Defamation case: Karnataka HC stays trial proceedings against Shivakumar
Karnataka High Court
on Friday granted interim relief to Deputy Chief Minister
D K Shivakumar
by staying the trial court proceedings in a criminal
defamation case
filed against him by the State
BJP
unit over "
corruption rate card
" ads.
The court also extended similar relief to the
Karnataka Pradesh Congress Committee
(KPCC), which is a co-accused in the matter.
Justice S R Krishna Kumar, who presided over the matter, issued notice to the respondent and made it returnable on July 29, effectively pausing the ongoing proceedings until further directions.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
Play War Thunder now for free
War Thunder
Play Now
Undo
The defamation case arose after a series of controversial advertisements titled "Corruption Rate Card" were issued by the
Congress
party in the run-up to the 2023
Karnataka Assembly elections
.
The BJP has alleged that these advertisements falsely accused it of institutionalising corruption while in power, claiming that appointments and transfers in government departments came with fixed "rates" and "commissions."
Live Events
According to the BJP, the advertisements--published in local newspapers and promoted online--damaged the party's public image. The BJP has termed the Congress's claims as entirely fabricated and "born out of fanciful imagination."
Of particular contention is the Congress party's reference to the then BJP-led state government as a "trouble engine Sarkar", a wordplay on the BJP or NDA's self-description as a "double engine Sarkar." The BJP has argued that this was a deliberate attempt to ridicule and tarnish the party's image ahead of crucial polls.
The complaint specifically names D K Shivakumar, in his capacity as KPCC President, and
Siddaramaiah
, then the Leader of Opposition, as the individuals responsible for commissioning and approving the advertisements.
It also claims that
Rahul Gandhi
amplified the alleged defamatory content by posting it on his 'X' (formerly Twitter) account.
Earlier this year, in January, the High Court had granted a similar interim stay on the trial proceedings against Rahul Gandhi in connection with the same case.
Senior Advocate K Shashi Kiran Shetty and Advocate Surya Mukundaraj appeared on behalf of Shivakumar. The KPCC was represented by Advocates S A Ahamed and Sanjay B Yadav.
The matter is expected to come up next on July 29, when the High Court will further examine the validity of the defamation proceedings initiated by the BJP.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hindu
14 minutes ago
- The Hindu
Madhav takes over as Andhra Pradesh BJP president, vows to carry forward party's legacy
P.V.N. Madhav officially assumed charge as BJP State president here on Wednesday amid a grand rally that witnessed participation from party workers and leaders across the State. The event coincided with the ABVP Foundation Day. The rally began at Tummalapalli Kalakshetram, where Mr. Madhav paid floral tributes at Dr. B.R. Ambedkar's statue. During the procession, Mr. Madhav garlanded the statue of legendary Telugu poet and Jnanpith awardee Viswanatha Satyanarayana. Hailing Mr. Satyanarayana's contribution to the Telugu language and literature, he noted the poet's role in advocating for Telugu as the legislative language of the State through a legislative lexicon. Addressing the media, Mr. Madhav demanded that Vijayawada's Lenin Centre be renamed after Viswanatha Satyanarayana, questioning the relevance of Lenin to India and advocating for a local icon who worked tirelessly for the Telugu language. 'Why should a place in India be named after Lenin, who has no connection to our country?' he asked. 'We must honour those who contributed to our culture and language. Viswanatha Satyanarayana deserves this recognition,' he said. At the party office, Mr. Madhav vowed to carry forward the party's legacy with the strength and determination demonstrated by his predecessors. He emphasised unity and proactive engagement, stating, 'Every worker is functioning with the spirit of being a leader. This collective zeal is the foundation of our movement.' Reflecting on political atmosphere in the State, Mr. Madhav said 'a decisive verdict has been delivered to end the anarchic rule,' signalling a turning point in the State's political landscape. Expressing his gratitude to the party, he said, 'I consider the post as a matter of great honour, and I will strive to uphold its dignity through dedicated service.' Mr. Madhav emphasised unity and strengthening of the party at the grassroot. 'Every karyakarta should feel like they are the president. We will move forward with discipline and national spirit,' he said. Recalling his ABVP roots, Mr. Madhav said it was meaningful to assume responsibilities on the ABVP Foundation Day. Outgoing president Daggubati Purandeswari expressed confidence that under Mr. Madhav's leadership, the party would grow stronger. 'The appointment of Mr. Madhav has already generated positive vibrations among party ranks. He will lead the BJP to greater heights in the State,' she said. Senior leaders, including Somu Veerraju, P. Vishnu Kumar Raju, Lanka Dinakar, N. Ramakrishna Reddy, V. Narayana Reddy, G. Sitaram Anjaneya Chowdhary, and B. Shivannarayana were present.
United News of India
24 minutes ago
- United News of India
Centre stood by Himachal in the past and will continue to do so: Nadda
Shimla, July 9 (UNI) BJP National President and Union Minister Jagat Prakash Nadda today visited the rain-ravaged areas of Mandi district of Himachal Pradesh due to the monsoon. The party chief visited areas that suffered major damage due to heavy rains including Nachan, Pangliur, Baga, Sainj, and Thunag. He met people who had lost 100 percent of their homes and land, some had even lost their parents and family members in the disaster. He also visited relief camps housing the affected people. Talking to the media, Nadda said he has been consistently visiting Himachal Pradesh during times of disaster, offering support and solidarity. "Recent destruction caused by rains is distressing. It has caused damage in the state, especially causing loss to life, property, and livestock. Many villages have been rendered and many places I visited have suffered huge losses," he lamented. If any political party was the first to provide relief to the public, it was the BJP, he claimed, adding that with the support of the public, various service centres were being operated, and the BJP played a leading role in quickly collecting and distributing food and daily necessities to the victims. Nadda emphasised that the Government of India has always been prompt in providing relief and financial assistance to Himachal Pradesh. "Our sentiments are with the affected people. BJP, headed by state president Rajeev Bindal and supervised by Leader of Opposition Jai Ram Thakur, is spearheading in relief work in Himachal. We are ensuring that no one is left in pain," he said. As far as relief from the centre is concerned under the leadership of PM Narendra Modi, immediate and time-bound assistance has been provided time and again. Recalling the 2023 disaster, Nadd said he had visited Himachal thrice during that period and ensured that assistance worth Rs 3,146 crore was delivered to the state through the central government. Currently in the wake of the disaster, Home Minister Amit Shah has released Rs 2006 crore as disaster relief for rehabilitation and reconstruction on the basis of assessment. "As a representative of Central Government I would like to assure the people of the state that the Centre is committed to give more than the rightful funds for relief work. I urge the state government to implement the relief and rehabilitation effectively as earlier there were reports of weak implementation in relief work, despite the fact that there were adequate funds," he said. UNI XC SSP
The Hindu
29 minutes ago
- The Hindu
Turbulent history: lessons from the dark days of Emergency
April 1976 was a month with long nights and no dawns. Fear hung in the air. There had been reports of an impending doom in Delhi, when a bulldozer would arrive at people's doorstep, demolishing all that they had earned, nursed and nurtured for generations. The worst apprehensions soon came true. 'Early on the morning of 13 April 1976, a rusty old bulldozer wheezed and creaked down Asaf Ali Road towards Turkman Gate...', John Dayal and Ajoy Bose documents in For Reasons of State: Delhi Under Emergency (India Viking/2018). Kalan Mahal, Turkman Gate, Dujana House all bore the brunt of the machine that spared no brick and mortar structure in its way. As the bulldozer demolished houses that had stood there for generations, a million dreams were crushed. Clearly shaken, women and children soon climbed on to the waiting trucks as commanded by a lower level functionary of the DDA to literally start life from scratch in Nand Nagri, Trilokpuri, Seelampur, and Ranjit Nagar — places they did not know existed. The men protested, some loudly, most feebly. Many held Jagmohan, the DDA chairman, to be the villain. Others felt Rukhsana Sultana, the enthusiastic proponent of coercive family planning programme to be responsible. She, after all, had Sanjay Gandhi's ear. A few turned to Subhadra Joshi, the local MP of the Congress. Most knew it was the doing of one man: Sanjay Gandhi. No one had the courage to say so. Finally, a thousand residents signed a memorandum addressed to the Gandhi scion, pleading for the bulldozer action to be halted. Mountain of complaints Dayal and Bose wrote: 'A small band of Youth Congress the prince himself. Sanjay Gandhi greeted them coldly when he heard what they had to say. They presented him with a memorandum signed by more than 1,000 people of Turkman Gate demanding the end of the demolition drive. The once and the meeting was over. After they left, the prince tore up the memorandum into little shreds. He had little time for the rabble. He had to catch a plane to Simla.' Delhi, apparently, was too hot. For him. And for the unfortunate bulldozer victims, now left to pick up the pieces of their life again. They were among the less unfortunate ones. The victims of police brutality were worse off. The Justice Shah Commission received a multitude of complaints about police excesses. Seasoned politician-lawyer and Governor of Goa, P.S. Sreedharan Pillai, who was a first year law student at Kozhikode Law College at that time, has written in detail about it in Democracy Enchained Nation Disgraced: Dark Days of India's Emergency (Konark Publishers/2025). 'Hundreds of pieces of evidence were presented before the Justice Shah Commission, clearly implicating Sanjay Gandhi and his coteries in the brutal actions in Turkman Gate and other areas across infamous and brutal torture method known as uruttal (rolling) was implemented in most police stations.' Pillai goes on to write of other torture methods, including 'fanning' where the victim's hands were tied to the blades of a fan which was then turned on. All along he seeks to highlight how the common citizen was dispossessed of all rights, even the basic dignity of food and clothing. Understandably, as Pillai writes, 'Foreign nations began to question whether India still deserved to be called a 'civilised community'.' Of course, there were Indians abroad whose heart beat for the nation. This is written in much greater detail by Sugata Srinivasaraju in The Conscience Network: A Chronicle of Resistance to a Dictatorship (Vintage/2025). International pressure Srinivasaraju undertakes a painstaking exercise to chronicle the two years when India was under Emergency rule where the author's scholarship and vast experience comes to the fore. While focussing on many of the international developments around Emergency, he makes space to talk of the challenges and the troubles of the likes of Indians for Democracy founder Anand Kumar who was threatened with deportation for raising his voice against Emergency. He also writes about Anand Patwardhan, documentary filmmaker who hailed from a family of freedom fighters, and whose film Waves of Revolution became an effective means of protest against the Emergency, and Subramanian Swamy, the 'maverick academic' who had disguised himself as a Sikh driver of Nanaji Deshmukh in India, and then on a lecture tour across the U.S. stated, 'It was completely false to suggest that only a handful of Western -educated elite were complaining about the Emergency.' Defiance at home By November 1975, there was resistance in 300 districts across India, Swamy revealed. In the U.S., there were posters highlighting the ongoing wrongs in India, seeking the help of common citizens with posters like, 'Support Political Freedom in India' and 'Support Human Rights in India'. Meanwhile, the government in India alternated between using its long arm of pliant diplomats and the inevitable recognition that the move had failure written all over. People could not be silenced forever. Writes M.A. Baby in his foreword to Sebastian Joseph's The Emergency: Twenty-One Months of Draconian Rule (Konark Publishing/2025), translated from the Malayalam by Radhika P. Menon, 'It was a dark chapter in Indian democracy as fundamental rights were suspended, the press was censored, and thousands of political opponents were detained without trial.' Then the seasoned politician has a word of caution for contemporary times, writing, 'Today, even though there is no formal suspension of civil liberties or censorship of the press, we are witnessing a disturbing trend: people exercising their liberties are often attacked — physically and digitally. The mainstream media, by and large, appears reluctant to question the powers that be.' It reminds us of L.K. Advani's words in 1975, and reproduced in Pillai's book about the media then, 'You were merely asked to bend but you chose to crawl.' The Emergency's lessons remain valuable.
