Should KiwiSaver evolve – or hold the line?
Retirement worries on the rise
More New Zealanders are heading into retirement with a sinking feeling, Kevin Norquay and Virginia Fallon reported in the Sunday Star Times yesterday (paywalled). According to a new survey of retirees by the Retirement Commission, only around half are feeling even somewhat confident they have saved enough, while one in five said they had no confidence at all. Nearly 40% of retirees rely solely on NZ Superannuation to get by, and a further 20% say they depend on it plus only a little extra.
The people most at risk of hardship are those who live alone, rent or have experienced setbacks such as illness or divorce, with single women among the most vulnerable. Lead researcher Dr Jo Gamble said many of those surveyed were 'just scraping by' and worried about what a financial shock could mean for their future. Retirement commissioner Jane Wrightson reinforced the message: NZ Super alone is no longer enough for a comfortable old age – KiwiSaver and other investments are now essential.
Bolder investments, bigger balances?
In that context, new research from the Financial Markets Authority (FMA) suggesting New Zealanders are becoming more proactive about growing their retirement savings is good news. The proportion of KiwiSaver funds in higher-risk portfolios has jumped from 10% in 2021 to over 40% today – a 'dramatic' shift that could leave investors better off, assuming long-term market trends continue. Morningstar data backs that up: aggressive funds have averaged 10.89% annual returns over the past five years, compared to just over 3% for conservative options. The move reflects both better investor education and the wider availability of growth-oriented products.
But for some, the change is also cause for concern, writes Newsroom's Jonathan Milne. Financial commentator Janine Starks tells him that older investors may be staying too long in standalone, high-risk KiwiSaver funds, when it would be safer to diversify their investments and spread the risk as they approach retirement.
A controversial argument for more withdrawals
One complication in risk planning is that KiwiSaver now serves two very different goals: saving for retirement and, increasingly, for buying a first home. As David Hargreaves points out in Interest.co.nz, those goals carry contradictory risk profiles – a person buying a home in five years should be in a lower-risk fund, while someone saving for retirement should generally opt for growth. He suggests allowing people to split their KiwiSaver contributions or creating a separate savings scheme for housing.
A more contentious position is held by property investor Nicole Lewis, whose column in Stuff calls for KiwiSaver to allow investment property purchases, not just first homes. With the average first-home buyer now aged 37, she argues many are left with little time to rebuild their balances. If KiwiSaver could be used for 'rentvesting' – buying in a cheaper region and renting where you live – then people would be able to purchase property earlier, giving them longer to save for retirement, she says. 'If [KiwiSaver] is to help New Zealanders achieve financial security in retirement, then home ownership, whether for living in or renting out, must remain central to that mission.'
Should KiwiSaver fund farms?
Lewis's argument is part of a broader push to expand KiwiSaver's purpose. Federated Farmers recently launched a campaign urging the government to let young farmers withdraw funds to buy their first farm, herd or flock – a proposal finance minister Nicola Willis says she's 'sympathetic to' and currently reviewing with Inland Revenue. Critics warn such a change would open a Pandora's box, reports Jenée Tibshraeny in the Herald (Premium paywalled). Massey University's Claire Matthews says allowing farm purchases blurs the line between home and business investment and risks undermining the fund's integrity.
Simplicity economist Shamubeel Eaqub notes that most farmers don't contribute to KiwiSaver anyway, and the average balance would barely make a dent in the cost of a farm. The proposal, he argues, could 'weaken KiwiSaver's core purpose' while benefiting very few. The bigger question, says the Retirement Commission's Tom Hartmann, is what KiwiSaver is really for – and whether broadening withdrawal criteria today could jeopardise retirement security tomorrow. As more people rely on KiwiSaver to bridge the growing gap left by NZ Super, the stakes for any change are higher than ever.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Herald
3 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Inflation data delivers ‘green light' for rate cut, but food prices cause concern
'Home ownership (otherwise known as building costs) fell 0.1% in the quarter to be up just 0.8% for the year,' he said. 'The last time annual building cost inflation was this low was in the depths of the GFC and, before that, the 1998/1999 recession.' Weak building costs also flowed through to property maintenance which experienced 1.4% annual inflation, he said. There was annual deflation for furniture, furnishings and floor coverings, household textiles and household appliances. But the really worrying thing was that the cost of essentials was rising far faster than the remainder of the CPI, he said. 'There are a lot of ways that you can cut this but we reckon the things that are most essential are food, accommodation and energy (electricity, gas and petrol).' 'Our very back-of-the-envelope 'essentials index' shows the cost of essentials rising at around twice the pace of the remainder of the CPI.' The biggest concern was that food price inflation had accelerated to an annual 4.2% following a 1.6% quarterly increase, he said. As well as being a significant hardship for a large portion of the population, this was adding to the headwinds for the economic recovery. 'If GDP is to pick up meaningfully then household consumption has to rise. With effective real disposable incomes under so much pressure there is very little chance of an increase in real spending.' BNZ's early forecast for the current quarter was for prices to rise 0.8% in the quarter, taking the annual rate to 2.9%. Other economists have forecast the third quarter rate to rise above the upper limit of the RBNZ's 1-3% target range. 'We also acknowledge that there is some upside risk to this,' Toplis said. 'But the good news is that we believe that will be the peak with annual inflation back near the midpoint of the RBNZ's target band by this time next year.' A key assumption was that food price inflation would soon abate, he said. 'New Zealand commodity price inflation is already past its peak and this is normally a forerunner to domestic prices, particularly for food. There is even a chance that food prices outright fall.' BNZ also assumes further falls for petrol prices drift lower. With the economy continuing to perform below capacity, there would be continued downward pressure on non-tradeable inflation, he said. KiwiBank senior economist Mary Jo Vergara noted that tradeable inflation was on the rise. Mary Jo Vergara, Kiwibank economist. Photo / Supplied 'We're no longer importing deflation,' she said. Annual tradeables inflation lifted from 0.3% to 1.2%. 'The 4.2% increase in food prices accounted for 28.5% of the lift in headline inflation,' she said. 'Domestic inflation, in contrast, continues its (slow) move south.' Annual non-tradeables inflation fell below 4% for the first time in four years to 3.7%. 'Domestic inflation had fallen some way from its 6.8% peak in 2023, but it was still sitting high above the long-term average (around 3%). 'And that's despite such a weak domestic economy.' The persistence was due to lingering strength in 'administered prices' such as rates, insurance costs and power. Annual council rates and insurance costs were running well above historic averages, up 12.2% and 6%, respectively, she said. Households were also contending with high electricity charges, climbing to 9.1% annually. 'Given excess capacity still sloshing in the economy, domestic inflation should continue to head lower. But the pace of easing is being dictated by factors largely outside of the RBNZ's control,' Vergara said. 'That's a frustration.' Overall, the data added to the case for another OCR cut in August and suggested risks were tilting towards further easing being delivered sooner than previously expected, ANZ senior economist Miles Workman said. 'We have long been expecting the RBNZ will need to cut the OCR more than they have recently been signalling,' he said. 'With [this] data not the roadblock we thought it was going to be, the risk of a follow-up cut in October is now looking higher.' Liam Dann is business editor-at-large for the New Zealand Herald. He is a senior writer and columnist, and also presents and produces videos and podcasts. He joined the Herald in 2003.
Scoop
6 hours ago
- Scoop
ComCom Finds No Evidence Of Cartel Behaviour In Banks' Involvement In Net-Zero Banking Alliance
The Commerce Commission has investigated and found no evidence to support a complaint from Federated Farmers of New Zealand (Federated Farmers) alleging potentially anti-competitive, coordinated, cartel-like behaviour involving five major banks in New Zealand associated with the Net-Zero Banking Alliance. The banks involved are ANZ Bank New Zealand Limited (ANZ), ASB Bank Limited (ASB), Bank of New Zealand (BNZ), Rabobank New Zealand Limited (Rabobank), and Westpac New Zealand Limited (Westpac). These banks collectively account for around 97% of New Zealand's agricultural lending market. Commerce Commission General Manager Competition, Fair Trading and Credit Vanessa Horne says the complaint, received last December, alleged the banks were coordinating their agricultural lending policies to align with Net-Zero Banking Alliance strategies and targets. It alleged that, in doing so, the banks were potentially acting anti-competitively, in breach of the Commerce Act. The complaint also raised concerns that this alleged coordination could reduce farmers' access to capital, resulting in higher borrowing costs and stricter lending terms. 'We know New Zealanders are very focused on the work being done by the Commission (and others) to ensure banks are acting fairly - and farmers are no different,' says Ms Horne. 'If we see activity that falls foul of the laws we enforce, we will not hesitate to act. In this case, however, we thoroughly investigated the complaint and concluded that the banks had made their own, independent decisions. We found no evidence of unlawful coordination between the banks or with the Net-Zero Banking Alliance, either relating to the banks joining or in meeting their obligations under this alliance.' On that basis, the Commission says, it will be taking no further action. The Commission is keenly aware that, in many sectors, New Zealand businesses are working hard to develop and deliver sustainability initiatives together. New Zealand's competition laws can accommodate such collaboration - to help businesses, the Commission has developed Collaboration and Sustainability Guidelines that can be found on its website. Background The Net-Zero Banking Alliance The Net-Zero Banking Alliance is a United Nations (UN) convened initiative, supporting banks to lead on climate mitigation in line with the goals of the Paris Agreement. It was co-launched on 21 April 2021 by the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) Financial Initiative and the Prince of Wales Sustainable Markets Initiative Financial Services Taskforce, with 43 initial banks as signatories. Joining the Net-Zero Banking Alliance is entirely voluntary, and any signatory may join or withdraw at any time. Banks that choose to become signatories to this alliance make a public statement of an intention to align the greenhouse gas emissions from their lending and investment portfolios with net-zero pathways by 2050 or earlier. The Net-Zero Banking Alliance does not prescribe targets that signatories should set. Instead, it provides signatories with a framework for target setting, resources, global expertise, and tools to help them individually assess the emissions within their portfolios and understand ways that the shift of capital towards low-carbon activity might be accelerated.
Scoop
7 hours ago
- Scoop
Inflation Remains Within Target Range
Minister of Finance New data released today shows inflation remains under control, Finance Minister Nicola Willis says. Stats NZ released the Consumers Price Index today, showing inflation increased slightly to 2.7 per cent in the 12 months to the June 2025 quarter, remaining in the Reserve Bank's target range. 'It's the fourth consecutive quarter inflation has remained within the target range – a stark contrast to under the previous government, where inflation raged on unchecked, reaching 7.3 per cent in 2022,' Nicola Willis says. 'New Zealanders can be assured it now has a Government that is paying attention to forces that affect their cost of living. 'It's pleasing to see non-tradeables inflation – which paints a picture of domestic demand and supply conditions – continues to fall. 'However, the effect of council rates on inflation is a concern.' Stats NZ noted the largest single contributor to annual inflation was local authority rates and payments, which rose 12.2 per cent in the year. 'That's why this Government has also been clear in its call to councils to focus on the basics and keep rates under control. We look forward to councils taking heed of this and playing their role as stewards of ratepayers' money better in the future. 'External pressures on inflation remain, and we must remain cautious – it's a reminder that the economic recovery is not to be taken for granted. 'That's why this Government is focused on economic growth, because that is New Zealand's pathway to more jobs, higher incomes and the money to pay for schools, hospitals and safer communities.'
