Gaurav Gogoi writes to Education Minister over historical inaccuracies in Class VIII textbooks
Gaurav Gogoi
, has written to Union
Education Minister
Dharmendra Pradhan for urgent steps to correct the
historical inaccuracies
in
Class VIII textbooks
.
'The inclusion of the Ahoms, who ruled Assam for over six centuries and defended it against multiple
Mughal invasions
, is welcome and long overdue. However, their representation contains errors and oversimplifications that risk distorting students' understanding of history,' said Gogoi in his letter to Pradhan.
Finance
Value and Valuation Masterclass - Batch 4
By CA Himanshu Jain
View Program
Artificial Intelligence
AI For Business Professionals Batch 2
By Ansh Mehra
View Program
Finance
Value and Valuation Masterclass - Batch 3
By CA Himanshu Jain
View Program
Artificial Intelligence
AI For Business Professionals
By Vaibhav Sisinity
View Program
Finance
Value and Valuation Masterclass - Batch 2
By CA Himanshu Jain
View Program
Finance
Value and Valuation Masterclass Batch-1
By CA Himanshu Jain
View Program
Gogoi said that while the history textbooks of
NCERT
for Class VIII state that the Ahoms migrated from present-day Myanmar, historical scholarship locates their origin in Mung Mao, a Tai polity in the Dehong region of present-day Yunnan, China. The inaccuracy is in the chapter 'Tribes, Nomads and Settled Communities,' which deals with the
Ahom Dynasty
of Assam, Gogoi pointed out.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
With temperatures hitting 95°F, this is the mini air conditioner everyone's buying in the U.S
News of the Discovery
Undo
'The
Paik system
is inaccurately described as 'forced labour,' disregarding its nature as a rotational administrative and military service structure, which provided land and advancement opportunities,' Gogoi said in his letter.
'The account of the 1663 treaty of Ghilajarighat is distorted, as it is presented as a defeat for the Ahoms rather than the strategic truce it was—one that enabled the eventual expulsion of the Mughals from Assam. There is also an oversimplification of socio-political integration. The claim in the textbook that the Ahoms 'suppressed' the Bhuyan landlord class reduces a complex process of integration to a one-dimensional narrative,' he added.
Live Events
Gogoi further said that there are omissions, pointing out that there is no reference to significant elements such as the Khel administrative system, architectural landmarks like the Rang Ghar and the Talatal Ghar, and the Ahoms' role in shaping the Assamese identity.
Gogoi, who is also the president of the
Assam Pradesh Congress Committee
(APCC), said that such inaccuracies not only undermine the historical legacy of the Ahoms but also risk perpetuating misconceptions about the cultural heritage of Assam and the northeast.
'It's vital that the national curricula reflect historical truths with balance and respect, especially when introducing regional histories to students across India,' Gogoi said while urging the ministry to take immediate steps to correct the inaccuracies.
The Ahoms established a kingdom in Assam that lasted for nearly 600 years.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
22 minutes ago
- Time of India
'Give cheap fuel, not cheap comedy': Opposition takes on petroleum ministry over Gandhi-Savarkar poster; BJP reacts
A social media post by the oil ministry marking Independence Day has triggered a political storm, with the opposition accusing the Modi government of distorting history and glorifying 'traitors' by placing V D Savarkar above Mahatma Gandhi . The Congress reacted sharply. Party general secretary K C Venugopal posted on X, 'Every Independence Day, the Modi-led BJP makes it a point to distort history and make heroes out of traitors.' 'This Orwellian image, elevating a British mercy petitioner like Savarkar over Gandhi ji - the undisputed Mahatma who got us freedom, and completely eliminating Pandit Nehru and Sardar Patel ji, shows their contempt for our freedom fighters.' 'What else can one except from those whose forefathers collaborated with the British to sow the seeds of division and hatred that haunts us to this very day?' the Congress leader further added. Congress media and publicity department head Pawan Khera also took aim at the government, posting in Hindi, 'While mixing ethanol in petrol, now you've started mixing impurities even in freedom fighters. Those who couldn't become great in history, you're making them big on posters.' by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like American Investor Warren Buffett Recommends: 5 Books For Turning Your Life Around Blinkist: Warren Buffett's Reading List Undo 'The country is asking you for cheaper oil, not cheap comedy,' he further mocked the organisation. BJP general secretary (organisation) B L Santhosh hit back replying to Khera's post, 'Sick brigade to the core... Veer Savarkar lived and died for the country.' Congress whip in the Lok Sabha Manickam Tagore wrote on X, 'No matter how hard you try, Mr Modi, you can't push Mahatma, Netaji & Bhagat Singh below Mafiveer. Don't disgrace the martyrs who fought and died for freedom by glorifying those who begged the British with apology letters.' CPI(M) MP John Brittas also criticised the ministry's post, saying, 'The deliberate elevation of VD Savarkar over Mahatma Gandhi is not a coincidence but a calculated act. The government's actions undermine the nation's commitment to its secular Constitution. It is pertinent to note that Savarkar was an accused in Gandhi's assassination, though acquitted due to insufficient evidence. 'However, the Kapur Commission highlighted circumstantial evidence implicating Savarkar. Those who uphold the Constitution should unequivocally condemn this mockery of justice and secular values,' he further added. Tushar Gandhi, great grandson of Mahatma Gandhi, joined the criticism row, writing on X, 'Shame on the Patroleum And Natural Gas Ministry for placing the traitor and murderer Savarkar above true patriots and martyrs. That to with money of the exchequer.' What former PM Indira Gandhi thought of Savarkar Amid the opposition's criticism, BJP leader Amit Malviya recalled former Prime Minister Indira Gandhi's message on the death of Veer Savarkar, highlighting her words of praise for him. She said, 'Veer Savarkar's name has been a byword for daring and patriotism. He was cast in the mould of a classical revolutionary, and countless people drew inspiration from him. Death removes from our midst a great figure of contemporary India.' "Malviya remarked that in their opposition to Prime Minister Narendra Modi, the Congress has now disowned both Jawaharlal Nehru and Indira Gandhi," he further added. Oil ministry's post On Friday, the ministry of petroleum and natural gas shared a picture on X featuring Savarkar alongside Gandhi, Subhas Chandra Bose and Bhagat Singh, with the caption, 'Freedom was their gift, shaping the future is our mission'. The ministry's message read 'As we celebrate our nation's independence, let's remember — liberty thrives when we nurture it every day, through unity, empathy, and action. Happy Independence Day.' VD Savarkar row The row over V D Savarkar also went to court this week. Earlier on Thursday, Rahul Gandhi's lawyer withdrew a plea in a Pune court that said he was under threat from Savarkar's followers. Advocate Milind Pawar, representing Gandhi in a defamation case filed by Satyaki Savarkar, grand-nephew of Vinayak Damodar Savarkar, said the Special MP/MLA Court had accepted the withdrawal. Rahul Gandhi is out on bail in the defamation case, in which trial proceedings are yet to begin. Satyaki Savarkar alleges the Congress leader defamed his great-uncle in a March 2023 speech in London, accusing V D Savarkar of writing that he and friends had once beaten a Muslim man and felt happy about it, a claim the complainant says is entirely false and unsupported by any writing.
Time of India
34 minutes ago
- Time of India
The week that was: Azerbaijan and Armenia sign peace deal; Munir uses US trip to brandish Pakistan's nuclear arsenal; and more
Donald Trump, center, shakes hands with Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan (right) and Azerbaijan President Ilham Aliyev, Asim Munir. Welcome back to another edition of My Take 5, your weekly wrap of top international news. It's been a blockbuster week and here are the stories we are covering this week. Trump and Putin are about to meet in Alaska, Azerbaijan and Armenia sign a peace deal, a concert riot in Poland with possible geopolitical consequences, Munir's nuclear sabre-rattling, and Netanyahu's push to take over Gaza city. So let's get to it: Trump-Putin meet: The biggest global international story is certainly the Alaska summit between Trump and Putin today. Missing at the table will be Zelenskyy and European representation. Trump has described the meeting as a 'feel-out' to see if Putin is serious about a ceasefire in Ukraine. He has also threatened serious consequences if Putin refuses to end the war in Ukraine. But this isn't the first time Trump has signalled tough measures only to not follow through. So, big question marks remain over the outcome of the summit. From the Ukrainian perspective, certain things are clear. First, Russia must agree to a ceasefire. Any negotiations over territorial issues or a final peace deal must include Ukraine's participation. That Ukraine will only negotiate on territorial issues on the basis of the current contact line. There is no question of legally recognising the Russian-occupied territories – forbidden under the Ukrainian constitution. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Seniors are going crazy for these comfy, stylish, easy-on shoes Ultra-Comfortable Shoes Undo And there is no chance of demilitarisation of Ukraine or pullback of Ukrainian forces from areas they currently control in the four provinces of Donetsk, Luhansk, Zaporizhzhia and Kherson. These positions were firmed up in the pre-summit meet between Zelenskyy and European partners, and between them and Trump. Trump, on his part, has said that he will prioritise a ceasefire in his talks with Putin. But it's still not known what terms will Putin actually put forward. According to some commentators, Putin has two gaols in mind – either get Ukraine to give up Donetsk and Luhansk and withdraw from Ukrainian-controlled areas of Kherson and Zaporizhzhia plus permanently close Nato's door to Ukraine; or convince Trump to stop supplying military aid to Ukraine in total. Trump has already stated that Nato membership for Ukraine is off the table. But the Europeans have insisted that Russia can't be allowed to dictate Nato membership. Trump, however, appears to have accepted security guarantees for Ukraine which, at the moment, appears to be taking the shape of a multi-nation reassurance force once ceasefire or peace takes hold. But the bottomline is that a deal that does not take into account Ukraine's sovereign interests and seems to reward the aggressor simply won't hold. Tens of thousands of Ukrainians have had to evacuate from Russian-occupied territories, leaving behind their home and hearth. Russians are taking over their properties. This internally displaced population in Ukraine will never accept an unjust peace and force future Ukrainian dispensations to reclaim their homes through covert and overt security measures. In any case, peace won't hold then. Plus, what is the guarantee that Russia won't use the occupied territories to launch future aggression against Ukraine, just as it did from occupied Crimea in 2022? So these are very complicated issues. Ukraine has lost and sacrificed its best and bravest in this war. The people of Ukraine want justice. They won't allow Zelenskyy to settle for less. Concert riots in Poland: In an unfortunate incident, Poland is expelling 63 people, including 57 Ukrainians and six Belarusians, after concert riots in Warsaw. More than 100 people were detained following the performance of hugely popular Belarusian rapper Max Korzh. The concert turned into chaos after concert-goers got into fights with security guards. But a parallel controversy erupted when some of the concert-goers displayed flags of the World War II-era Ukrainian Insurgent Army (UPA). The UPA was a Ukrainian resistance force that fought against the Soviets, Nazis and Polish resistance groups for Ukraine's independence. But in Poland, the UPA is associated with the Volyn massacre, a dark chapter in Ukraine-Poland history. Although the people accused of carrying the UPA flag have apologised, as has Ukraine's ambassador to Poland, the incident is likely to be exploited by Russia to sow discord between Ukraine and Poland. Warsaw, after all, has stood steadfast in supporting Ukraine throughout the war, taking in vast numbers of displaced Ukrainians, and coordinating military aid to Ukraine. Moscow, therefore, would like nothing more than to disrupt this solidarity. Polish PM Donald Tusk has already warned against this. In the current geopolitical moment, Poland and Ukraine have no choice but to avoid bilateral controversies and stand together, Armenia-Azerbaijan deal: In a hugely significant deal that sees the US expand its interests in the Caspian Sea region, leaders of Armenia and Azerbaijan signed a peace treaty in the presence of Trump to effectively end their 35-year-old conflict. It will be recalled that Armenia and Azerbaijan relations have been bedevilled by two competing territorial issues – access to Azerbaijan's Nakhchivan exclave through Armenia, and the previously ethnic Armenian dominated region of Nagorno-Karabakh in Azerbaijan. Both those issues now stand resolved after Azerbaijan took the breakaway Nagorno-Karabakh region by force in 2023, and the US-sponsored peace treaty now giving Baku access to its Nakhchivan exclave through a strategic Armenian corridor which will be controlled by a US private consortium on a 99-year lease from Armenia. Importantly, the said strategic corridor – being dubbed as Trump Route for International Peace and Prosperity – runs along Armenia's border with Iran. Note also that Russia has a military base in Armenia. But neither Tehran nor Moscow was able to influence the outcome here. In fact, it is safe to surmise that Russia's involvement in the Ukraine war, and Iran's recent military battering by Israel and US have made Moscow and Tehran unable to protect their strategic interests in the region. In fact, this has been the trend since last December when the Bashar al-Assad regime fell in Syria. In other words, Russia's preoccupation with Ukraine and Iran's with Gaza and Lebanon have allowed the US to press the advantage and push back Russian and Iranian strategic influence in West Asia. The Armenia-Azerbaijan deal further bolsters this trend. As Trump prepares to meet Putin in Alaska, the message for Moscow is that the more it pursues its aggression against Ukraine, the more it will lose strategically elsewhere. Munir's nuclear sabre-rattling: Pakistan army chief Asim Munir used another trip to the US to brandish his country's nuclear arsenal. In what could only be described as highly irresponsible statements, Munir said that Pakistan would take 'half the world down' if it was pushed to a desperate situation. That he would make such a comment from US soil tells us two things. First, Pakistan has managed a new compact with America based on Munir currying favour with Trump. By pumping up Trump's ego and nominating him for the Nobel Peace Prize, Pakistan feels that it can reset ties with Washington at a critical geopolitical moment. This is also Pakistan's way of hedging against China, whose influence over Pakistan has grown tremendously. This was amply demonstrated by China's military help to Pakistan during the clashes with India this summer. That said, while Trump might be impressed with Munir, the US system by now knows Pakistan quite well. It is essentially an economic basket case that thrives on playing all sides. India, on its part, should have seen this coming. New Delhi should have know that its relations today are with Trump, not the US government. Nonetheless, Pakistan's honeymoon period with Trump is expected to be short-lived. Trump perhaps has forgotten that it was Pakistan that sheltered Osama bin Laden. Therefore, given Trump's mercurial ways, this relationship can flip any time. Plus, Munir's irresponsible statements need to be examined in the light of integrity and safety of Pakistan's nuclear weapons. The world can't let rogue actors get their hands on nukes. Netanyahu wants to conquer Gaza: In a catastrophic decision, Israeli PM Netanyahu's cabinet approved the seizing of Gaza city. The UN and Israel's allies like UK, Germany and France have criticised the move, saying it would only exacerbate the suffering in Gaza. In fact, even Israel's military brass is said to be against the plan. However, this was Netanyahu's plan all along. He wants to eradicate the possibility of a Palestinian state once and for all. And backed by the most right-wing cabinet in Israel's history, he apparently has a free hand to implement his long-held agenda. But a viable Palestine state existing side by side with Israel is the only viable solution to the Israel-Palestine conflict. But Netanyahu doesn't see it that way. He used Israeli military operations in Gaza to raze the enclave to the ground and create hell on earth so that the Palestinians would be desperate to leave to any Arab nation willing to take them. This cleansing of Gaza is a huge blot on the international community. Yes, the October 7, 2023 Hamas attack on Israel was horrific. Hamas needs to be banished, sanctioned and eliminated. But now Israel is just attacking Palestinian civilians and starving them to death. That will only keep Hamas going. The big question now is: How long before opinions in the Arab world reach a point where Arab governments can no longer turn a blind eye to what Israel is doing in Gaza?
Time of India
36 minutes ago
- Time of India
Chinese state media calls U.S. a 'surveillance empire' over trackers in chip shipments
BEIJING: The United States' practice of installing location trackers in chip shipments at risk of diversion to China reflects the "instincts of a surveillance empire," China's state-run media outlet Xinhua said in a commentary published on Friday. Reuters reported earlier this week that U.S. authorities had secretly placed location tracking devices in targeted shipments of advanced chips to detect diversions to China, which is under U.S. curbs for advanced chip exports. The Xinhua commentary , titled "America turns chip trade into a surveillance game," cited "reports" that Washington had embedded such trackers, accusing the United States of running "the world's most sprawling intelligence apparatus". by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like The Fastest Way to Overcome Knee Pain and Swelling Wellnee Undo The U.S. government has in the past few years tightened restrictions on the exports of advanced chips as well as related technology and equipments to China, as the two superpowers vie for technological dominance. The Chinese commentary follows longstanding accusations from Washington and its Western allies that China could use some exported products, from telecommunications equipment to vehicles, for surveillance, posing potential security risks. Live Events In 2022, the Biden administration banned the sale and import of new telecommunications equipment from several Chinese firms, including Huawei, citing national security concerns. In January, it intensified scrutiny by targeting China-made cars and trucks. In its commentary, Xinhua accused the U.S. government of seeing its trading partners as "rivals to be tripped up or taken down," adding that "if U.S. chips are seen as Trojan horses for surveillance, customers will look elsewhere." China's cyberspace watchdog last month said it had asked U.S. chipmaker Nvidia to explain whether its H20 chips had any backdoor security risks - a hidden method of bypassing normal authentication or security controls. Chinese authorities have also cautioned domestic tech firms over their use of H20 chips, Reuters recently reported.
