. The TSA (Transportation Security Administration) have shared a call out on social media after a passenger left behind an entire tray of their belongings while going through airport security. And one item in particular stood out. In the security tray alongside personal items and even a luxury bag was a Labubu collectible, In a post on Threads, TSA said: "Paging the passenger who forgot literally their entire tray of items at security, your labubu is looking at us weird plz come get it immediately. Thank you." The post, shared on Wednesday, racked up thousands of likes and hundreds of comments on Threads where people were stunned to see the items left behind at the airport. "How does someone leave their entire tray of stuff?" asked one commenter. While another wrote: "Digital camera and LV bag? What decade is this? If it weren't for the Labubu I would think this photo was from 2008." A picture of the items left behind in the tray at the TSA checkpoint. A picture of the items left behind in the tray at the TSA checkpoint. TSA/Threads Labubu, created by Hong Kong-born artist Kasing Lung and produced by POPMART, has exploded from underground art darling to global pop culture icon in the last year. Distributed primarily in "blind boxes," Labubu figures have become cult favorites, appearing in the hands of celebrities like Rihanna, Kim Kardashian, and David Beckham. The high-fashion market has even embraced the plush toys, with figures appearing on high-end Hermès Birkin bags and in the pages of Vogue magazine. According to official TSA data, approximately 90,000 to 100,000 items are left behind each month at security checkpoints across the U.S. That equates to over 1 million items every year, ranging from mundane toiletries and electronics to valuable jewelry, and, apparently even valuable toys like the Labubu. It isn't just items that get left behind either. In 2023, TSA agents reported collecting over $956,253 in forgotten coins and bills, nearly double the amount recorded in 2012. The agency is legally permitted to retain this unclaimed cash, which is then put toward aviation security programs and contributes to the federal treasury. And it's not the first time a TSA checkpoint incident has sparked attention. Last year security pulled a suspicious bag at the airport only to be stunned by the contents—a bag full to the brim of canned cooked pork. While another woman was stopped for having an entire rotisserie chicken in her bag to eat on the flight, confusing both agents and the internet. While previous TSA posts have shared unusual things found in people's luggage, including a weapon disguised as a marker pen and a stun gun that looked just like an iPhone.

South Park's savage takedown shows Trump has picked a fight he can't win
South Park's savage takedown shows Trump has picked a fight he can't win

Yahoo

time38 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

South Park's savage takedown shows Trump has picked a fight he can't win

Of all the dubious achievements of Donald Trump's time in office, the most surprising may be this: the US president has made South Park relevant again. The long-running animation – just days ago signing a record-breaking $1.5bn deal with Paramount to produce 50 new episodes over the next five years – used its long-awaited season premiere to launch a characteristically pugnacious critique of the president. Over the past weeks and months, Trump's antagonism towards his country's arts and media sector has intensified. Part of this has manifested in legislation – such as the cuts to PBS and NPR, the US's public service broadcasters, which were passed by congress earlier this month. The National Endowment for the Arts has undergone drastic cuts this year, slashing government investment in the humanities at a local level. At other times, Trump's ire has taken the form of litigation: Trump last year sued Paramount, the parent company of the network CBS, over what he contended was misleading editing in an interview with his opponent Kamala Harris ahead of the 2024 election. This month, legal action was also launched against The Wall Street Journal, NewsCorp and Rupert Murdoch, over the publication of the president's alleged birthday letter to convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein. The fight with Paramount has an extra wrinkle: a proposed $8bn merger with Skydance Media, which requires the approval of the FCC, the federal regulatory body, to go ahead. Much of Paramount's recent decision-making has been interpreted as an attempt to pre-emptively pander to the forthcoming owners, and to the FCC, now under the leadership of Trump's hand-picked chairman Brendan Carr. This includes the announcement earlier this month that Stephen Colbert's popular TV stalwart The Late Show, long vocal in its criticism of the president, was not being renewed beyond next year. It was also announced that Paramount had agreed to settle what some have called the 'patently unconstitutional' Trump lawsuit for $16m – prompting claims of 'bribery' from Democratic senators. Titled 'Sermon on the Mount', the new episode of South Park folds these various controversies into one unwieldy blob of satire. One minute, you have South Park's breakout character, foul-mouthed schoolboy Eric Cartman, bemoaning the defunding of NPR. Later in the episode, Trump sues the town of South Park, with the figure of Jesus Christ – sent by Trump to impose himself in the local schools – telling the locals: 'You guys saw what happened to CBS! You really want to end up like Colbert?' The episode ends with the town being instructed to pay Trump $3.5m, and record a PSA of 'pro-Trump messaging'. These are, at least, the more tasteful criticisms of Trump that South Park creators Trey Parker and Matt Stone deploy. Elsewhere, they resort to sledgehammer irreverence, South Park's usual weapon of choice. In one scene, Trump has a sexual encounter with Satan; another sees the cartoon president bare his genitals and reveal that he has a micropenis. Rumours that Trump appears on the widely discussed "Epstein list" are also mentioned. It's significant, perhaps, that South Park should enter its new era on Paramount with an episode that's so unapologetically anti-Trump. Where much of the entertainment industry has always skewed left-wing, South Park has always teetered somewhere in the middle, spitting its acid in both directions. It has a storied history of shunning political correctness, while never tipping over into right-wing reactionism. Parker and Stone's comic ethos – that both sides of any debate are usually just as fatuous as each other – has seen the show, and its creators, weather substantial criticism down the years. But they've stuck to it. South Park is, if not a voice of reason, then at the very least, a voice of uniform scepticism. You have to wonder what the bosses at Paramount are thinking right now; South Park hasn't just bitten the hand that feeds it, but torn it clean off the arm. (And in any case, it won't need feeding again for another five years.) The White House went so far as to issue a statement hitting out at South Park, branding it a 'fourth-rate show' that 'hasn't been relevant for over 20 years and is hanging on by a thread' – criticisms that might hold more water if the ink on a billion-dollar licensing deal wasn't still wet. Parker and Stone were unrepentant during an appearance at Comic-Con after the episode aired, while an administration source told Deadline that the president was 'seething'. There's a lesson in here, when it comes to Trump. For all the legislative power he wields, and the not-inconsiderable influence he may hold over parts of the entertainment industry, a war with television is not one he can win. The more he tries to impose himself, the more mud will be flung his way. And some of it, inevitably, will stick.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store