CVS vs. Amazon: Healthcare Battle Continues- Which Stock to Buy Now?
But CVS hasn't stood still. After a tough 2024 marked by cost headwinds at its Aetna insurance unit, the company is staging a strong comeback in 2025, now among the top 10 S&P 500 performers year to date. In the first quarter of 2025, CVS posted $95 billion in revenue and continued expanding its vertically integrated ecosystem, including Oak Street Health clinics, Aetna's Medicare Advantage plans and over 9,000 retail locations.
What once looked like an asymmetrical battle is now shaping into a true rivalry. With Amazon driving digital-first, scalable models powered by generative AI and logistics strength and CVS focusing on integrated care and physical access, investors are currently watching closely to see who will ultimately lead the next era of healthcare delivery. Let's discuss in detail.
Physical Footprint vs. Digital Deployment
CVS Health continues to capitalize on its vast physical footprint, boasting over 9,000 retail pharmacies across the United States, alongside its insurance arm, Aetna, and a growing network of Oak Street Health clinics. This infrastructure enables CVS Health to offer coordinated, in-person care with integrated logistics, pharmacy, and insurance services under one umbrella. The company's ability to deliver both routine and specialized care locally makes it a go-to player for communities seeking trusted, comprehensive healthcare access.
In contrast, while it lacks a clinic network, Amazon is leaning into its core strength, logistics. Its recent launch of at-home diagnostics in six Indian cities via a partnership with Orange Health sent shockwaves through the market, triggering concerns for local diagnostics giants. By integrating test booking directly into its app, Amazon is building a tech-enabled healthcare layer on top of its existing consumer base and delivery infrastructure, reinforcing its push toward frictionless, on-demand healthcare.
Integrated Clinical Model vs. Tech-Fueled Efficiency
CVS Health is building a vertically integrated healthcare ecosystem that brings together insurance (Aetna), pharmacy services, and care delivery, offering patients a cohesive, end-to-end experience. In Q1 2025, CVS Health reported that Medicare Advantage members who use CVS pharmacies experienced 3% lower medical costs, a reflection of stronger medication adherence and care coordination.
Amazon, meanwhile, is pursuing a modular, tech-driven approach. Through Amazon One Medical in the United States, the company is embedding generative AI tools, such as Amazon Web Services (AWS), HealthScribe and Bedrock, directly into clinical workflows, slashing physicians' administrative time by around 40%. Beyond primary care, AWS is expanding its healthcare footprint with AI-powered solutions in diagnostics, medical coding, drug discovery, and operational efficiency. Rather than integrating care under one roof, Amazon is redefining each function with digital tools that emphasize productivity, scalability, and user experience.
CVS Eighth on the S&P 500 Chart, AMZN at No. 262
After a rough 2024, marked by high utilization at its Aetna insurance unit, as well as reimbursement pressure, CVS Health has experienced a dramatic recovery so far in 2025. The stock has become the S&P 500's eighth-best performer, with a year-to-date return of 56%, thereby outperforming all other index members by a significant margin. Amazon, on the other hand, is at number 262 on the chart with a 1.8% gain. These compare to the benchmark's 5.1% rise during this period.
YTD Price Performances of CVS and AMZN
Comparing EPS Projections: CVS Health & Amazon
The Zacks Consensus Estimate for CVS' 2025 earnings per share suggests a 12.7% improvement from 2024.
Image Source: Zacks Investment Research
The Zacks Consensus Estimate for AMZN's 2025 EPS implies an improvement of 12.5% over the previous fiscal.
CVS is Attractively Valued Than AMZN
CVS is trading at a forward 12-month price-to-earnings, which is a commonly used multiple for valuing healthcare stocks, of 10.48X, above its five-year median of 9.45X. Meanwhile, Amazon is presently trading at a forward 12-month price-to-earnings of 33.3X, which is below its five-year median of 55.1X.
This suggests that while CVS may appear slightly elevated compared with its own historical average, it remains attractively valued relative to CVS.
Buy CVS Now, Hold AMZN
While Amazon is making bold, tech-driven plays in healthcare, CVS Health is firmly holding its ground with a focused, integrated strategy. Backed by a Zacks Rank #2 (Buy), CVS is outperforming the market in 2025 through strong Medicare Advantage growth and disciplined execution. Amazon, a Zacks Rank #3 (Hold) stock, remains an innovator, but its healthcare efforts are still maturing and carry greater execution risk. For near-term earnings prospects and sector leadership, CVS stands out as the better investment today. You can see the complete list of today's Zacks Rank #1 (Strong Buy) stocks here.
Zacks Names #1 Semiconductor Stock
It's only 1/9,000th the size of NVIDIA which skyrocketed more than +800% since we recommended it. NVIDIA is still strong, but our new top chip stock has much more room to boom.
With strong earnings growth and an expanding customer base, it's positioned to feed the rampant demand for Artificial Intelligence, Machine Learning, and Internet of Things. Global semiconductor manufacturing is projected to explode from $452 billion in 2021 to $803 billion by 2028.
See This Stock Now for Free >>
Want the latest recommendations from Zacks Investment Research? Today, you can download 7 Best Stocks for the Next 30 Days.
CVS Health Corporation (CVS): Free Stock Analysis Report
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
14 minutes ago
- CBC
Non-profit run by 23andMe co-founder gets court approval to buy the genetic testing company
Social Sharing Anne Wojcicki's bid to buy 23andMe, the genetic testing company she co-founded nearly 20 years ago, has received the court green light. That means Wojcicki's non-profit TTAM Research Institute will purchase "substantially all" of San Francisco-based 23andMe's assets for $305 million US (about $416 million Cdn). The transaction — which arrives more than three months after 23andMe filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy — is set to officially close in the coming weeks. "I am thrilled that TTAM will be able to build on the mission of 23andMe to help people access, understand and benefit from the human genome," Wojcicki said in a statement Monday. She later added that, "the future of health care belongs to all of us." The sale, which was approved by U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Brian C. Walsh on Friday, marks the end of a months-long bidding war between TTAM and Regeneron Pharmaceuticals — a biotech company that had previously agreed to buy most of 23andMe's assets for $256 million US in May. But Wojcicki's non-profit later topped that offer, winning the final round of bidding held last month. Under the deal, TTAM will acquire 23andMe's signature "Personal Genome Service" provided through the company's saliva-based DNA testing kits — as well as research operations and its Lemonaid Health subsidiary, a telehealth services provider that 23andMe previously planned to wind down. Wojcicki had worked to take 23andMe private for some time. With the company struggling to find a profitable business model since going public in 2021, she's maintained that it would operate better outside market pressures. But that endeavour proved to be tumultuous — notably in September of last year, when all of 23andMe's independent directors resigned from its board citing a "clear" difference of opinion with Wojcicki on the company's future following drawn-out negotiations. Leading up to 23andMe's March bankruptcy filing, subsequent efforts from Wojcicki to acquire the company were unsuccessful. And when 23andMe filed for Chapter 11 in late March, Wojcicki resigned as CEO — noting at the time that she was stepping down to be "in the best position" as an independent bidder. Now that Wojcicki's non-profit will acquire 23andMe, it's unclear whether the co-founder will step back into the CEO seat. But despite stepping down from the top post months ago, Wojcicki has remained on the company's board throughout the bankruptcy process. Beyond financial strains leading up to 23andMe's bankruptcy, privacy concerns related to customers' genetic information also emerged — dating back to even before the bankruptcy process, notably with a 2023 data breach. But concern what new ownership could mean for 23andMe users' personal data has bubbled up in recent months. The genetic testing business had about 13 million customers at the time of its sale hearing, court documents note. WATCH | 23andMe customers urged to delete personal data: 23andMe customers urged to delete personal data 3 months ago Duration 1:44 Roughly 15 million customers who used the genetic testing company 23andMe are being urged to take steps to delete their personal data and protect their privacy. Cybersecurity experts say that DNA data could be sold as part of a restructuring or sale after the company filed for bankruptcy protection. In June, 27 states and the District of Columbia filed a lawsuit seeking to block the sale of personal genetic data by 23andMe without customer consent. And in a memorandum opinion outlining his approval 23andMe's sale to TTAM on Friday, Walsh acknowledged these states' objections to the acquisition — but that noted many had since been resolved. Still, California, Kentucky, Tennessee, Texas, and Utah "remain actively opposed to the sale." In a statement to Politico on Monday, California Attorney General Rob Bonta's office maintained that 23andMe's sale "does not comply" with genetic privacy law in the state — and said it was "disappointed" with the court's approval, adding that it was evaluating next steps. The Associated Press reached out to Bonta's office for further comment on Tuesday. When announcing its intended sale to Wojcicki's non-profit last month, 23andMe confirmed that TTAM "has affirmed its commitment" to comply with the company privacy policies and applicable law. That means TTAM will honour existing policies around consumer data, the company said, which includes allowing users to delete their data and "opt out" of research. All customers will be emailed at least two business days before the acquisition closes — with details on TTAM's privacy commitments and instructions on how to delete data or opt out of research, 23andMe said. The company added that TTAM will offer customers two years of Experian identity theft monitoring at no cost. 23andMe reiterated those privacy policies on Monday. And Wojcicki said: "Core to my beliefs is that individuals should be empowered to have choice and transparency with respect to their genetic data and have the opportunity to continue to learn about their ancestry and health risks as they wish."
Canada Standard
30 minutes ago
- Canada Standard
Economic Watch: U.S. ramps up trade pressure on multiple fronts as 90-day tariff deadline approaches
The United States is scrambling to wind up trade talks with a large number of trading partners as the self-imposed deadline of July 9 is approaching. Following Canada's concession, Trump is continuing his efforts to press multiple trade partners. BEIJING, July 1 (Xinhua) -- Days after U.S. President Donald Trump threatened to halt trade talks and impose tariffs, Canada scrapped its planned digital services tax on Sunday. The White House praised the move, saying talks would resume immediately and declaring that Canada had "caved" to the United States. The United States is scrambling to wind up trade talks with a large number of trading partners as the self-imposed deadline of July 9 is approaching. Following Canada's concession, Trump is continuing his efforts to press multiple trade partners. While the EU stood firm on protecting its digital sovereignty and rejected U.S. demands to include digital laws in trade talks, Trump moved on to Japan on Sunday, accusing it of refusing to buy American rice amid a shortage and threatening a formal trade complaint shortly after labeling U.S.-Japan trade "unfair." U-TURN ON TALKS Canadian Finance Minister Francois-Philippe Champagne announced Sunday that Canada will rescind its digital services tax as it prepares for a broader trade agreement with the United States. The tax, which was designed to take effect on Monday, would impose a 3 percent levy on the revenue of U.S. multinational companies like Amazon, Google and Meta earned from Canadian users. "It's very simple: Canadian Prime Minister (Mark) Carney and Canada caved to President Trump and the United States of America," White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt told reporters on Monday at a briefing. Leavitt's comments followed remarks by National Economic Council Director Kevin Hassett, who said the United States will restart trade negotiations with Canada immediately. According to him, the White House is likely to push other countries to abandon their digital services taxes in future trade negotiations, building on Canada's recent reversal. "My expectation is that the digital services taxes around the world will be taken off, and that that will be a key part of the ... ongoing trade negotiations that we have," Hassett was quoted by CNBC as saying. Hassett suggested that countries planning to maintain or introduce digital services taxes could face the "wrath" from U.S. Trade Representative Jameson Greer over what he called "unfair trade practices." INEFFECTIVE STRATEGY Washington's pressure tactics didn't prove effective with the EU, where officials have firmly rejected including digital legislation in trade talks with the United States. "Our legislation will not be changed. The Digital Markets Act (DMA) and the Digital Services Act (DSA) are not on the table in the trade negotiations with the U.S.," European Commission spokesperson Thomas Regnier told a briefing Monday. Washington has repeatedly slammed the EU's digital regulations, including the DMA and DSA, as unfair and called for looser oversight of American tech firms. In February, the White House warned it might retaliate if EU regulators targeted U.S. companies under those rules. Regnier emphasized that European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen has made it clear that EU legislation is not up for negotiation, "and this also includes, of course, our digital legislation," he said. "We're not going to adjust the implementation of our legislation based on the actions of third countries. If we started to do that, then we would have to do it with numerous third countries," Regnier added. Nevertheless, the spokesperson said that the Commission remains committed to reaching a trade deal with the United States by July 9. Trump had earlier said the talks were "going nowhere" and threatened a 50 percent tariff on all EU imports starting June 1. After a call with von der Leyen, he agreed to postpone the hike until July 9. European Commissioner for Trade and Economic Security Maros Sefcovic said on Monday that he would travel to Washington on Tuesday to try to avoid higher U.S. tariffs and reach a deal "fair for both sides." Currently, the EU faces 50 percent U.S. tariffs on steel, aluminum and 25 percent on automobiles, alongside 10 percent baseline duties on most other exports. NEXT ON LIST In a Truth Social post on Monday afternoon, Trump claimed that the Japanese people and their government were "spoiled" because they wouldn't buy American rice. "To show people how spoiled Countries have become with respect to the United States of America, and I have great respect for Japan, they won't take our RICE, and yet they have a massive rice shortage," Trump wrote. "In other words, we'll just be sending them a letter." Yet rice, like the EU's digital regulations, is not on the Japanese menu for trade talks with the United States. On Tuesday, Japanese Economic Revitalization Minister Ryosei Akazawa, who is also the chief representative in tariff negotiations with the U.S. administration, said that his country will not sacrifice the agricultural sector as part of its tariff talks with the United States, adding that he would continue to negotiate with his U.S. counterparts to protect Japan's national interests. "I have repeatedly stated that agriculture is the foundation of the nation," he told a press conference. Trump's rice complaint followed another swipe at Tokyo's trade practices. In an interview aired on Fox News a day earlier, he slammed Japan for importing too few American cars, saying, "They won't take our cars, and yet we take millions and millions of their cars into the United States. It's not fair," he said. "I could send one (letter) to Japan: 'Dear Mr. Japan, here's the story. You're going to pay a 25 percent tariff on your cars,'" Trump said during the interview.
Globe and Mail
38 minutes ago
- Globe and Mail
Old National Names Matt Keen Chief Information Officer
MINNEAPOLIS and ST. PAUL, Minn., July 01, 2025 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) -- (NASDAQ: ONB) – Old National Bancorp ('Old National') has appointed Matt Keen as Chief Information Officer (CIO). In this role, Keen will join Old National's Executive Leadership Team – the company's senior-most group of C-suite executives. Keen brings more than three decades of experience in significant technology leadership roles at national companies, including leading architecture development, as well as experience with brokerage and banking services, cloud service optimization, and platform modernization. 'As Old National continues our Midwest and Southeast expansion, our technology strategy and capabilities are also evolving to continue meeting our ever-growing clients' needs and expectations,' said Old National Chairman & CEO Jim Ryan. 'Matt's wide-ranging technology expertise will be essential for helping us innovate and deliver client-focused solutions, while also supporting the personal relationships that have always been the heart of our success.' Keen's previous technology leadership experience included consulting with American Express as part of his tenure at PriceWaterhouseCoopers, almost 15 years at Ameriprise Financial (formerly a division of American Express), and six years at Two Harbors Investments. Most recently, he served as CIO for Bremer Bank, which became a division of Old National Bank on May 1, 2025. As Old National's CIO, Keen will lead a forward-thinking approach to leveraging technology as an enabler for business success. He will shape and execute the company's technology strategy, working closely and collaboratively with all aspects of the business to identify ways to increase efficiencies and drive growth. With a particular emphasis on innovation, Keen and his team will use technology, as well as data and analytics, to effectively support and enhance the client and team member experience, to meet their ever-evolving expectations. 'I'm looking forward to continuing to advance the strong technology foundation that has enabled Old National to achieve its growth goals,' Keen said. 'Through a collaborative approach and intense focus on our clients, we'll bring forward the best technology capabilities to serve the business and support the culture that our team members, clients, and communities expect and appreciate.' A resident of Chanhassen, Minn., Keen holds a degree in quantitative methods and computer science from the University of St. Thomas. Keen succeeds retiring Chief Information Officer Paul S. Kilroy, who joined Old National in 2020. During his tenure, Kilroy spearheaded a groundbreaking partnership with Infosys that vastly improved contact center quality and stabilized information quality metrics across the organization, leading to a 2024 'Tech Exec of the Year' honor from the Indianapolis Business Journal. ABOUT OLD NATIONAL Old National Bancorp (NASDAQ: ONB) is the holding company of Old National Bank. As the fifth largest commercial bank headquartered in the Midwest, Old National proudly serves clients primarily in the Midwest and Southeast. With approximately $70 billion of assets and $37 billion of assets under management (including Bremer Financial Corporation on a pro forma basis as of March 31, 2025), Old National ranks among the top 25 banking companies headquartered in the United States. Tracing our roots to 1834, Old National focuses on building long-term, highly valued partnerships with clients while also strengthening and supporting the communities we serve. In addition to providing extensive services in consumer and commercial banking, Old National offers comprehensive wealth management and capital markets services. For more information and financial data, please visit Investor Relations at In 2025, Points of Light again named Old National one of "The Civic 50" -- an honor reserved for the 50 most community-minded companies in the United States. Media Relations: Rick Vach (904) 535-9489 A photo accompanying this announcement is available at
