Mystery over rock band 'that doesn't exist' with over 600,000 streams
The Velvet Sundown sound familiar, and their songs are perfectly listenable, if not the next Sweet Jane.
But they're causing controversy because people think they're entirely AI-generated, and you can see why. They either don't exist at all, or they're pretending to be AI for a marketing gimmick.
According to their 'verified artist' Spotify profile, the band was 'formed by singer and mellotron player Gabe Farrow, guitarist Lennie West, Milo Rains, who crafts the band's textured synth sounds, and free-spirited percussionist Orion 'Rio' Del Mar'.
Only problem is, none of them have any social media presence or evidence of existing outside of this bio, and the band itself only started posting on X and Instragram three days ago.
To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video
Not quite what you'd expect if they'd been gigging and promoting themselves for years before their big break.
Their official Instagram account references the controversy with a video captioned: 'They said we're not real. Maybe you aren't either.'
Equally enigmatically, their bio reads: 'A band you might have heard once in a dream. This one has only just begun.'
But their online presence is even odder than this, as there are several different accounts claiming to be them on both X and Instagram, one of which has been very outspoken insisting they are not AI.
They wrote: 'This is not a joke. This is our music, written in long, sweaty nights in a cramped bungalow in California with real instruments, real minds, and real soul. Every chord, every lyric, every mistake — HUMAN.'
But the plot thickens, as a different Velvet Sundown account on X (the one linked to in the band's Spotify profile) indicated the first account wasn't even them at all.
They wrote: 'To all the journalists who wrote about us — Thank you for listening. However, these are the only official pages of the band. All others are reflections, echoes, projections. Don't amplify what isn't us.'
The possibly fake X account has more followers than the official X account, and also started posting first, so you can see why people are getting confused about all of this.
🚨 Absolutely crazy that so-called 'journalists' keep pushing the lazy, baseless theory that The Velvet Sundown is 'AI-generated' with zero evidence. Not a single one of these "writers" has reached out, visited a show, or listened beyond the Spotify algorithm. 1/ — The Velvet Sundown (Band) – Official 🎸🎶🎧 (@Velvet_Sundown) June 29, 2025
We asked to speak to the people behind the (fake?) X account and they agreed to talk, but did not yet reply when we asked if it could be a video call.
The band also has at least five Instagram accounts, one of which is filled with what looks like AI generated images.
These images are part of the reason the band has been accused of being fake, with oddities in the images like fudged fingers or a guitar with disappearing strings.
But again, the band now say this is not their official account, which has only one promo video on the grid.
Deezer, a rival music streaming service, has tagged the Velvet Sundown's music as being AI generated.
This had nothing to do with the images or promotion surrounding them, but was down to analysis of the music itself.
Aurelien Herault, Chief Innovation Officer at Deezer, told Metro: We have trained our detection tool using datasets from a number of generative models, including Suno and Udio, which means that our detection tool is able to recognise the signals and sounds in fully AI-generated music that you don't find in authentic tracks.
'We have also made significant progress in training our detection tool to identify AI tracks even without a specific dataset to train on.
'Thanks to our tool, we are confident that the album pages that are currently tagged generated by AI on our platform are generated by AI.'
Their software flagged The Velvet Sundown as being AI before the contoversy erupted, and so a label is now shown to users warning 'AI generated content. Some tracks on this album may have been created using artificial intelligence.'
It's growing, and Deezer say they now see 20,000 tracks which are 100% AI generated submitted every single day, which has doubled from the start of the year.
Mr Herault told Metro that artifically generated music now makes up approximately 18% of all tracks delivered to the platform.
He said: 'At Deezer we want to prioritise revenues going to real artists, which is why we remove fully AI-generated tracks from algorithmic or editorial recommendations.
'We don't believe AI music is inherently good or bad, but we believe music fans have a right to know what they are listening to, which is why we opt for a transparent approach and tag AI-generated music on Deezer, in order to build trust with our users.'
As the tech continues to improve, we will no doubt get tracks which sound great and are made by AI, at the same time as becomes more integrated in filmmaking and yes, maybe takes your white collar job.
Spotify has been investing heavily in AI, and you can now use it to make you playlists or listen to a DJ curating songs for you.
But it has also been accused of adding AI generated music to popular playlists like Ambient Chill and Peaceful Piano, without it being obvious to users.
The company has not commented on this, but previously said it was 'categorically untrue' that it was creating AI music itself to fill playlists.
Instagram has introduced a tag to show if something is made using AI, and videos made by Google Veo are watermarked.
However, the industry standard is less clear when it comes to AI music, with Deezer currently the only streaming platform to tag it as such.
One way scammers might benefit from uploading AI music to streaming platforms is by getting enough streams to earn them royalties.
There are even so-called 'streaming farms' where tracks are listened to over and over again to try and game the system.
So a song could be made by AI and listened to by bots on repeat, with humans barely part of the musical process at all.
It would be too obvious if an unknown artist suddenly racked up millions of streams (much like with the Velvet Sundown).
So to get around this, fraudsters flood streaming platforms with lots of fake songs which are each streamed just a few thousands times: enough to make money, but less likely to make people suspicious.
Explaining the problem, Mr Herault said: If an artist is able to gain a significant number of users streaming their music, they then become entitled to a bigger share of the royalty pool. More Trending
'This is true whether an artist is using AI or not; the only difference being that AI music is significantly easier to produce.'
He said that fraudulent streams 'are often generated by streaming farms or bots, which repeatedly 'listen' to tracks in order to inflate their streams and increase their share of the royalty pool.'
Deezer said that up to 70% of streams of fully AI tracks are fraudulent, though currently AI tracks only make up 0.5% of overall streams.
The company said: 'When detecting stream manipulation of any kind, Deezer excludes the streams from the royalty payments.'
Get in touch with our news team by emailing us at webnews@metro.co.uk.
For more stories like this, check our news page.
MORE: Legendary 70s rock band tease reunion tour after retiring over frontman's serious injury
MORE: Rock star shares hospital bed update after 'very aggressive' cancer diagnosis
MORE: I worked at Wimbledon for 40 years — now a machine has taken my job
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NBC News
39 minutes ago
- NBC News
An indie band is blowing up on Spotify, but people think its AI
An indie psych rock band has amassed more than 850,000 listeners on Spotify in a matter of weeks and generated buzz throughout the music industry — but nobody is exactly sure if it's real or not. The Velvet Sundown, a band bent on 'Saving Modern Rock,' according to its Instagram account, has even some music industry veterans confused. The images put forward by the band all look like they were created by AI. The music? That's harder to say. Rick Beato, a music producer with more than 5 million subscribers on YouTube identified what he called 'artifacts, particularly in one of the track's guitar and keyboard parts. He said that can indicate a song was created by AI. 'This is having a lot of problems and I suspect that it may be because this is an AI track,' Beato said in a YouTube video, after running one of The Velvet Sundown's songs through Apple's Logic Pro track splitter. 'Every time you have an AI song, they are full of artifacts.' Whether the band is real, fake or something in between, its emergence and the broader debate about it add to a growing concern about the future of art, culture and authenticity in the era of advanced generative artificial intelligence. Many major tech platforms have already seen floods of AI-generated content, while AI influencers are becoming increasingly common on social media platforms. Velvet Sundown appears to have first emerged in June, according to its social media profiles. On Spotify, the band has a 'Verified Artist' badge, offering some sense of authority. On X, The Velvet Sundown teased an upcoming album 'Paper Sun Rebellion,' and nodded to questions about doubts about the band's origins. Aside from the quick rollout of songs, its uncannily plasticine promotional images of band members have prompted accusations of AI use as well. In a video announcing the release of its upcoming album 'Paper Sun Rebellion' later this month, the band pushed back against accusations that they aren't 'real,' stating in one video that 'you believed the lie, and danced to it anyway.' 'They said we're not real,' the account posted. 'Maybe you aren't either.' The band's Spotify bio claims that the group is composed of four people: singer Gabe Farrow, guitarist Lennie West, Milo Rains, 'who crafts the band's textured synth sounds,' and percussionist Orion 'Rio' Del Mar. Farrow also allegedly plays the mellotron, which is an electro-mechanical instrument that plays pre-recorded sounds when its keys are pressed. 'There's something quietly spellbinding about The Velvet Sundown,' their Spotify bio states. 'You don't just listen to them, you drift into them. Their music doesn't shout for your attention; it seeps in slowly, like a scent that suddenly takes you back somewhere you didn't expect.' Questions about the band's origins were further complicated after other social accounts purporting to represent the band began rejecting claims that the band was using AI-generated images or music, as well as a person who spoke to Rolling Stone claiming to be connected to the band who called it an 'art hoax.' That person later admitted in a Substack post that his claim to represent the band was itself a hoax. The Velvet Sundown said that the person quoted in the article is not affiliated with them in 'any way.' 'He does not represent us, speak for us, or have any connection to this project,' The Velvet Sundown said in a statement to NBC News via Instagram. On Thursday, the social media accounts tied to the band's Spotify account posted that 'someone is trying to hijack the identity of The Velvet Sundown by releasing unauthorized interviews, publishing unrelated photos, and creating fake profiles claiming to represent us.' The Velvet Sundown's YouTube publisher Distrokid did not respond to requests for comment. Spotify also did not respond to a request for comment. The band's meteoric rise highlights modern issues around AI, and how difficult it can be to verify what is and is not real on the internet. Last year, Google researchers found that AI image misinformation has surged on the internet since 2023. A Consumer Reports investigation found that leading AI voice cloning programs have no meaningful barriers to stop people from nonconsensually impersonating others. According to the music streaming app Deezer, which uses its own tool to identify AI-generated content, 100 percent of The Velvet Sundown's tracks were created using AI. Deezer labels that content on its site, ensuring that AI generated music does not appear on its recommended playlists and that royalties are maximized for human artists. 'AI generated music and AI bands may generate some value to the user, so we still want to display that,' Alexis Lanternier, the CEO of Deezer, said. 'We just want to make sure that the remuneration is taken in a different way.' Every week, about 18 percent of the tracks being uploaded to Deezer — roughly 180,000 songs — are flagged by the platform's tool as being AI generated. That number has grown threefold in the past two years, Lanternier said. Suno and Udio, both generative AI music creation programs, declined to say whether The Velvet Sundown's music was created using their software. 'I think people are getting too far down the rabbit hole of dissecting, is it AI, is it not AI? And forgetting the important question, which is like, how did it make you feel? How many people liked it?' said Mikey Shulman, CEO and co-founder of Suno. According to Suno's rights and ownership policy, songs made by its users who are subscribed to its higher tier plans are covered by a commercial use license. That allows them to monetize and distribute songs on platforms like Spotify without attributing them to Suno. 'There are Grammy winners who use Suno, you know, every day in their production,' said Shulman. Recently, Grammy Award-winning record producer Timbaland launched an AI artist named TaTa with his new entertainment company, Stage Zero. He told Billboard that TaTa, who created a catalog of AI-generated music through Suno, was neither an 'avatar' nor a 'character.' Suno was one of two AI companies sued last year by major record labels — including Universal Music Group, Sony Music Entertainment and Warner Music Group — who allege that the companies infringed on the labels' recording copyrights in order to train their music-generating models. About a year into the legal battle, however, the music labels have begun talks to work out a licensing deal so that Suno and Udio could use copyrighted recordings by compensating the artists for their work, according to a Bloomberg report published last month. It's a trend that's become worrisome to artists like Kristian Heironimus, who is a member of the band Velvet Meadow (not to be confused with the now-viral The Velvet Sundown). 'I've been working for like, six years just constantly releasing music, working my day job,' Heironimus said. 'It is kind of disheartening just seeing an AI band, and then in, like, what two weeks, [have] like, 500,000 monthly listeners.' The creep of generative AI into music and other creative industries has incited backlash from those who worry about the devaluation of their human work, as many AI developers have been known to scrape data from the internet without human creators' knowledge or consent. Beyond ethical debates about the consequences of the AI boom on human labor, some online worry about the rise of low-quality AI slop as these tools grow increasingly capable of replicating voices, generating full-length songs and creating visuals from text prompts. Heironimus said there are similarities between his band, Velvet Meadow, and The Velvet Sundown, beyond just the names. One of the members pictured in The Velvet Sundown's Spotify band photo, for example, looks similar to a photo of Heironimus when he used to have long hair, he said. The bands also fall within the same genre, though Heironimus described The Velvet Sundown's tracks as 'soulless.' Shulman, of Suno, said most streaming music is already 'algorithmically driven.' 'People don't realize just how depersonalized music has become, and how little connection the average person has with the artist behind the music,' he said. 'It's a failure of imagination to think that in the future, it can't be a lot better.' But Lanternier, of Deezer, argues that as AI continues to evolve, streaming platforms should also be trying to ensure artists can make enough royalties to survive. 'People are not only interested in the sound. They are interested in the whole story of an artist — in the whole brand of an artist,' Lanternier said. 'We believe that what is right to do is to support the real artist, so that they continue to create music that people love.'
Daily Mirror
an hour ago
- Daily Mirror
Romeo Beckham's heartfelt call to Brooklyn in moving Diogo Jota tribute
Premier League footballer Diogo Jota and his brother, Andre Felipe, died in a crash in Zamora near Spain's north-west border with Portugal. Romeo Beckham shared a passionate post about telling the people you love how much you appreciate them following the tragic death of Diogo Jota. The Premier League footballer and his brother, Andre Felipe, died in a crash in Zamora near Spain's north-west border with Portugal. The tragic incident occurred just days after Jota's marriage to his childhood sweetheart, Rute Cardoso, who had to identify her husband and his brother after the devastating crash. After the news was made public, Romeo took to his Instagram to share a picture of the footballer along with a few heartbroken emojis. He later returned to his Instagram Stories to send a cryptic message to his older brother, Brooklyn Beckham, telling him that 'the people that truly love you and care for you will always be there'. The recent post comes amid a reported family feud between Brooklyn and his wife, Nicola Peltz, and the rest of the Beckham family. Romeo wrote: "Life is too short, love who you love and tell them how much you really do! Life can flash before your eyes at any moment! But the people that truly love you and care for you will always be there... "Don't hold back from LOVE OR APPRECIATION for ANYTHING OR ANYONE." Piers Morgan also shared a tribute on social media. On Twitter /X, he wrote: "Desperately sad news coming out of Spain that Liverpool and Portugal star Diogo Jota, 28, has died, along with his brother, in a car accident in Zamora. He only got married 2 weeks ago. Heart-breaking." Others paying respects on social media was footballer Harry Maguire's wife, Fern Maguire. She shared the Premier League's tribute as she wrote: "Utterly heartbreaking." David Beckham also penned touching tribute over the top of a black-and-white image of the star in a Portugal game."Devastating to hear this such sad news.. Sending love to Diogo & Andre's families," he wrote. Meanwhile, Brooklyn and Nicola sparked concern for the famous family when they failed to attend any of David's 50th birthday celebrations in May. They had even jetted into London from Los Angeles but decided to stay away from the special family events. It proved just the start of distance forming for the Beckhams, as Brooklyn failed to reach out to his football icon dad when he received his long-awaited knighthood. Father's Day also came and went without a murmur from the eldest son, with reports claiming he has stopped responding to his famous parents and siblings.
Metro
an hour ago
- Metro
Comedian admits he 'nearly got into a punch-up' at Wimbledon
To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video An Australian comedian has revealed he narrowly avoided getting into a fight into the stands at Wimbledon. On Monday the tennis tournament kicked off at the All England Lawn Tennis & Croquet Club in South West London. Flocks of famous faces have descended on the grounds, including David Beckham, Jessica Alba, Olivia Rodrigo, Cate Blanchett, Isla Fisher and Russell Crowe. Among the Australian stars to attend was comedian Dave Hughes – best known for hosting and appearing on shows including Australia's Got Talent, The Masked Singer Australia and I'm A Celebrity…Get Me Out of Here! Although the prestigious event is known for demanding a respectful etiquette from those in the stands, Dave has now explained a messy incident nearly unfolded when he went. Posting a video of himself with his son in the stands on Instagram, Dave detailed what happened. 'At Wimbledon and we are loving it. This is court 1 and we just saw Jordan Thompson win on court 15. Aussie, Aussie, Aussie. It was a very small court and there was this English bloke behind us who would just not shut up right throughout the match. Eventually I said, 'mate can you just be quiet' and Raf what did he call me?' he asked his son Rafferty, who was sitting next to him. Leaning into the shot, Rafferty said that his dad had been called a 'little Hitler'. 'Bit of an overreaction I feel like!' he added. Jumping back in, Dave added: 'Everyone around us was happy that I did it. What is it with entitled w***ers.' Captioning the post he also wrote: 'Three rows of seating on court 15, within metres of the players, tense fifth set, and this English bloke would not stop loudly talking to his friend as if he was down at his local boozer. When I eventually told him to pipe down, he was livid, real 'how dare you tell me what to do you Aussie scum' vibe. He called me 'Little Hitler'. But after a long, very tense back and forth, he zipped it and everyone was happy, except him.' Many threw their support behind Dave, including a woman who was actually there too. 'I was the row in front of you and was cheering you on! Love that you didn't back down!! Crowd totally had your back!… He hardly said a word rest of the match!' Kylie commented. 'Glad you educated him and put him in his place,' Melanie wrote. 'Good to know your fans are everywhere,' fellow comedian Rove McManus added. Last year Dave also stood up to other loud talkers – this time at once of his own shows. More Trending During a show in Adelaide earlier this year he ejected three disruptive women after they repeatedly ignored his demands to 'shut up'. 'I don't wanna kick people out, but if they refuse to stop talking, there's no other choice!' he told Sky News at the time. 'Hopefully this story might inspire others to not ruin shows/movies for other paying audience members!' Got a story? If you've got a celebrity story, video or pictures get in touch with the entertainment team by emailing us celebtips@ calling 020 3615 2145 or by visiting our Submit Stuff page – we'd love to hear from you. MORE: The shocking moment teenage boy punches woman unconscious at UK rapper's concert MORE: Tim Henman names two 'favourites' to win Wimbledon as Novak Djokovic advances MORE: Jack Draper complains about big Wimbledon change after painful Marin Cilic defeat
