Mysterious Antikythera Mechanism May Actually Be a Toy, Study Says
A new study suggests the device may simply have been an elaborate toy.
Researchers from the National University of Mar del Plata in Argentina discovered that the configuration of the gears and teeth indicates the mechanism isn't functional.
The Antikythera mechanism was thought to have been used by the ancient Greeks to calculate the movements of the Sun, Moon, and other planets, as well as eclipses. Only a fragment of it survived, but experts have been trying to imagine the rest of it since its discovery in a shipwreck in 1901.
This latest study builds on previous work by Cardiff University astrophysicist Mike Edmunds, which looked at the shape of the mechanism's gear teeth and the manufacturing errors that may have been introduced as the mechanism was made.
"Under our assumptions, the errors identified by Edmunds exceed the tolerable limits required to prevent failures," write the researchers.
"Consequently, either the mechanism never functioned or its actual errors were smaller than those reported by Edmunds."
What's new here is the way that calculations on both gear teeth and possible errors – including variations in the spacing of the teeth and evidence of variations in gear rotation – are combined together for a more comprehensive simulated model of the device.
Whereas previously there had been some indications that the mechanism may not have been entirely accurate in its celestial mapping – perhaps as much due to the limited understanding of the cosmos as the mechanism itself – here the suggestion is that the device wouldn't really have functioned.
"Our model revealed numerous instances of gear jamming and disengagement caused by both the random and systematic distribution of the teeth," write the researchers.
There are plenty of caveats here, and the researchers themselves admit their work is "speculative" in parts. Only fragments of the mechanism remain, fragments that were battered and eroded underwater for many centuries, so there's a lot of educated guesswork going on.
Nevertheless, it's enough to call into question whether the Antikythera mechanism was actually a work of genius or just an ornate decoration. Future studies will now be able to build on these findings.
"This analysis suggests that we must be cautious in assuming that our measurements of the fragments perfectly reflect their original values," write the researchers.
"Instead, it highlights the need for further research and the possible development of more refined techniques to better understand the true accuracy and functionality of the Antikythera mechanism."
The research has yet to be peer-reviewed or published in a journal, but is available on the preprint server arXiv.
'Neuromyths' Distort Our Concept of The Human Brain, Study Finds
Our Relationships With Indoor Plants Come in 4 Types, Study Finds
Study of 616 Languages Identified Which Had Most Words For 'Snow'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Scientists scan famous 'Earthrise' crater on mission to find alien life in our solar system
When you buy through links on our articles, Future and its syndication partners may earn a commission. A lunar crater immortalized in one of the most famous photographs ever taken has just played a key role in the hunt for alien life in our solar system. Stretching nearly 25 miles (40 kilometers) across the far side of the moon, the lunar impact crater formerly known as "Pasteur T" may be the most-viewed lunar crater in history. Countless Earthlings have seen it spreading prominently through the foreground of the iconic "Earthrise" photo snapped by American astronaut William Anders on Dec. 24, 1968, during the Apollo 8 mission. The majestic photo, which shows a half-lit Earth rising majestically above the lunar horizon, became so famous that the crater was renamed "Anders' Earthrise" in 2018. Now, nearly 60 years after Anders' flyby put his eponymous crater on the map, another spacecraft has glimpsed it from orbit — this time, with extraterrestrial science in mind. The Jupiter Icy Moons Explorer (JUICE) spacecraft, which launched from Earth in April 2023 and is expected to reach Jupiter's orbit in 2031, flew past the moon nearly a year ago. Mission scientists used this encounter to test the spacecraft's 10 science instruments, which will eventually be used to hunt for signs of habitability on the many moons of Jupiter. This lunar flyby presented the first opportunity to test the performance of JUICE's instruments on a solid surface in space, representatives from the European Space Agency (ESA) said in a statement. Of particular importance was the Radar for Icy Moon Exploration (RIME) instrument, which uses radio wave echoes to measure elevation on rocky bodies. "RIME's task at Jupiter is to peer below the icy surfaces of moons Europa, Ganymede and Callisto to map the invisible rocky layers below," ESA representatives wrote in the statement. Because RIME needs to "listen" for precise changes in radio waves, the instrument requires as much silence as possible to get the best readings. That's where Anders' Earthrise crater comes into play. While JUICE sailed past the famous crater, ESA scientists silenced all of the probe's other instruments to let RIME observe it in peace for eight uninterrupted minutes. RIME's radar mapped the moon's elevation in and around the crater, which researchers compared to earlier measurements taken by other spacecraft, such as NASA's Lunar Orbiter Laser Altimeter (LOLA). The team found that electronic noise within JUICE was throwing off RIME's measurements — kicking off a months-long project to correct the issue with a new algorithm. RELATED STORIES — Space photo of the week: 'Earthrise,' the Christmas Eve image that changed the world — Against the Blackness of Space: From the First Atlas to 'Earthrise' — Apollo 8: Everything you need to know ESA now reports that this project was a success. The new elevation map of Anders' Earthrise crater (above) shows peaks and valleys that perfectly match the elevations captured by LOLA during earlier lunar flybys. The data prove that RIME is ready for its big job: charting the subsurface depths of the largest moons in the solar system — and, hopefully, aiding in the search for extraterrestrial life. With a long journey still ahead, JUICE is now headed toward Venus, where our neighboring planet's gravity will give the spacecraft a boost on the path to Jupiter. Ultimately, JUICE will complete 35 flybys of Jupiter's most massive moons, before settling into orbit around Ganymede from December 2034 to September 2035, according to ESA. Studying Jupiter and its moons will not only provide new insights about the formation of gas giants and planetary systems at large but also help to tease out signs of life and habitability beneath the icy shells of the enormous moons. This story was provided by Live Science, a sister site of Solve the daily Crossword
Miami Herald
17 hours ago
- Miami Herald
Crypto mogul flies to space aboard latest Blue Origin flight
A Blue Origin rocket launched cryptocurrency entrepreneur Justin Sun and five others on a trip to the edge of space and back. The flight lifted off Sunday at 7:42 a.m. local time from West Texas on a short suborbital joyride to space. Sun founded TRON, a blockchain platform, and serves as an adviser to HTX, one of the world's largest cryptocurrency exchanges. He placed the top bid of $28 million for a seat on Blue Origin's tourism craft in 2021. The proceeds went to Blue Origin's Club for the Future foundation to benefit space-based charities. The other members on board were real estate investor Arvi Bahal; Turkish businessman Gökhan Erdem; meteorologist and journalist Deborah Martorell; teacher Lionel Pitchford; and JD Russell, founder of venture capital firm Alpha Funds. The crypto entrepreneur was supposed to fly on Blue Origin's first human flight with company founder Jeff Bezos in July 2021, but Sun had to reschedule. Other celebrities have taken on the suborbital mission, including pop star Katy Perry and Bezos' now-wife Lauren Sánchez. While Blue Origin does not disclose its price for a seat on one of its tourism flights, rival space tourism company Virgin Galactic charges around $600,000 for a similar experience. Blue Origin has now launched 14 tourist missions on its New Shepard to date, the company said. _____ Copyright (C) 2025, Tribune Content Agency, LLC. Portions copyrighted by the respective providers.
Yahoo
a day ago
- Yahoo
August Moon: Here's what to look for during all 4 major moon phases
When you buy through links on our articles, Future and its syndication partners may earn a commission. The ever-shifting phases of Earth's moon present a wealth of targets for amateur astronomers to explore, ranging from magnificent craters and lunar seas to strange visual phenomena created as sunlight plays across the ancient surface, forming familiar shapes where none should be. So, grab your telescope and join us on a short, guided "road trip" of August's moon, in which we'll highlight a series of stunning targets to explore during each moon phase. Any backyard telescope will allow you to pick out the targets on our list, though a scope with an aperture of 6 inches or more will help reveal more detail across ancient lunar landscapes. Be sure to check out our roundups of the best telescopes and binoculars for exploring the solar system if you find yourself wanting a closer look at Earth's natural satellite. The first quarter moon (Aug. 1) The nights following each new moon phase will see the line separating night from day on the lunar surface creep inexorably westward. By Aug. 1, this line of demarcation — known as the terminator — will divide the lunar surface in two, heralding the onset of the moon's "first quarter phase." During this phase, the moon will already be high in the sky at sunset, with its right side fully lit and its left hidden under a veil of shadow. The nights leading up to Aug. 1 present a perfect opportunity to search for the historic Apollo 11 landing site on the southwestern shore of Mare Tranquilitatis (Latin for the Sea of Tranquility), from where Neil Armstrong announced "the Eagle has landed" on July 20, 1969. Mare Tranquilitatis is easily visible to the naked eye as a dark basaltic plain close to the equator to the right of the terminator, as indicated on the graphic below. A 6-inch telescope will help you zero in on the landing zone — known as Tranquility Base — by looking to the lower right of the prominent Ritter and Sabine craters, which can be found on the western edge of the lunar mare. Two nights later, on Aug. 4, the moon's terminator will fall slightly to the west of the Sinus Iridum impact basin, causing a brilliant "Golden Handle' to appear in the northwest region of the lunar surface. This striking effect occurs when the sun's rays pick out the peaks of the Montes Jura mountain range on the northern edge of Mare Imbrium. The full "Sturgeon Moon" (Aug. 9) By Aug. 9, the relentless westward march of the terminator will have swept across the entirety of the lunar surface, setting the stage for the full "Sturgeon Moon" to slip above the horizon at sunset, local time. The Sturgeon Moon is named for the time of year when the titular fish are most readily caught; it presents a good opportunity to observe the mighty form of Tycho crater extending its influence over the lunar disk. Tycho is easily visible to the naked eye, thanks in part to the vast streaks (or rays) of reflective material cast outward across the lunar surface in the wake of the brutal asteroid impact that created the 53-mile-wide (85-kilometer) crater. Every one of the moon's larger impact sites would have once played host to a bright ray system like Tycho, though exposure to the harsh space environment has since caused many to fade. After all, Tycho formed a mere 108 million years ago, while other lunar craters have been estimated to be 3.9 billion years of age. The August full moon also presents a great time to learn the locations of the many lunar mare (Latin for "seas") that can be spotted with the naked eye as the surface of Earth's natural satellite darkens. Each of the mare visible today were created billions of years ago, when lava flows filled the network of lunar craters carved out by powerful asteroid strikes. The lava lakes swiftly hardened to "repave" the moon, forming enormous basaltic plains that can be explored without the need for a telescope or binoculars. Mare Crisium can be spotted as a dark oval to the northeast of the lunar surface, while Mare Tranquillitatis (the Sea of Tranquility) — which plays host to the Apollo 11 landing site — is located to its left, bordered to the north by Mare Serenitatis (the Sea of Serenity). The equatorial region to the westward side of the lunar disk is dominated by Oceanus Procellarum (the Ocean of Storms), with Mare Imbrium (the Sea of Showers) to the north and Mare Nubium (the Sea of Clouds) to the south. The third quarter moon (Aug. 16) The passing of the full moon will see the terminator return to sweep over the eastern limb of the lunar surface until, finally, on Aug. 16, the third quarter moon will rise, with its right half bathed in shadow and its left illuminated by direct sunlight. Aug. 16 is a great opportunity to observe a dramatic display of light and shadow play across the terminator and to hunt down a pair of massive craters named to honor two legendary ancient Greek philosophers, inventors and astronomers: Plato and Archimedes. Look for the 62-mile-wide (10 km) Plato Crater just below the narrow form of Mare Frigoris soon after the moon rises around midnight on Aug. 16. Then, follow the terminator south to find the similarly sized Archimedes impact site above the pronounced sweep of the Montes Apenninus mountain range. The following night (Aug. 17) is a wonderful time to see the Copernicus and Kepler craters brightening Oceanus Procellarum. Both impact sites are surrounded by bright ejecta rays, albeit less pronounced than those exhibited by Tycho further to the south. The Copernicus Crater looks particularly impressive around this time, with its westward rim and central peak cast into relief by the oblique angle of the sun. Copernicus had been proposed as a candidate landing site for the Apollo 18 crewed lunar mission, though the program was cancelled long before its scheduled launch date due to budget constraints. New moon (August 23) During the new moon phase, the lunar disk lurks unseen in the daytime sky, leaving the night unblemished by the glare of reflected sunlight. Head away from city lights around this time to hunt the glowing band of the Milky Way's core, which can be spotted during the summer months streaming towards the eastern horizon as dusk gives way to night in dark sky locations. The moon will appear as a slim waning or waxing crescent on a handful of nights before and after the new moon phase, during which you may see the shadow-veiled expanse of the lunar surface infused with a soft glow. This phenomenon, known as "Earthshine," or the "Da Vinci Glow," occurs when the moon is positioned roughly between our planet and the sun, at which point sunlight reflected off Earth's surface bathes the unlit lunar disk in a subtle glow. Editor's Note: If you would like to share your astrophotography with readers, then please send your photo(s), comments, and your name and location to spacephotos@ Solve the daily Crossword
