Celebs Share Dumb Reasons They Were Rejected For A Role

Buzz Feed

11 hours ago

In a 2015 interview, Zoë Kravitz revealed that she auditioned for a part in Christopher Nolan's The Dark Knight Rises, but was told she was "too urban" for the role.
Zoë Kravitz talked about auditioning for a small role in The Dark Knight Rises in a 2015 interview with Nylon, revealing how she wasn't even allowed in the auditioning room because the role wasn't "going urban." While Kravitz didn't disclose which part she was initially denied for, she said, "Being a woman of color and being an actor and being told at that time that I wasn't able to read because of the color of my skin, and the word urban being thrown around like that, that was what was really hard about that moment.' Years later, Kravitz would go on to secure the role of Selina Kyle in the 2019 film, The Batman. Upon receiving the news, she explained how she'd never gotten so much online attention and was thrilled to step into the world of Batman and bring a new interpretation to the iconic role of Catwoman.
Maggie Gyllenhaal shared that she was told by a Hollywood producer she was simply "too old" to play the love interest opposite a 55-year-old man, despite being 37 at the time.
During an interview with The Wrap, Gyllenhaal explained how she was denied a role for her apparent "old" age, although she was much younger than her male counterpart at the time of the audition. She said, "I'm 37 and I was told recently I was too old to play the lover of a man who was 55. It was astonishing to me. It made me feel bad, and then it made feel angry, and then it made me laugh." She went on to disclose her distaste for Hollywood's unequal gender treatment, pointing out the need for fair representation for women onscreen. She also spoke on the objective of casting "younger" women in Hollywood, a notion that's been notoriously present since its Golden Age, sharing how it needs to allow more inclusivity of women in all age ranges.
Scarlett Johansson was told she was essentially "too sexy" for the lead role in David Fincher's adaptation of The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo.
After auditioning for the lead role of Lisbeth Salander in The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo, rumors began circling that Johansson lost the role to Rooney Mara for being "too distracting" for audiences to successfully play the part. While Scarlett has gone on to say that wasn't the exact reason for director David Fincher denying her the part, the situation remains a little unclear. Johansson claimed, "I remember having conversations with Fincher and he said, 'You have to look like you're totally uncaring of yourself, deprived...you're fragile...' I said, 'I will, I can be this person!' And he said 'No, you can't.'" However, Fincher contradictorily stated that despite her giving a great audition, "The thing with Scarlett is, you can't wait for her to take her clothes off."
Tiffany Haddish revealed how she used to "secretly" record auditions by leaving her purse behind so she could hear why she was rejected for certain roles, some of which claimed, "She's so ghetto."
Tiffany Haddish used to "accidentally" audition in rooms with her voice memos app recording to see what casting directors really thought of her. Among the many harmful, ridiculous comments, Haddish explained how she'd hear things like "She is not as urban as I thought she would be," "She's so ghetto, I just can't," "Her boobs aren't big enough," and, "I really think we should just go with a white girl. This role should be changed to white." While never explicitly stating how many rooms she'd done this in, Haddish explained how she'd learned quite quickly what casting directors really thought of her and how she'd used that tactic numerous times over the years.
Regé-Jean Page shared how he was denied the role of Superman's grandfather in the Syfy series Krypton due to his skin color.
After being asked to come in and audition for the role of Superman's grandfather in a new Krypton series, Page disclosed how he wasn't cast because show executive Geoff Johns claimed, "Superman couldn't have a black grandfather." He found out later that the villain in Man of Steel, played by Michael Shannon, to which Krypton was allegedly a prequel to, was replaced by a Black actor in the Krypton series. Page hopped onto Twitter, stating, "Hearing about these conversations hurts no less now than it did back then," and "The clarifications almost hurt more tbh. Still just doing my thing. Still we do the work."
Mindy Kaling recalled an audition where she was rejected for not being "attractive enough" to play herself on a sketch show.
Mindy Kaling revealed that she auditioned to play herself on a TV network sketch show, but was ultimately denied the part for not being "pretty" or "funny" enough in a 2014 interview with The Guardian. She stated that among herself and other participants, "We were not considered attractive or funny enough to play ourselves." Kaling recalled the situation to be deeply "humiliating," but has since come to ignore comments about her appearance, continuing on in her highly successful writing and acting career.
Elle Fanning explained the truly "disgusting" reason she lost out on a role at age 16, and recently, she was rejected for "not having enough Instagram followers."
In the first instance, Fanning mentioned in a roundtable interview with The Hollywood Reporter how she auditioned for the role of the daughter in a father-daughter comedy, but stated that someone said, "Oh, she didn't get the father-daughter road trip comedy because she's unfuckable." Fanning recalled the comments to be "so disgusting," adding, "I can laugh at it now, like, 'What a disgusting pig!" However, in 2023, Fanning faced a similar experience after losing out on a part in a franchise series for her alleged social media presence, or lack thereof. She explained, "I didn't get a part once for something big — and it might not have just been this reason, but this was all the feedback that I heard — because I didn't have enough Instagram followers at the time."
Nia Long revealed she was passed over for a lead role in the 2000 Charlie's Angels film for being "too old" and "too sophisticated."
Nia Long originally auditioned for the role of investigator Alex Munday for the film, but lost the role to Lucy Liu because she would appear "too old" and "too sophisticated" to star alongside one of the other leads, Drew Barrymore. Despite being only four years older than Barrymore, Long stated, "I think that was just a nice way to say you're a little too Black." She added, "Personally, that's what I think. Because if you notice, there were no brown skin [actors]. I mean, honestly, I would have been the blackest thing in the film." In addition, not only was she deemed too old for the role, Lucy Liu ended up starring alongside Drew Barrymore and Cameron Diaz, despite ironically being two years older than Long.
Priyanka Chopra shared that she lost out on a movie role for being "too ethnic."
While she never explicitly shared for which role or movie, Chopra explained how she lost out on a huge movie role due to her ethnicity as an Indian woman while speaking as a guest of honor at the TIFF Soirée in 2017. She went on to share, "First of all, everyone has an ethnicity. Even Caucasian is an ethnicity. But I was 'too ethnic' for the part and it was a mainstream American part," revealing the immense discrimination she's faced in the American film and television industry.
Winona Ryder was told she lost out on a role because she was "too Jewish," and was told separately that she "wasn't attractive enough" to be a star in the '80s by a casting director.
In an interview with The Sunday Times, Winona Ryder shared how she was overlooked for a part because of her Jewish identity. She explained, "There are times when people have said, 'Wait, you're Jewish? But you're so pretty!' There was a movie that I was up for a long time ago, it was a period piece, and the studio head, who was Jewish, said I looked 'too Jewish' to be in a blue-blooded family." Ryder didn't share which film, but went on to discuss other antisemitic remarks she's faced in Hollywood as a Jewish actor. In a recent Sad Happy Confused episode, Ryder revealed how she was told by a casting director mid-audition, "You should not be an actress. You are not pretty enough. You should go back to wherever you came from and you should go to school. You don't have it."
Meryl Streep revealed she was rejected from a big role in the 1976 King Kong remake because she was "too ugly."
Meryl Streep revealed on The Graham Norton Show in 2015 that she was denied a major role in the Hollywood King Kong remake due to her appearance. She explained how she'd met the director's son after he'd seen her in a play. After bringing her to meet his father, she shared, "I walked in and his son was sitting there, very excited that he'd brought in this new actress. And the father said to his son in Italian, because I understand Italian, he said, 'che brutta', you know, 'why do you bring me this ugly thing?'"
Catherine Zeta-Jones explained that she lost out on the main role in the theatrical play, Aspects of Love, for being "too old" at the age of 19.
Catherine Zeta-Jones was denied the leading role in Andrew Lloyd Weber's play, Aspects of Love, for apparently being "too old" for the part when she was just 19, despite the role specifications being for a 20-year-old. Zeta-Jones explained that Lloyd Weber and the director of the play, Trevor Nunn, told her she was "just a little bit too old and a little bit too pretty." At the time, Zeta-Jones recalls telling Nunn, "I wasn't even 20 and I remember telling him I could be as not pretty or as not old as he wanted, but it didn't do any good."
Similarly, Olivia Wilde was also told she was "too old" to play opposite Leonardo DiCaprio in Martin Scorsese's The Wolf of Wall Street, despite being only 29.
Olivia Wilde had auditioned for the role of Naomi in The Wolf of Wall Street, but claimed she was told she was "too sophisticated," for the part. Later, Wilde discovered that meant code for "too old." The part of Naomi eventually went to 22-year-old Margot Robbie. However, Wilde did go on to discuss how agents in Hollywood should be more upfront about the reasons for rejections in the future, stating, "I want to make a translation sheet for Hollywood that's all the feedback your agents give you and what it really means.'
James McAvoy shared that he's lost many roles due to his 5'7" height making him "too short" for certain parts.
While discussing some of his struggles as an actor in an interview with Telegraph, McAvoy shared, "As a shorter man, I sometimes get told I'm too short for a role. Or even when I get a role, I'm made to feel like, well, of course, we're going to have to do something about that… because nobody would believe [the character] would be with someone like her." He spoke about a time on set when an female actor claimed he was "too short" to ever play opposite of her in a film, however, he did not reveal any names or projects.
Lastly, Reese Witherspoon stated she's lost various roles due to the fact that she's "too smart" for certain parts, among other ridiculous reasons.
Witherspoon told Harper's Bazaar that she'd once been declined for a role because she was simply "too smart" to play a female heroine in a movie. She went on to say how for Hollywood roles, "I was always considered TOO something. Too short. Too feisty. Too energetic. I once got told I seemed too smart to play a young female character." However, Witherspoon has a fairly optimistic approach and mindset, explaining, "Sometimes the universe is protecting you from a bad job or a toxic relationship," she said. "So remember next time you fail at something or someone leaves you heartbroken... let yourself be sad, grieve what didn't happen for a minute but move ON. Better things are waiting for you."
Know any more actors who've been denied roles for ridiculous reasons? Share in the comments down below!