Australian on-road tests reveal top-selling EVs like BYD Atto 3 and Tesla Model 3 fall short of promised range
One popular SUV performed particularly poorly, stopping short of its advertised range by more than 100km.
The Australian Automobile Association released the results on Thursday after testing five electric vehicles as part of its $14 million Real-World Testing Program.
The findings come one week after the program revealed 25 out of 30 petrol and hybrid vehicles tested had consumed more fuel than their lab results showed and more than three in every four vehicles examined had failed to meet expectations.
The motoring body road-tested five electric vehicles in its first trial of the technology, using a 93km circuit around Geelong in Victoria in damp and dry conditions, and measuring the vehicles' energy consumption.
BYD's Atto 3 SUV produced the worst result of the models tested, falling short of its promised range by 111km or 23 per cent, and using 21 per cent more power than advertised.
Tesla's entry-level electric car, the Model 3, also failed to meet its promised range by 14 per cent, or 72km, and used six per cent more electricity than lab results showed.
The Tesla Model Y and Kia EV6 SUVs also failed to meet their range by eight per cent, or just over 40km, while the Smart #3 electric car came the closest to its lab test results, falling within five per cent or 23km of the advertised range.
The results could help families and fleet managers make choices about their next vehicle purchases, association managing director Michael Bradley said, as research showed range anxiety remained a significant concern for buyers.
'As more EVs enter our market, our testing will help consumers understand which new market entrants measure up on battery range,' he said.
An electric car's range could be affected by a number of factors, Australian Electric Vehicle Association national president Chris Jones said.
These include high or low temperatures, headwinds, steep terrain, and the use of air conditioning and heating features.
Car makers should seek to 'under-promise and over-deliver' when it comes to vehicle range, he said, to allow buyers to make informed choices about the models that will suit their needs.
'It is frustrating that manufacturers are inflating the values when they really ought to be a bit more conservative,' Mr Jones said.
'I would have thought a 10 per cent difference was reasonable but 20 per cent is pretty bad.'
Electric vehicle range is typically tested in Australia using the older New European Driving Cycle (NEDC) laboratory test, but this will be replaced by the more accurate Worldwide Harmonised Light Vehicle Test Procedure (WLTP) from December.
The Australian Automobile Association's vehicle-testing program, funded by the federal government, has examined 114 fuel-powered vehicles since it began in 2023 and found 88 models, or 77 per cent, failed to meet their advertised energy consumption.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sydney Morning Herald
11 hours ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
China's EVs are dirt cheap. Its policymakers are concerned
Electric vehicles are an absolute steal in China right now. And the country's top leaders are concerned. EV manufacturers are locked in a death spiral of cost-cutting fuelled by weak domestic demand and an overcrowded, ferociously competitive marketplace that has been bloated by state subsidies. Today, Chinese motorists can drive off in BYD's top-selling Seagull hatchback for just 50,800 yuan (about $11,000) – more than 30 per cent below its guide price – after the EV giant kicked off a price-slashing war in May to squeeze its rivals. Its competitors followed suit. Only a handful of the 129 EV brands in China are turning a profit, BYD among them, while others are simply trying to outlast their rivals in weathering mounting losses. The toxic competition has spawned a phenomenon of dealers passing off new cars, fresh off the assembly line, as 'zero-mileage' used cars. They are then heavily discounted and sold domestically and overseas to boost revenue and clear inventory, while further driving down prices. The price war has prompted warnings from analysts, and even carmakers, of a looming mass consolidation that will wipe out dozens of players – a bad outcome for buyers and one that will drive up unemployment. The EU, US and even China's friends in Asia and South America have complained about cheap Chinese goods flooding their markets and wiping out local competitors. You won't see Chinese EVs on American roads. They have been shut out by a 100 per cent tariff imposed by the Biden administration to protect American carmakers.
The Age
11 hours ago
- The Age
China's EVs are dirt cheap. Its policymakers are concerned
Electric vehicles are an absolute steal in China right now. And the country's top leaders are concerned. EV manufacturers are locked in a death spiral of cost-cutting fuelled by weak domestic demand and an overcrowded, ferociously competitive marketplace that has been bloated by state subsidies. Today, Chinese motorists can drive off in BYD's top-selling Seagull hatchback for just 50,800 yuan (about $11,000) – more than 30 per cent below its guide price – after the EV giant kicked off a price-slashing war in May to squeeze its rivals. Its competitors followed suit. Only a handful of the 129 EV brands in China are turning a profit, BYD among them, while others are simply trying to outlast their rivals in weathering mounting losses. The toxic competition has spawned a phenomenon of dealers passing off new cars, fresh off the assembly line, as 'zero-mileage' used cars. They are then heavily discounted and sold domestically and overseas to boost revenue and clear inventory, while further driving down prices. The price war has prompted warnings from analysts, and even carmakers, of a looming mass consolidation that will wipe out dozens of players – a bad outcome for buyers and one that will drive up unemployment. The EU, US and even China's friends in Asia and South America have complained about cheap Chinese goods flooding their markets and wiping out local competitors. You won't see Chinese EVs on American roads. They have been shut out by a 100 per cent tariff imposed by the Biden administration to protect American carmakers.
The Advertiser
2 days ago
- The Advertiser
Electric goes large: low-emission utes, vans get a show
Australian drivers love utes, but for years there have been few low-emission options. Electric and hybrid utility vehicles have gone on show alongside battery-powered vans and trucks in Sydney at the first Australian event dedicated to light commercial vehicles. Transport experts welcomed the changes but they warned major vehicle manufacturers were still delaying the launch of some electric utes, meaning the transition away from petrol- and diesel-powered offerings could take several years. The exhibition on Thursday and Friday came after BYD posted record sales for its plug-in hybrid ute during June and July, helping the Chinese firm surpass US electric car giant Tesla. Shifting driver attitudes and government policies were largely responsible for changing the automotive market, FutureDrive AutoShows chief executive Ray Evans said. Those changes had encouraged sole traders, and small and large businesses, to seek more-efficient vehicles. The arrival of electric and hybrid utes and the promise of more would usher further changes, Mr Evans said. "The EV revolution has certainly changed from when we started three years ago - we couldn't do this show," he said. "There are currently 96 to 100 electric models in market in Australia and there are another 70 coming in 2026, including light commercials." The event, held at Sydney's International Convention Centre, showed off converted Ford F-150 Lightning electric utes, as well as BYD's Shark 6 plug-in hybrid and electric vans from Volkswagen and newcomer Farizon. Traditional diesel utes such as Kia's Tasman and the RAM 1500 Hurricane would also go on show, Mr Evans said, but he expected many buyers to inspect low-emission offerings first. "You've got your big players, obviously, with Fords and Toyotas, but there are a lot of challengers coming into the space," he said. "More than ever, businesses are looking at what the options are and what's happening within the new energy space." Other companies offering electric and hybrid utes in Australia include Chinese brands LDV and GWM, with models expected from established players Ford and Isuzu within months. Adding utes to the nation's electrified fleet would be critical to helping EVs become a mainstream purchase, Australian Electric Vehicle Association president Chris Jones said, as utes had become a mainstay. "We've got pretty much every other mode and every other segment covered, but utes and vans are a bit of a deficiency," he said. "If you can convince rural and regional Australia to buy an EV, then you've convinced everyone, because they'll probably be the most sceptical." Some vehicle manufacturers were still reticent to make left-hand-drive electric utes for Australia though, Dr Jones warned, such as Rivian with its R1T and Ford with its F-150. Australian drivers love utes, but for years there have been few low-emission options. Electric and hybrid utility vehicles have gone on show alongside battery-powered vans and trucks in Sydney at the first Australian event dedicated to light commercial vehicles. Transport experts welcomed the changes but they warned major vehicle manufacturers were still delaying the launch of some electric utes, meaning the transition away from petrol- and diesel-powered offerings could take several years. The exhibition on Thursday and Friday came after BYD posted record sales for its plug-in hybrid ute during June and July, helping the Chinese firm surpass US electric car giant Tesla. Shifting driver attitudes and government policies were largely responsible for changing the automotive market, FutureDrive AutoShows chief executive Ray Evans said. Those changes had encouraged sole traders, and small and large businesses, to seek more-efficient vehicles. The arrival of electric and hybrid utes and the promise of more would usher further changes, Mr Evans said. "The EV revolution has certainly changed from when we started three years ago - we couldn't do this show," he said. "There are currently 96 to 100 electric models in market in Australia and there are another 70 coming in 2026, including light commercials." The event, held at Sydney's International Convention Centre, showed off converted Ford F-150 Lightning electric utes, as well as BYD's Shark 6 plug-in hybrid and electric vans from Volkswagen and newcomer Farizon. Traditional diesel utes such as Kia's Tasman and the RAM 1500 Hurricane would also go on show, Mr Evans said, but he expected many buyers to inspect low-emission offerings first. "You've got your big players, obviously, with Fords and Toyotas, but there are a lot of challengers coming into the space," he said. "More than ever, businesses are looking at what the options are and what's happening within the new energy space." Other companies offering electric and hybrid utes in Australia include Chinese brands LDV and GWM, with models expected from established players Ford and Isuzu within months. Adding utes to the nation's electrified fleet would be critical to helping EVs become a mainstream purchase, Australian Electric Vehicle Association president Chris Jones said, as utes had become a mainstay. "We've got pretty much every other mode and every other segment covered, but utes and vans are a bit of a deficiency," he said. "If you can convince rural and regional Australia to buy an EV, then you've convinced everyone, because they'll probably be the most sceptical." Some vehicle manufacturers were still reticent to make left-hand-drive electric utes for Australia though, Dr Jones warned, such as Rivian with its R1T and Ford with its F-150. Australian drivers love utes, but for years there have been few low-emission options. Electric and hybrid utility vehicles have gone on show alongside battery-powered vans and trucks in Sydney at the first Australian event dedicated to light commercial vehicles. Transport experts welcomed the changes but they warned major vehicle manufacturers were still delaying the launch of some electric utes, meaning the transition away from petrol- and diesel-powered offerings could take several years. The exhibition on Thursday and Friday came after BYD posted record sales for its plug-in hybrid ute during June and July, helping the Chinese firm surpass US electric car giant Tesla. Shifting driver attitudes and government policies were largely responsible for changing the automotive market, FutureDrive AutoShows chief executive Ray Evans said. Those changes had encouraged sole traders, and small and large businesses, to seek more-efficient vehicles. The arrival of electric and hybrid utes and the promise of more would usher further changes, Mr Evans said. "The EV revolution has certainly changed from when we started three years ago - we couldn't do this show," he said. "There are currently 96 to 100 electric models in market in Australia and there are another 70 coming in 2026, including light commercials." The event, held at Sydney's International Convention Centre, showed off converted Ford F-150 Lightning electric utes, as well as BYD's Shark 6 plug-in hybrid and electric vans from Volkswagen and newcomer Farizon. Traditional diesel utes such as Kia's Tasman and the RAM 1500 Hurricane would also go on show, Mr Evans said, but he expected many buyers to inspect low-emission offerings first. "You've got your big players, obviously, with Fords and Toyotas, but there are a lot of challengers coming into the space," he said. "More than ever, businesses are looking at what the options are and what's happening within the new energy space." Other companies offering electric and hybrid utes in Australia include Chinese brands LDV and GWM, with models expected from established players Ford and Isuzu within months. Adding utes to the nation's electrified fleet would be critical to helping EVs become a mainstream purchase, Australian Electric Vehicle Association president Chris Jones said, as utes had become a mainstay. "We've got pretty much every other mode and every other segment covered, but utes and vans are a bit of a deficiency," he said. "If you can convince rural and regional Australia to buy an EV, then you've convinced everyone, because they'll probably be the most sceptical." Some vehicle manufacturers were still reticent to make left-hand-drive electric utes for Australia though, Dr Jones warned, such as Rivian with its R1T and Ford with its F-150. Australian drivers love utes, but for years there have been few low-emission options. Electric and hybrid utility vehicles have gone on show alongside battery-powered vans and trucks in Sydney at the first Australian event dedicated to light commercial vehicles. Transport experts welcomed the changes but they warned major vehicle manufacturers were still delaying the launch of some electric utes, meaning the transition away from petrol- and diesel-powered offerings could take several years. The exhibition on Thursday and Friday came after BYD posted record sales for its plug-in hybrid ute during June and July, helping the Chinese firm surpass US electric car giant Tesla. Shifting driver attitudes and government policies were largely responsible for changing the automotive market, FutureDrive AutoShows chief executive Ray Evans said. Those changes had encouraged sole traders, and small and large businesses, to seek more-efficient vehicles. The arrival of electric and hybrid utes and the promise of more would usher further changes, Mr Evans said. "The EV revolution has certainly changed from when we started three years ago - we couldn't do this show," he said. "There are currently 96 to 100 electric models in market in Australia and there are another 70 coming in 2026, including light commercials." The event, held at Sydney's International Convention Centre, showed off converted Ford F-150 Lightning electric utes, as well as BYD's Shark 6 plug-in hybrid and electric vans from Volkswagen and newcomer Farizon. Traditional diesel utes such as Kia's Tasman and the RAM 1500 Hurricane would also go on show, Mr Evans said, but he expected many buyers to inspect low-emission offerings first. "You've got your big players, obviously, with Fords and Toyotas, but there are a lot of challengers coming into the space," he said. "More than ever, businesses are looking at what the options are and what's happening within the new energy space." Other companies offering electric and hybrid utes in Australia include Chinese brands LDV and GWM, with models expected from established players Ford and Isuzu within months. Adding utes to the nation's electrified fleet would be critical to helping EVs become a mainstream purchase, Australian Electric Vehicle Association president Chris Jones said, as utes had become a mainstay. "We've got pretty much every other mode and every other segment covered, but utes and vans are a bit of a deficiency," he said. "If you can convince rural and regional Australia to buy an EV, then you've convinced everyone, because they'll probably be the most sceptical." Some vehicle manufacturers were still reticent to make left-hand-drive electric utes for Australia though, Dr Jones warned, such as Rivian with its R1T and Ford with its F-150.
