NHL players walk free after gang rape trial—critics say justice system chose hockey careers over a woman's truth
A landmark sexual assault case involving five former members of Canada's World Juniors hockey team has ended in acquittals, sparking renewed criticism of the nation's hockey culture and the legal system's handling of sexual violence.
The case, centered on a 2018 incident in a London, Ontario hotel room, saw the complainant, 'EM,' testify in excruciating detail about what she described as non-consensual acts involving multiple players. Despite this, the judge found her 'not credible nor reliable,' a ruling that has left many Canadians disheartened.
A trial that put the accuser on the stand more than the accused
EM endured nine days of testimony, including seven under cross-examination by five separate defense teams.
Her account described being intoxicated, overwhelmed, and pressured into adopting a 'porn star' persona in a room of intimidating men. She admitted to trying to placate the players to avoid danger, not to willingly engage in group sex. But the judge, Justice Maria Carroccia, rejected her narrative, even citing discrepancies like her weight as evidence of dishonesty.
'The complainant, rather than answering the question truthfully, chose to repeat what she had said previously,' Carroccia said, interpreting a minor weight estimate as a sign of deceit.
This line of reasoning, critics argue, exemplifies a damaging legal double standard—one that held the complainant to impossible standards while largely ignoring the behavior of the accused.
Hockey Canada's reckoning fades as players seek return to the
NHL
Though the trial reignited scrutiny of Canadian hockey's longstanding culture of silence and impunity, reform has been slow. Hockey Canada had previously settled with EM and admitted to having a secret fund for sexual assault claims.
The revelations led to public outrage, dropped sponsors, and players being barred from the NHL.
Still, many believe this reckoning is already being walked back. With the players acquitted, their union is advocating for their reinstatement. The NHL said the conduct was 'unacceptable' but is still 'determining next steps.' For many, this signals a return to business as usual.
Also Read:
'A non-starter for the Edmonton Oilers': Carter Hart's NHL comeback faces major hurdle despite acquittal, says insider
FAQs
1. What was the outcome of the Canada hockey assault trial?
All five accused players were acquitted of sexual assault charges.
2. Did the Hockey Canada sexual assault trial judge believe the complainant's story?
No, the judge found her testimony not 'credible nor reliable.'
3. Will the players accused in the sexual assault trial return to the NHL?
The NHL has not confirmed but is reviewing the case post-verdict.
Catch Rani Rampal's inspiring story on Game On, Episode 4. Watch Here!
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
34 minutes ago
- Time of India
Sacramento Kings, Golden State Warriors in trade talks for Jonathan Kuminga amid ongoing contract standoff
Sacramento Kings is showing interest in Jonathan Kuminga (Image via Getty Images) There is still no end in sight to the Jonathan Kuminga drama. However, he is now receiving some intriguing offers from the Golden State Warriors and the Sacramento Kings. Devin Carter, Dario Saric, and second-round choices were the initial reported offer from the Sacramento Kings, but it was not going to be enough. According to reports, Sacramento Kings now want the player for Malik Monk and a first-round pick. Sacramento Kings reportedly push for Jonathan Kuminga with new trade offer The initial offers for a Jonathan Kuminga sign-and-trade have not impressed the Golden State Warriors . However, the most fascinating offer so far has reportedly been made. The Sacramento Kings, on the other hand, are looking to add some young players to their squad. Now, he is the target of their attention. By giving the NBA player a big role and the opportunity to thrive in ways the Golden State Warriors haven't been able to, they think they can maximize his potential. Hence, the Sacramento Kings have made a fresh offer for Jonathan Kuminga's trade, according to Sam Amick of The Athletic. He recently said: 'The Kings have offered Malik Monk and a lottery-protected 2030 first-round pick to the Warriors for Jonathan Kuminga. Unlike the Suns' four-year, $90 million proposal, Sacramento is only offering Kuminga a three-year contract.' He continued: 'As for the Kings, which last spoke with the Warriors earlier this week, team sources say they've offered a three-year, $63 million deal for Kuminga in a proposal that would send veteran guard Malik Monk and their 2030 first-round pick (lottery protected) to the Warriors…' Jonathan Kuminga is being desired by many teams (Image via Instagram / @jonathan_kuminga) He then concluded: 'If that pick didn't convey, then the Warriors would get the least favorable of the Kings or San Antonio's first-round pick in 2031. Those protections have been the primary sticking point, team sources said, as the Warriors have insisted that the first-rounder be unprotected. Thus, the stalemate…' This is a substantial offer. When the Sacramento Kings first tried to trade for Jonathan Kuminga, they offered a far lesser package. The Golden State Warriors might be interested in this one. Also read: Jonathan Kuminga's contract deadlock fuels Sacramento Kings' interest as trade rumors intensify this offseason For real-time updates, scores, and highlights, follow our live coverage of the India vs England Test match here. Catch Rani Rampal's inspiring story on Game On, Episode 4. Watch Here!
Time of India
44 minutes ago
- Time of India
Toronto Maple Leafs prospect Easton Cowan aims to secure NHL roster spot following Mitch Marner trade
After parting ways with star winger Mitch Marner in a blockbuster sign-and-trade with the Vegas Golden Knights, the Toronto Maple Leafs find themselves in a period of transition. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now While they've added depth through trades, one name creating buzz is 2023 first-round pick Easton Cowan. The 19-year-old forward is determined to turn heads at training camp and stake his claim on the Leafs' opening night roster. Easton Cowan targets NHL debut as Maple Leafs enter new era after Mitch Marner trade With Marner's departure freeing up cap space and creating a void in Toronto's top six, the Maple Leafs have retooled by acquiring Matias Maccelli, Nicolas Roy, and Dakota Joshua. But Cowan, the 28th overall pick in the 2023 NHL Draft could be the most intriguing addition to the offensive mix. Known for his speed, two-way play, and high-pressure performance, Cowan is expected to seriously challenge for a roster spot this fall. Cowan starred with the OHL's London Knights, scoring 83 goals and 218 points in 168 games over three seasons. His playoff numbers were even more impressive: 94 points in 55 games, including key performances in two OHL championships and a Memorial Cup victory this past season. His coach, Dale Hunter, recently endorsed his NHL readiness on The FAN Morning Show, stating: 'He's going to push to make the team... I'm betting he's going to make it.' Maple Leafs' crowded forward lineup creates uphill battle for Easton Cowan's NHL roster spot Despite his standout junior résumé and growing confidence, Cowan faces an uphill battle. Toronto already has 14 forwards on one-way NHL deals for 2025–26, not including restricted free agent Nicholas Robertson, whose future with the team remains uncertain amid trade speculation. If Robertson stays, Cowan's route to the NHL becomes narrower, but there could still be opportunities. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now He may need to outplay veterans like Calle Järnkrok or Michael Pezzetta to earn a bottom-six role, with the possibility of moving up the lineup as the season progresses. Cowan has publicly stated that he thrives under pressure and welcomes the challenge of high-stakes environments like Toronto. Easton Cowan's NHL readiness is becoming hard to ignore. With a strong development camp and training camp ahead, he has the tools, confidence, and timing to make a serious push. As the Maple Leafs shift into a post-Marner era, Cowan's rise could become one of the most compelling storylines of the season. Also Read:
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
'I no longer want to be here': Micah Parsons officially confirms trade request in emotional message to Dallas
Micah Parsons officially confirms trade request in emotional message to Dallas (Image via Getty) Micah Parsons has asked the Dallas Cowboys to trade him. He made this clear in a long message posted on X on August 1, 2025. In that message he wrote, 'I no longer want to be here,' thanking Dallas but saying he feels the team has ignored his contract needs. That is the most important part right at the start. Micah Parsons requests trade from Dallas Cowboys after talks fall apart Micah Parsons said he asked to be traded from the Dallas Cowboys on Friday, August 1, 2025, while training camp in Oxnard, California was underway. He posted a heartfelt note on X that started, 'Thank you Dallas.' In that note he said he spoke with the Cowboys earlier about a new contract, including a meeting in March 2025 with owner Jerry Jones, but the team never entered formal talks when his agent tried to get involved. Micah Parsons said no one from Dallas has had a contract discussion with his agent, David Mulugheta, yet. This led Parsons to file a trade request directly to team COO Stephen Jones. He added: 'I no longer want to be here.' He stayed quiet at first but felt pushed by media narratives and lack of respect. 'My trade request has been submitted to Stephen Jones personally.' Micah Parsons and Jerry Jones' contract talks, agent left out and rising tension Micah Parsons, born May 26, 1999, was drafted by the Cowboys in 2021 and has become one of the NFL's top defenders with multiple All-Pro, Pro Bowl, and Defensive Rookie of the Year honors. He is now 26 and playing under the team's fifth-year rookie option, set to earn around $24 million in 2025. But he is pushing for a record deal beyond that. Also Read: Cowboys Star Micah Parsons Drops Cryptic 'One Last Time' GIF Amid Contract Standoff According to league sources, tensions rose when Jerry Jones publicly downplayed Mulugheta's role, saying he didn't even know the agent's name, even though Mulugheta is highly respected. Dallas claims the spring talks counted as a handshake deal, but Parsons' camp disagrees and says the team refuses to negotiate further. As a result, he refused to join full on-field drills at camp. Some former Cowboys like Dez Bryant have said the team should focus on football and stop the drama, warning that it could hurt team trust and performance. Other teams are expected to ask Dallas about Micah Parsons, but so far the team says it has no intention to trade him at this time. For real-time updates, scores, and highlights, follow our live coverage of the India vs England Test match here. Catch Rani Rampal's inspiring story on Game On, Episode 4. Watch Here!
